or Connect
Mothering › Mothering Forums › Toddler › Life with a Toddler › boys peeing outside in public
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

boys peeing outside in public

post #1 of 153
Thread Starter 
Hello ... There's a phenomenon that bothers me a little, and I'd like to know if it's just me. DD and I attend a playgroup that meets at a playground when it's nice out. Very often, potty-trained toddler boys will walk over to a tree, take their pants and Pull-Ups all the way down, and let 'er rip. Sometimes, they do this on their own, and their mothers kind of shrug and giggle. Sometimes, the mothers guide them to do this.

Last week, a boy was on the swing, his mother said, "Oh, do you need to pee?" and walked him over to the tree like this was perfectly natural, and like this was the appropriate place to go. It didn't seem to be an accident kind of situation, like it was either tree or wet pants. There is no restroom actually at the playground, but there are local businesses right across the street with clean restrooms and nice staff. When this one boy depantsed and peed on the tree, two or three other boys wanted to do it, too. So there was a little peeing circle. FWIW, the mom of one of the boys was irritated, too, because she doesn't like her DS to do this and wished the first mom hadn't encouraged it.

Then my DD wandered over, despite my attempts to redirect her, and she didn't get why she couldn't do it, too, and then she saw her friend's penis and was very curious. That part's OK -- I suppose she had to see one sometime, but I just wasn't prepared for it (though I guess few parents are prepared for that first big "reveal" of the opposite gender's "parts").

I'm not sure quite what bothers me about the scenario. Maybe the public nature of it? The trees are near a fence, and the fence does not obscure the view from an alley, an apartment complex, and a park that is usually full of adults. Sometimes there are suspicious people hanging around. I guess I wonder whether parents should be teaching their boys (or girls,for that matter) that it's OK to just whip it out in such a public place. Also, except in a total emergency, isn't it a bit counterproductive to potty train but then encourage/reinforce peeing outside? And I have to admit, part of my irritation was that DD saw an activity that looked like fun, but she couldn't join in -- I know she'll learn someday that boys stand up and girls squat, but it felt like a weirdly sad moment for her!

What do you think of this? Should boys just fire away in public outdoor places, or should parents try to teach them to announce their need soon enough that they can get to an actual toilet? And am I just a prude?
post #2 of 153
I don't think people should pee in public generally. However, I have helped my dd pee in public on several occasions when we were not near a bathroom and she wouldn't have been able to hold it. Of course we pee outside when camping, hiking, etc.
post #3 of 153
I do this with my ds. I hope nobody in my neighborhood feels as you do. I certainly don't mean to offend anyone!

If there's no toilet at the playground-- or if the toilet provided is actually worse than going in the bushes-- it just seems logical to me. I would not go into a store because their facilities are for customers. They are not there to be the official playground restrooms, KWIM?

The moms in my group actively approve, because it's helpful in initiating potty training for some of the boys. If one's peeing, somebody else in diapers might come over and get the idea he can do that too. It just so happens that the four moms who get together all happen to have boys.

Admittedly, it's harder for girls. There have been moments on the playground when me and my pregnant bladder have wished it was so easy!
post #4 of 153
I don't see a problem with it and have actually encouraged my boys to pee outside too. They only do it when there are no other facilities around and when it is an emergency. Of course, with a just potty-trained toddler, it is usually an emergency - lol.

We were at my older son's soccer game last spring when the port-a-potty that was provided was disgusting. We usually use those if they are there with no problem, but this one had feces smeared on the walls. No way was I going to insist on my guys using that for modesty. They both peed behind it.

I agree with the pp - the restrooms in the businesses across the street are for their customers.
post #5 of 153
It's completely inappropriate unless it's an emergency. We've had to let DS go a few times in that case...once when he was just training and we were twenty miles from the nearest building, and he needed to go. We pulled over, hid behind some bushes and watered a tree.

Parents should absolutely not be encouraging their children to whip it out at a playground for no good reason. And if an emergency situation exists, a courteous parent will make some effort to shield the child from view.
post #6 of 153
Before having a potty training ds, I would have thought it was a little bizarre, maybe even a little icky. But now... absolutely, ds pees on a tree all the time, every time, multiple times a day. There are just no bathrooms--public, private, whatever--near any of the playgrounds. If there were, we'd use them. We also have a little travel potty, but since we walk everywhere, it's just one more thing to carry. I figure, well, about a gazillion dogs use the park, so it's not like there being pee on trees is because of local toddlers. (no, no, I'm not comparing my ds to a dog. ) Since it's part of hte culture of the playground, we never get strange looks or comments, ever.

And ds totally gets the difference between being at the park and peeing on a tree and being at home and peeing in the potty, never once has he had confusion about that.
post #7 of 153
That is disgusting.

I used to work with men who did this, and it was revolting, and so very very inappropriate. It's up there with ECing in your seat on a plane. NOT OK!

Quote:
If there's no toilet at the playground-- or if the toilet provided is actually worse than going in the bushes-- it just seems logical to me. I would not go into a store because their facilities are for customers. They are not there to be the official playground restrooms, KWIM?
So you do it too, then? What about at the supermarket, just drop your pants and wee outside the front door?
post #8 of 153
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by ThreeBeans View Post
Parents should absolutely not be encouraging their children to whip it out at a playground for no good reason. And if an emergency situation exists, a courteous parent will make some effort to shield the child from view.
I'm with you there ... that's part of the problem I have with the public peeing, too. There's no effort to shield, and there are often adults without children sitting on benches in plain view. To my mind, peeing in one's own secluded yard or behind some type of cover is different from doing so in a very public urban area. I was similarly bothered over the summer when 2 1/2-year-old twin girls would routinely strip off bottoms as well as tops and then walk across the playground to the fountain. I don't want to teach DD to be ashamed of her body, but I'm inclined to be more cautious about this type of behavior in public.
post #9 of 153
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by nabigus View Post
Before having a potty training ds, I would have thought it was a little bizarre, maybe even a little icky. But now... absolutely, ds pees on a tree all the time, every time, multiple times a day. There are just no bathrooms--public, private, whatever--near any of the playgrounds. If there were, we'd use them.
You're right that my perspective could very well change once DD is a little more into the potty learning and I realize how hard it is to get to a restroom in time!
post #10 of 153
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by birdie22 View Post
If there's no toilet at the playground-- or if the toilet provided is actually worse than going in the bushes-- it just seems logical to me. I would not go into a store because their facilities are for customers. They are not there to be the official playground restrooms, KWIM?
Yes ... which is why many parents take their DCs to the toilet there and then buy an iced tea, water, whatever, on the way out. The businesses in question are cafes/bakeries/restaurants, not stores. I know that's not always ideal, though -- maybe you have no cash on you that day, really don't want/need anything, etc. Ideal, of course, would be clean, safe, free restrooms everywhere!
post #11 of 153
I don't have a problem with it at all. My only issue is, why can't the girls do it too?

But then, I consider being able to pee outside an essential skill that nobody should arrive at adulthood without. YMMV.
post #12 of 153
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Laggie View Post
I don't have a problem with it at all. My only issue is, why can't the girls do it too?
Because even if I were OK with DD exposing her genitalia in this very public area, I don't want to clean dribbled, unaimed pee off her pants, or her feet and legs if I took her pants all the way off! And the area with the trees is sandy, scrubby, sometimes littered on, and previously peed on by dogs and other children -- and I don't want to have to clean all of that out of her nooks and crannies if she squats rather than standing.
post #13 of 153
I don't love this either. DD is in an almost all-boy playgroup, and has also witnessed this while looking vaguely mystified and put out. I sort of feel like the moms turn it into a "Tee hee, boys will be boys" thing. I am aware that boys often train later and with more difficulty, but still...if girls can survive without doing this, why can't boys? I dunno--I'm probably reaching, but I think this is how we get frat boys peeing in alleyways in public view, in the end.

We always use the potty before we go to the playground.
post #14 of 153
Quote:
Originally Posted by bettysmom View Post
Because even if I were OK with DD exposing her genitalia in this very public area, I don't want to clean dribbled, unaimed pee off her pants, or her feet and legs if I took her pants all the way off! And the area with the trees is sandy, scrubby, sometimes littered on, and previously peed on by dogs and other children -- and I don't want to have to clean all of that out of her nooks and crannies if she squats rather than standing.
That is why all girls should learn to pee outside. When I have taken my daughter pee outside in the event of an emergency, we have never had pee on her pants, feet, legs, or anything else. She squats and we have never had anything get on her either.
post #15 of 153
I can pee outside just fine in an emergency and will teach DD, but not at age 3.
post #16 of 153
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by loraxc View Post
I can pee outside just fine in an emergency and will teach DD, but not at age 3.
Likewise ... I certainly can if I really have to, and I'll teach DD, too, in case of emergency, but I think there's a difference between that and having it be an everyday, nonemergency-type habit.
post #17 of 153
Where I live if the park does not have a toilet, most moms will take the behind a tree approach particularly with boys. If my 2 year old is engaged in hard play, he will NOT be able to wait until we go that far once he announces. Best we go in the bushes (we do seek privacy where there is some) than it dribble down his legs onto the sidewalk.
post #18 of 153
Quote:
Originally Posted by bettysmom View Post
Likewise ... I certainly can if I really have to, and I'll teach DD, too, in case of emergency, but I think there's a difference between that and having it be an everyday, nonemergency-type habit.
Definitely. I think is bizarre and inappropriate for it to be done in an urban, non emergency situation.
post #19 of 153
Quote:
Originally Posted by loraxc View Post
I can pee outside just fine in an emergency and will teach DD, but not at age 3.
See I think it is more important at this age because of not being able to control her bladder as much as an older child or grown up.

We've had two emergency situations come up and my daughter is 3.5.
post #20 of 153
Peeing outside for an adult can mean an indecent exposure misdemeanor. Because of this, I don't think it's a good habit to get into. I've turned down people for employment because of that charge. In the industry I'm it's the same as a sex offense.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Life with a Toddler
Mothering › Mothering Forums › Toddler › Life with a Toddler › boys peeing outside in public