Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Ages and Stages › The Childhood Years › Question for those with an 'open fridge' policy
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Question for those with an 'open fridge' policy  

post #1 of 22
Thread Starter 
What do you do when you have a really really picky eater? I need help!

Some background: I do not force any food on my children, and respect their food choices whatever they may be. At home their choices are pretty good - lots of fruit, cut up veggies available in the fridge, cheese, yogurt, etc. I do, however, keep some snack foods around because they are handy for taking with us when we go out. I try to keep these as healthy as possible too, but still, they are snack foods...granola bars, rice crackers, whole wheat graham crackers, dried fruit, trail mix, spelt pretzels, that sort of thing.

My dd has done beautifully with this system, eats a wide variety of foods, and doesn't overdo the more 'snacky' carbohydrate-type foods. Ds (3), however, is the problem. I can usually get something decent into him in the AM, like oatmeal or scrambled eggs, but after that all he wants to eat are the snack foods (mostly the carb foods) and fruit. Some days this works, but other days he has complete meltdowns because (I think) he simply hasn't eaten enough. He doesn't want any of our food, and so he just doesn't eat. Or, he'll wait until we meet up with friends and mooch off of their carb snack foods. I really think he's not getting enough protein sometimes, in which case we get meltdowns.

So, my question is, how can I continue to respect his food choices when, IMO, he often doesn't eat a balanced diet? And even if I eliminate the carb-heavy snacks from our house, he's still going to get plenty from our friends (we have always shared food when out and about). Help!!!!
post #2 of 22
will he eat soups? My kids really love when I make cream of veggies soups and give them to them in tiny little cups, or with short fat straws. I think sometimes kids just dno't want to have to sit down and eat a meal. I try to do this when we are outside and they don't want to come in.
post #3 of 22
I don't have any advice because I am going through the exact same thing: I'm desperate to get my son to eat, he is so cranky and miserable all day because he won't eat. Yesterday was so bad I cried for an hour after he finally fell asleep. Sorry, just wanted to commiserate and look for advice.
post #4 of 22
What about yogurts and string cheese? These are snacky things that have protein.

The squeeze yogurts can be frozen, and then are more *fun.*

For awhile when my kids were little I would read picture books to them during lunch. That way they would sit down and eat some real food.
post #5 of 22
This may be oldfashined or not up your alley, but we have a one bite rule. DD is 2.5, not a super picky eater but likes to stick with what she already knows. She can eat as much as she wants, but she has to take one bite of everything on her plate before she can have seconds of anything. She doesn't even have to swallow the bite, she just has to taste everything.

I know this is coercing, but I'm hoping to save my daughter from my own picky eating curse. I was never made to try anything new when I was a kid and I'm still trying to get over my aversion to unknown foods. I feel like a two year old when I think of the list of foods I "don't like" but have not even tasted .
post #6 of 22
My 4 year old has SID and is a horrible eater. He would live off PediaSure if I'd let him.

We have an open fridge policy as well, our problem is that my son chooses NOT to eat, ever.

I've been reading an excellent book called "Just Take A Bite" that does an excellent job of addressing eating aversions and all of the sensory steps necessary for a child to eventually try and choose a new food. It's totally non-coersive, but has lots of activites and games you can play with your child that help them move through the steps necessary to tolerate and eventually choose new foods. Anyway, I highly recommend it for anyone with a picky eater. My son goes beyond picky and I can already see great progress in his diet!
post #7 of 22
Well I don't keep much unhealthy food in the house, and what I do keep I either consider fair game (like I buy limited supply of sugar-filled yogourts, and once she eats them they're all gone til I get them again), or I put it up high so it's not part of the 'open fridge' policy.

That said my child has been living on peanut butter sandwiches and not much else lately, she has suddenly gone off EVERYTHING else. So maybe I'm not the one to ask...
post #8 of 22
I guess we have a semi open fridge policy. We designated one of the little boxes on the fridge door to be DDs "snack place" I put a few things there in the morning and top up as required.

DD is not so much a picky eater, she will eat quite a variety of things, she just eats very little most days. Anyway it solved our problems with wanting multiple "treat" items in a day as I just put one in her snack box along with other things. For her knowing she can eat it whenever seems to be the key.

It's also working well for not getting to much stuff left out, she's quite good at "putting in my snack place for later", even if it is often her whole meal

DD is 3 and we've been doing this for about 6 months
post #9 of 22
I second the string cheese and stonyfield farm squeeze yogurts. Also almonds and cashews. They are a protein staple in our house. And thankfully he will eat meat at dinner.

What I do is if he asks for a snack (he will usually ask for pretzels or crackers) I give him the crackers or pretzels on a plate, with a cheese stick or pile of nuts next to it, and a few pieces of fruit. As long as the food he originally asked for is on the plate, he accepts it readily, and usually ends up eating the protein food with it.
post #10 of 22
Quote:
Originally Posted by mistymama View Post
We have an open fridge policy as well, our problem is that my son chooses NOT to eat, ever.

I've been reading an excellent book called "Just Take A Bite" that does an excellent job of addressing eating aversions and all of the sensory steps necessary for a child to eventually try and choose a new food. It's totally non-coersive, but has lots of activites and games you can play with your child that help them move through the steps necessary to tolerate and eventually choose new foods. Anyway, I highly recommend it for anyone with a picky eater. My son goes beyond picky and I can already see great progress in his diet!
Thanks- I'm going tocheck this out. That's exactly the problem, my son chooses not to eat and I don't know why.
post #11 of 22
Mere, we have an open-fridge policy, and I think it's worked out fine. For a while this summer, I felt like DD wasn't making great food choices. We printed out a food chart off (I think) Nick Jr.'s website. It lists how many servings per day she's supposed to have of dairy, protein, grains, etc. It also gives examples of each food category. It's been working pretty well for us, because it's not me being the "mean mommy." It puts more responsibility on my DD for her food choices, and she's totally cool with having, say, a dairy bedtime snack because she sees on her chart she hasn't had enough dairy for the day.

I don't know if this is something that would work for your son, because my DD's always been fairly open to different foods. But I'm just throwing it out there because it's worked for us.

Good luck!
post #12 of 22
This is probably not going to be popular, and I know you asked about those with an open-fridge policy (which we don't do yet), but I really don't think it's authoritarian to guide a 3yo's food choices. I think three is way too young for the responsibility of choosing from the entire universe of food.

I feed my child when he asks, but I give him two or three choices -- things I know he NEEDS to eat. If he needs protein, I offer cheese or peanut butter. If he's needing carbs, I offer cereal or something like that. I give him a few options and let him pick.

At three, he is not capable of responsibly choosing to balance his own diet -- he's going to decide based on taste or pretty packaging. So our fridge door is closed to him for now. I think by the time he is 4 or 5, we will re-evaluate this, but for now, I think it is kinder to guide his decision making so that he can be healthier and feel better and learn what a proper day's nutrition looks like.

I do like the food chart idea for older kids -- but my 3yo is not yet sophisticated enough to really understand something like that.
post #13 of 22
Quote:
Originally Posted by moonshoes View Post
Thanks- I'm going tocheck this out. That's exactly the problem, my son chooses not to eat and I don't know why.
Does he have sensory issues?
post #14 of 22
Quote:
Originally Posted by 425lisamarie View Post
will he eat soups? My kids really love when I make cream of veggies soups and give them to them in tiny little cups, or with short fat straws. I think sometimes kids just dno't want to have to sit down and eat a meal. I try to do this when we are outside and they don't want to come in.

I am going to try this! I think my dd would love it I also remember seeing some bowls with build in straws at the grocery store (I think they were supposed to be for cereal - so you can drink up the milk)
post #15 of 22
I generally allow my dd to choose what she will eat. She would eat a full box of cereal in one day though so I feel okay putting some limits.

When my dd will only eat one kind of food and it is a snack item then I will flat out tell her (a) snack food is not an option if she refuses to eat regular meals (that goes for other people's food too) -or- (b) that she has had her limit of xyz (she is told the amount she can have in advance) for the day and needs to choose a food from one of the other food groups now.

If my dd doesn't eat then we don't leave the house because hunger is a major tantrum trigger for her. She is hideous to be around when she is too hungry and at that point won't be reasoned with. She'll even refuse to eat anything at that point.

I guess I feel it is nice to have a totally open fridge policy but if the choices your very young child are making are having an adverse affect on his well being than I think you should step in and give guidance and some limits.
post #16 of 22
Quote:
Originally Posted by HoneymoonBaby View Post
This is probably not going to be popular, and I know you asked about those with an open-fridge policy (which we don't do yet), but I really don't think it's authoritarian to guide a 3yo's food choices. I think three is way too young for the responsibility of choosing from the entire universe of food.

I feed my child when he asks, but I give him two or three choices -- things I know he NEEDS to eat. If he needs protein, I offer cheese or peanut butter. If he's needing carbs, I offer cereal or something like that. I give him a few options and let him pick.

At three, he is not capable of responsibly choosing to balance his own diet -- he's going to decide based on taste or pretty packaging. So our fridge door is closed to him for now. I think by the time he is 4 or 5, we will re-evaluate this, but for now, I think it is kinder to guide his decision making so that he can be healthier and feel better and learn what a proper day's nutrition looks like.

I do like the food chart idea for older kids -- but my 3yo is not yet sophisticated enough to really understand something like that.
BUT if you have a picky eater, who just really isn't interested in eating, this does not work.
The kid will just not eat. And then be a melting down disaster.

And some kids have valid sensory issues behind their selective eating choices, and it would be pretty insensitive not to respect that.


Getting my son to eat is the hardest thing that I have to do as his parent. Because he borders on being a resistant eater...and would rather play than eat. And would go days without eating if he wasn't allowed to choose what he eats. (we have only health food in our house...no sugar AT ALL)

I really hope my next one isn't like this...from what I have seen it is usually only one kid in the family who is like this. I don;t know what I would do with 2 of them :

To the OP the only advice I can offer is don't turn it into a power struggle or something that is forced. Try not to let him see that it can be stressful for you when he wont eat.

I have had several points over the last year where I have cried (in another room) out of pure frustration that this kid is just not interested in eating! It is really hard and I am trying to find my way through it. I am going to watc this thread in hopes of getting some advice.

That book...Take a Bite that the PP mentioned sounds good...
post #17 of 22
I am not an expert in ANY sense of the word, but I think if a child chooses not to eat for long periods of time that is a real problem.

If you have lots of food choices in the house, and foods that he LIKES available to him, and he doesn't eat, I would be looking for another problem maybe.

Maybe you aren't keeping the sorts of foods he likes in the house?

I know, I know - my DS is very picky. But all I do is, if it really irks me to have a certain food in the house, I don't always keep it stocked. Beyond that he eats whatever he wants in the house.

I think kids are much better at knowing what they need and knowing what they should eat than the rest of us who have been exposed to mainstream science and diet ideas are... JMHO.
post #18 of 22
If he really likes carbs, why not incorporate protein and carbs? My kids LOVE triscuits with cheese melted on them. They also like to dip apples in pnut butter or celery sticks with pnut butter and raisins. Or how about pnut butter and crackers?

Also, how about making a list of protein foods he likes and another list of carb foods he likes and telling him that he can choose one thing from each list for snacks? Maybe he'll come up with some combos we've never thought of.
post #19 of 22
Thread Starter 
Thanks for the great suggestions! I'm going to try some of the ideas you all gave, and definitely the soup-through-a-straw - very clever!

I've started talking to him more specifically about protein, what it is and why he needs it. I'll just keep repeating it over and over and eventually he'll get it!

Today he ate nothing but fruit through the morning, then requested a cheese sandwich around noon but after eating some grapes declared himself 'too full' to eat the sandwich. I told him fine, but that I was going to bring his sandwich, a yogurt, and some almonds to the park and that he would need to eat some of one of those things before he had other snacks. He wasn't too happy about it, but eventually did eat the cheese sandwich. That got us through the afternoon anyway!
post #20 of 22
My son has a bunch of food intolerances so a lot of "healthy" foods are off limits, and I really have to control what he eats so that he isn't sick.
Anyway.. his problem is that if he snacks on too many carbs or sweet things, or eats carbs first in a meal then he refuses the protein/fat. When he eats a carb based diet he is miserable (as a spirited child miserable is MISERABLE) and looks very sick. I put a rule into place for him which works wonders for his behaviour. No substantial snacking between meals, and I give him the meat and fat first to eat. He eats heartily and enthusiastically at meals and is a cheerful guy this way... I think that every person is different, and some children need help with their food choices because they will not naturally choose what is best for them. Protein/Fat first, then when he's eaten his fill of that he is welcome to eat what he wants of the carby or sweet stuff (the fruit, potatoes, bread, cookie for dessert) and he is self limiting.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: The Childhood Years
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Ages and Stages › The Childhood Years › Question for those with an 'open fridge' policy