Mothering › Forums › Archives › Birth Professional › THIS is what they're teaching about birth in college?!?! AHHH!!! (vent)
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

THIS is what they're teaching about birth in college?!?! AHHH!!! (vent)  

post #1 of 3
Thread Starter 
I was reading my assignment for developmental psych. five minutes ago and almost lost it and burned the book. I CAN NOT believe what I just read. It makes me SO angry- here are excerpts:

In speaking of births attended by midwives before the development of modern obstetrics:
"The midwife who presided over the event had no formal training; she offered 'advice, massages, potions, irrigations, and talismans'" So she was the equivalent of a witch-doctor quack? She just provided magical potions? Advice? Argh!

On the danger of birth before hospitals and doctors:
"Childbirth in those times was a struggle with death for both mother and baby. In the 17th and 18th century France, a woman had a 1 in 10 chance of dying while or shortly after giving birth." Goes on to say how thousands of babies were stillborn, etc. etc. This was right after the speech about how midwives were incompetent.

But don't fear!! OBs and hospitals are here!
"The development of the science of obstetrics early in the 19th century and of maternity hospitals... revolutionized childbirth" and "The dramatic reductions in risks surrounding preg. and childbirth, particularly in the last 50 years, are largely due to the availablity of antibiotics, blood transfusions, safe anesthesia, improved hygiene and drugs for inducing labor".
Drugs for inducing labor has decreased the risks for mom and baby??

I'm pretty livid. Thankfully, we won't be discussing this in class. We will however, have a quiz on it. Can't believe this is what they're teaching to young men and women who are of childbearing age. Geez.
post #2 of 3
Thread Starter 
That's it, I just can't read anymore.

On VBACs: In a Scottish study "the risk of the infant's dying during delivery was about 11 times higher in vaginal births than in planned repeat cesareans".

On epidurals: They "provide almost immediate relief while enabling a woman to move around and fully participate in the birth with no increased risk of adverse outcomes for the fetus". They go on to cite a 2005 study which showed, apparently, that women who requested epidurals early in labor had shorter labors and no increased risk of c/s.

I want to address this in class, but I know we won't be talking about it and I hate being seen as the know-it-all or the person on a soap-box.
post #3 of 3
I have that book too! i posted about it a bunch of places ( i think here but must not have) it was so infuriating.. and my prof just said "its important to remember that we are studying the information found in this book" not the actual truth, just whats in this book. yay. you suck lady.
i was so frustrated. the rest of the book is allright though-- and has a good case for bfeeding.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Birth Professional
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Archives › Birth Professional › THIS is what they're teaching about birth in college?!?! AHHH!!! (vent)