Jennica, thanks for the update! I am so glad to hear it has all worked out for you!
post #241 of 256
3/5/08 at 12:48pm

Happy to see it worked out for you.
|
A short sale, or a quick sale, is when you owe more on your home then what it is currently worth, and you cannot afford to pay the mortgage payments anymore. Typically, your only option would be to go into foreclosure, but, if you work with the bank and prove that you can't afford your payments and that you have already tried selling the house for what you owe on it (60 days on the market is standard), they may allow a short sale. If they do allow one, then you lower the price of your home and wait for offers. Then the tricky part is getting the bank to accept an offer, this typically takes about 60 to 90 days, so having multiple offers is good in case one backs out. So, when it's all said and done, the bank gets all the money and they forgive whatever it was you owed over that. If you are insolvent there is no tax issue either, so you walk away clear of any debt, but with a 100 point drop on your credit score.
|
|
chinakat and Knittin' in the Shade,
Would it kill either of you to temper your harsh comments with helpful or constructive advice or at least some words of encouragement? My impression, FWIW, is that she would like to honor her obligation. However, she wouldn't be much of a Mom if she didn't at least think about the cost to her DC in terms of quality of life and longterm savings when you consider the possibility that they could become slaves to this mortgage only to wind up losing the house anyway. How often do you think her DC would see her parents if they worked as much as it sounds like they'd need to, especially when you factor in commuting. And what kind of shape do you think they'd be in when DC did see them? My guess is that she is tired, overwhelmed and possibly depressed. It may well have been easier for her to stick her head in the sand and post here after the house was in foreclosure. I suspect both of you would have been more compassionate then and yet in this scenario she is trying to be responsible. JMO, ~Cath |
|
I honestly don't know anything about foreclosure or bankruptcy, other than the people in our lives that we have seen be extremely irresponsible with their money and then file bankruptcy and then get to keep everything they charged up on their credit cards. They don't seem to have any repercussions at all from doing this, except that they have to rent for about five years. I always wanted to save my credit in the past in order to buy a home, but now I don't care if I have to rent. I wasn't aware of any other repercussions, I wasn't trying to make it look like foreclosure was the best option, I just feel like it is and that obviously came out in my post. No way. Now that is uncalled for. We have never, ever, in our lives payed a rental or mortgage payment late, nor have we payed a credit card late, nor a utility bill unless it was a total accident, which happens to us mortals. I have a long credit history that I can point to. Anyone who wouldn't look at the whole picture is not worth renting from anyway. |
|
Well, I am sorry for any hurt feelings I have caused by speaking bluntly. The OP did ask for honesty, and that's what I provided, but I should remember that there are real people involved and that sometimes people have no interest in hearing my honest opinions, and that it probably doesn't help anyway.
I speak out of my general frustration with the entire foreclosure fiasco. If this is happening to hundreds of thousands of mortgage holders across the country, I can't see how it's not going to hurt ALL of us. I'm angry with the lenders for allowing this to happen, but I'm also bothered by borrowers that won't take any personal responsibility for getting in over their heads. If people take out an adjustable rate mortgage even though they can't handle an additional $200 in monthly payments, I just can't feel too sorry for them. It's a THIRTY YEAR commitment -- it's hard to imagine anybody thinking interest rates were going to stay so low for that long. Hence my frustration. I'm sure it's incredibly stressful to personally be in such a bind. I meant no harm to the OP by speaking so bluntly, I was really speaking to the situation in general rather than to the individual at hand, although I'm sure that's not how it came across. I do honestly hope the OP finds a happy way to resolve her situation. I'm just kind of astonished (and really sad) that so many people are in this situation in the first place. ![]() |
|
I disagree. My commitment to my children is stronger than my commitment to any bank. I would not go to work full-time in a minimum wage job to avoid forclosure.
|
|
Haven't read the whole thread--please forgive if someone has already posted this. Moody's did a recent survey/study that despite what they say, banks have worked w/ less than 1% of the customers now in default/foreclosure. It's a rigged system and they don't care. This is just like the S&L of the 80's--the banks didn't help the customer then either.
IMHO it is not unethical to walk away, it's unethical to promote an ARM. There is no reason why any bank should push an ARM--it's a device to trick the consumer and take their money. I think Congress should and will step in and make ARMs illegal, or at the very least capped. Just my two cents! Oh, and FWIW we have a fixed, no debt (other than the mortgage) and I totally think no one should get a free ride! I just think the banking system is at fault here. ETA I read more and saw the OP's plan--that sounds much better for you! Foreclosure isn't a good thing, although sometimes maybe it's the best option. Good luck in whatever you do. |
|
It's easy to say that "the information is out there so you should have found it", but the fact is, I had no idea that there was information that I was supposed to find. When we rented, one of DH's checks went to rent, and the other to everything else. When we bought our townhome, one of Dh's checks went to mortgage and one to everything else. So when we moved here and the mortgage amount came out that one of Dh's checks would go to mortgage and one to everything else, it didn't seem wrong to us or alarming or scary in any way. That is how we had been living life for the 8 years that we were out on our own and it had been going fine. Only recently has that other check of Dh's not been covering all of our other expenses. The crazy thing is that Dh makes more now than ever before (I mean after inflation is accounted for), so I still feel like I have no idea what happened. I still look at the numbers and wonder where I am going wrong and why these aren't adding up anymore. I'm not saying we didn't make a mistake. We obviously made a very big one. I'm just saying I didn't know any better when we made it. No one told us anything that made us worry about what we were doing. Our realtor, our lender, our parents, our siblings, our friends, none of them said that our mortgage payment had to be only 25% of our take home pay. Everyone we knew was living the same way as we were. We grew up in homes were our parents struggled to make ends meet and spent half of their monthly pay on rent/mortgage too. So, like I said, I'm glad you've had such great opportunities in life. It sounds like your doing great financially and it also sounds like you are very knowledgable about things that I never even knew that I should know or look for. But, I think there are a lot of people out there like me, and I don't think it is entirely our fault what is happening now. |
:Ditto! I love how so many people have the crystal ball of what life may throw them & you have to factor this & you have to factor that. Spare me. You cannot be prepared for any & everything that may come your way. And you can read & read & inform yourself & still get screwed. Depends on where you find the information, who do you believe etc? Not everything is cut & dry. Yes you need personal responsibility & the OP has admitted to that. We had 3 mortgage brokers lie straight to our faces. Out right LIE. And they both came highly regarded by friends & family who had used them. We could have easily been screwed. They make it look so easy & just blow smoke up your arse. I am not in your situation OP but I hope you know some of us do realize you looked to someone with the expertise (the mortgage broker/co.) to help you decide if homeownership was something you could afford. They obviously lied to you ![]() |
|
Respectfully, hogwash. It's a choice w/ ramifications, like anything else. If the OP were working, who's to say they wouldn't have qualified for XXX more dollars and faced the same scenario now?
I'm happy to be a SAHM and it ain't the life of luxury and our last name isn't Gates. We cut our coat to fit our cloth just like everyone else--we just currently use less cloth. Sorry to hijack, Jennica--good luck w/ your short sale. |
|
I think people need to remember that we're talking about a disruptive and upsetting event in a person's life, not just a hypothetical situation or a philosophical argument about the state of the economy and so on - and have a little more kindness for the OP, who I imagine has spent a lot of sleepless nights feeling terrible about this.
|
|
Being a SAHP is ONLY a luxury item if you will be able to make enough to afford dc, extra transportation costs, extra clothing costs, additional taxes, the price of convenience foods (because I WOH and let me tell ya, all these people that say make everything from scratch absolutely DO NOT work a 40+ hour week and if they do they are probably squeaking by with about 4 hours of sleep a night), and all the other hidden costs of working. |
|
From this website which was linked above;
The bank told us we had to prove that we would have a zero or negative balance at the end of each month, and then they would be able to do a quick sale, forgive our debt, and we would not owe anything on taxes. I will check with a tax advisor to be sure. How do I find one and how much will they charge me to ask them this question? By the way, our realtor did not expect to be able to sell our house in the event of a quick sale, he expected that the bank would take over the sale with their own agents. He has even sent us the form to take the house off the market when the time comes. He had no vested interest in advising us to do a quick sale. He will lose money on the deal since he likely wont get to sell the house. |
|
Even if someone tries to encourage you to take out a bigger loan than you can reasonably afford, it's always your choice to say no, and even if someone lies to you (and I'm not at all doubting that that happens, although I'm also guessing it doesn't happen quite as often as is suggested by some here), the paperwork spells out the terms - if what you were told doesn't match the paperwork, then you don't sign it. Period. If you have questions, then you get your own attorney to look it over, someone who DOES have a responsibility to you.
|
|
I'm going to assume from your tone that you've never worked in the mortgage industry.
Lying happens by the minute. To the customer, to the client, to the bank. I saw things going on that made me sick. And I got "layed off" twice because I refused to tell those lies. Just because you haven't experienced it doesn't mean it isn't everyday in the industry. Chances are good that you A- did a lot of homework, or B- had a good broker who did what they're supposed to do. You'd be amazed at how few of those there are out there. There's too much money involved in the industry for it to not be corrupt. |
| And I don't know what the laws are in your state, but not every state has lawyers involved in the process. And in those states, the process of hiring a lawyer to look over the paperwork is generally not feasible, not practical, and definitely not cheap. I know from 10 years in the business that on average we would get loan paperwork within a few days of closing. That doesn't leave time to question anything. If you decline to sign the paperwork because things aren't as they should be, you'd better hope your seller is sympathetic and willing to extend the contract, or else you're out your deposit, your fees, and your new house (and probably your old one, too). The current RE situation makes me very glad that after the last lay off, I decided to get out of the industry. |



Follow Mothering