Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Gentle Discipline › 17 mo challenge
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

17 mo challenge  

post #1 of 4
Thread Starter 
My 17 mo is a challenge. The best way to describe her is mean. She is with me or my DH 24 hours a day. She is always in the same room with one of us during the day and sleeps with her 2 sisters.

The first hour of the day she is lovey and happy. Then she starts with her demands. If we do not give into her demands she screams, hits, bites, and uses other objects that she can find like brushes and shoes to hit you with.

Her demands are simple and we try to comply. But this morning I ran out of grape nuts... yes grape nuts. She had half of mine. When I ran out... she kicked me. She tried to dig her nails into my arm but I stood up and tried to walk away.

She has a very good vocab at 17 months. "All Gone" is one of them... but she doesn't seem to care. I end up using "no" more than 10 times a day.

I let her do things... and try natural consequences... but that doesn't work... she doesn't care. Last week she severed her thumb down to the bone, just by forcing a door to close on her finger.

My other two daughters are not like this. My oldest has great manners and is the easiest kid in the world. My second is borderline Autistic and Sensory integration disorder and as long as we don't make wild changes in her schedule and let her play with Play doh... she is happy. I can go days without saying no to them!

The 17 mo has never had any examples of this type of behavior.

When she has hurt us seriously, we have to put her in her crib so we can calm down. The hair brush to the face was a big one.

Her throwing away my wallet, check book, gift cards and remote controls can be overlooked... but the constant screaming and hitting us with "weapons" cannot. Do you have any ideas on how to decrease this behavior?

I would also like pointers to get her to stop chewing on wood furniture please!
post #2 of 4
Just wanted to say I read your post and feel for you. I have WAY less experience than you, so I don't have much advice.

I would *guess* it's just a phase. I was just read a development book by Brazelton. He suggests some of this type of behavior is very normal and expected. Perhaps it's an attempt for more attention? Could you devote any one-on-one time for an hour each day and see if that helps?

I have an 18 month old, who is an only child and has just started hitting/screaming (this week!!) when she doesn't get her way. I do my best to honor her impulses, but the safety ones are non-negotioable. We're still re-directing a lot and distracting. I try not to say "no" and explain why she can't do something. (ie. standing on the kitchen chairs, yogurt on my laptop

I'll be checking back to see what others say.
post #3 of 4
Could your youngest DD also have some sensory integration issues? I ask b/c cutting your finger to the bone sounds like her brain isn't processing pain normally (most kids would stop when the door started to hurt). Can you schedule an evaluation w/ an OT or other child development specialist to see what they think? It's easier to help them if they're diagnosed before age 3. (My mom is an OT specializing in kids birth to age 3--that, plus your middle daughter makes me think maybe there is something more going on that typical 18mo-ish behavior.)
post #4 of 4
Yeah, it sounds like there might be more going on than just normal toddler stuff--sensory issues and/or food allergies/sensitivities are the first things that come to mind. Are there any other issues like eczema, diaper rash, runny/soft poops, redness on face after eating?

Both my kids are like Jeckyll and Hyde if they've had any dairy or most fruits (grapes and apples are the WORST!).
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Gentle Discipline
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Gentle Discipline › 17 mo challenge