Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Gentle Discipline › I don't know how to GD 4 year olds effectively. Help!!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

I don't know how to GD 4 year olds effectively. Help!!  

post #1 of 18
Thread Starter 
Our oldest just turned 6. We have 4 year old twins. Our baby is 6 months. They're all great kids. I love them with all of my heart. That said, four is the hardest age we've ever dealt with. It was hard with our now 6 year old for months. Now that we have TWO 4 year olds, I feel drained all the time and dh feels the same. We work opposite shifts so they aren't in daycare. I work part time until noon, then he works until 9:00pm. We don't have childcare around here. My mom and dad who did watch them sometimes are moving out of state in a couple weeks. It's not so much a thing of needing a break anyway, because when I get out by myself for a few hours and feel refreshed, I quickly go back to stressed after being home for a little bit.

The 6 year old on his own does great usually but he's only 20 months older than the twins, so he's easily swayed into whatever behavior they're doing. They fight, ignore me, try to hurt each other, laugh and keep doing whatever I asked them not to do. I know it's all normal 4 year old behavior, but I don't know how to get through it. They're 4y4m. It seems like the more I try to be calm and gentle, the worse they get. I try the playful parenting tips sometimes and it works sometimes, although I'm exhausted from it. But exhausted and happy is better than exhausted and stressed. Many times they get into this bad cycle with each other and I can't snap them out of it. They don't listen when I say it's time for quiet time/alone time/take a break/whatever. They just get in each other's faces even more. The 6 year old is starting to say now that he wants some quiet time and he'll go to his room. We're working on respecting privacy, so the kids know if someone has their door closed, you knock. If they say you can come in, fine, otherwise you need to leave them alone. They'll go knock on the door and he'll say he wants quiet time so the twins will scream at his door or pound on it and just yell stuff like "lalalalalalalalaal" or "I won't be quiet for you!" until 6 year old gets mad and things escalate. If I try to physically move them, I can only do one at a time, so when I go back up to the other one, the first one just runs back up there. It's exhausting and I end up yelling several times per day.

A year and a half ago, we did 1-2-3 magic time outs. It worked. I started learning about GD though and decided it wasn't the route we wanted to take. In a moment of desperation a couple days ago (we were leaving a friend's house after dark and they took off running down the sidewalk far away and ignored my "red light" that we say only when we absolutely need them to stop and ignored every other attempt too) I said "That's ONE!" and they listened. : Yesterday something similar happened with them fighting with each other. They were in the car hurting each other (there is no other way to seat them and they have a space in between, but lean over to pinch) and wouldn't stop no matter how I tried to change the subject, be silly, etc. I said "That's one" and they sat nicely.

I don't want them to only listen when I yell or count them. I *want* to GD them. We tried family meetings but the twins ignore it and "lalalalala" through it or cover their ears.

Any advice on getting through this without losing whatever GD progress we had made before? I yell every day and I know it doesn't make things better, so I need to stop that. But I have absolutely no idea how to deal with this. None. I don't even enjoy being around them most of the time. I know it's terrible to say. I do love them, it's just hard to be around them.
post #2 of 18
Thread Starter 
Anyone? Truly, I'm at a loss here. I don't know how to get through this and still be considered "gentle". I want to be, I really do. I can let a lot go that used to bother me. I'll clean up when they ignore me asking for their help. I'll model cleaning up and helping. I don't make them phrase things with "please" anymore because I realize that I don't always say please either. However I can not tolerate and will not sit by while they hurt each other and damage things in the house. I won't. And I don't know what to do to get through this phase and still have a good connection. We've brainstormed with them for ideas and all they think of is stuff like "listen or don't do it anymore or don't pinch". I need help.
post #3 of 18
Oh Mama,
Am I right there with you? You bet.

And I only have one four yr old. I am at my complete and total wits end with him as well, and frstrated by the fact that as much as I explain gently what needs to happen, try to redirect, explain why we don't punch sister in the head, etc etc etc....the behaviour continues. The second I offer a consequence (the toy goes away if we fight over it) the behaviour stops. Frustrating as all get out to try so hard with the GD and yet the "other way" works so quickly and easily it seems. (although long term consquences of punitive parenting aren't what we want to promote.)

Anyway, I have no advice for you, because I'm inthe same place myself.

I'll be watching here for advice. Four is rough.

Anno
post #4 of 18
Thread Starter 
Thanks Anno. At least all this four stuff is normal, even if it is incredibly frustrating.
post #5 of 18
I hear you...Four is rough. (And I believe that is putting it mildly.) I think my mantra has been..Stay calm, be kind and firm. It doesn't always work. But it helps most of the time. And I believe they know you are sincere when you apologize when you "lose it." HUGS mama!!
post #6 of 18
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by croleRN View Post
And I believe they know you are sincere when you apologize when you "lose it." HUGS mama!!
Thank you for this!

Today is better. I spent a lot of time yesterday brainstorming ways to make this better or at least tolerable. I remembered what my oldest son's teacher said last week at the conference- how he likes order and not chaos. The twins are better with order too. I worked on a flexible schedule for us today. They're pretty excited about it. I also realize that I like to be in control and I think you have to give up a certain amount of control in order to not be in a constant power struggle. I'm having a hard time with that but I'm going to try much harder.
post #7 of 18
I'm right there as well. For me the behavior that is out of hand is whining, tantruming, and running away.

All of my "tools" that worked when he was younger no longer work. Maybe it's that he has moved past the phase where he wants to please me? I don't know. I also yell at least daily and feel awful about it. This is not what I want our relationship to be! I had envisioned so much more when he started school and we'd have the whole evening alone to have fun. I've ended up relying on the TV (something I wanted to do LESS) so that I can get some peace and recharge my batteries. I have no patience with this kind of behavior.

Sorry!
post #8 of 18
I think it would be totally acceptable to use consequences if you feel that they work in your situation. If you can calmly implement them, they aren't harsh, and they keep your kids from hurting each other, I'd go for it. You have a unique situation, and your first priority is keeping your children safe. So if 1,2,3 Magic helps restore order and keeps you calm, what's wrong with it?
post #9 of 18
Quote:
Originally Posted by natensarah View Post
I think it would be totally acceptable to use consequences if you feel that they work in your situation. If you can calmly implement them, they aren't harsh, and they keep your kids from hurting each other, I'd go for it. You have a unique situation, and your first priority is keeping your children safe. So if 1,2,3 Magic helps restore order and keeps you calm, what's wrong with it?
Yeah, that. 1,2,3 Magic is gentle enough if it restores order without you yelling.
post #10 of 18
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by natensarah View Post
I think it would be totally acceptable to use consequences if you feel that they work in your situation. If you can calmly implement them, they aren't harsh, and they keep your kids from hurting each other, I'd go for it. You have a unique situation, and your first priority is keeping your children safe. So if 1,2,3 Magic helps restore order and keeps you calm, what's wrong with it?
Quote:
Originally Posted by ASusan View Post
Yeah, that. 1,2,3 Magic is gentle enough if it restores order without you yelling.
Really? What about time out not being really accepted as GD though. I'll have to think about this. It's good to know that I wouldn't be ruining them if we go that route.

I do have to say that today has been much better. I'm exhausted, but the day is going pretty well.
post #11 of 18
Quote:
Originally Posted by lovemyfamily6 View Post
Really? What about time out not being really accepted as GD though. I'll have to think about this. It's good to know that I wouldn't be ruining them if we go that route.

I do have to say that today has been much better. I'm exhausted, but the day is going pretty well.
Well, I think a lot of mothers who consider themselves GD use T/O. I consider myself as striving to be GD, though far from perfect, and while I don't use a traditional T/O, there have been times that I have simply removed a child to their room when things are out of control.

I guess that you have to consider the trade-offs. There are different types of yelling, some more damaging than others, and I think that if you were frequently getting to the breaking point and screaming at your children, it would be preferable to calmly implement a punishment instead. I'm talking hypothetically here, not knowing your situation, because when I have tried T/O, it has always been a situation where I'm very mad and usually yell along with it, but have used it as prevention to me hitting. But I have seen my friends use T/O in a very calm way, and in my perception, it's really pretty gentle. And considering your situation is pretty unique, with three boisterous closely-aged children, it might be that you need a little more leverage to break it up when they start feeding off of each other.

And I wanted to add that it might be worth considering why 1,2,3 Magic seems to work. Is it because they dread the punishment so much? Or is it because it's very clear and concrete what is expected of them, and it's easier to follow the rule? Also, could you just try separating them, instead of an official T/O? Maybe you could even make it a sort of a game, where you had special spots all in one room for them, but far apart? Their spot could be their phonebooth, where they changed back into Superkids or something.
post #12 of 18
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by natensarah View Post
And I wanted to add that it might be worth considering why 1,2,3 Magic seems to work. Is it because they dread the punishment so much? Or is it because it's very clear and concrete what is expected of them, and it's easier to follow the rule? Also, could you just try separating them, instead of an official T/O? Maybe you could even make it a sort of a game, where you had special spots all in one room for them, but far apart? Their spot could be their phonebooth, where they changed back into Superkids or something.
I do think it's because they are clear about what is expected of them. They don't really dislike timeout. And we never did it where you just keep taking them back if they didn't stay. If they didn't stay, we sat with them and hugged them and talked with them.

I did end up giving a timeout a few minutes ago. The twins were both at fault, hurting each other. I said "We use kind touches. Gentle please." and they kept at it, both crying and saying "You're bad." to their brother. I told them it's okay to be mad and say they're mad, but not okay to hurt someone. It continued. I tried some playful parenting stuff but they were stuck in this fight. So I said "That's 1. If I get to 3, you have a timeout." I quickly got to 3. I took one to the upstairs landing and said he needed to stay there until he could play gently. I took the other one to the downstairs landing and said the same thing. He punched me. : I just repeated what I said and walked back upstairs. The one upstairs kicked the wall a few times. A few minutes later I went to get each of them and held them and said that our family rule is to use kind words, kind tones and kind touches. I repeated that you can be mad, but may not hurt. I hugged them and asked if they were ready to play gently and that was that. *I* feel more calm because I knew that there was an end in sight, it wasn't going to just be nonstop fighting. I felt like I was much more able to be calm and deal with the issue.

This parenting stuff is hard. :
post #13 of 18
Quote:
Originally Posted by lovemyfamily6 View Post
I do think it's because they are clear about what is expected of them. They don't really dislike timeout. And we never did it where you just keep taking them back if they didn't stay. If they didn't stay, we sat with them and hugged them and talked with them.

I did end up giving a timeout a few minutes ago. The twins were both at fault, hurting each other. I said "We use kind touches. Gentle please." and they kept at it, both crying and saying "You're bad." to their brother. I told them it's okay to be mad and say they're mad, but not okay to hurt someone. It continued. I tried some playful parenting stuff but they were stuck in this fight. So I said "That's 1. If I get to 3, you have a timeout." I quickly got to 3. I took one to the upstairs landing and said he needed to stay there until he could play gently. I took the other one to the downstairs landing and said the same thing. He punched me. : I just repeated what I said and walked back upstairs. The one upstairs kicked the wall a few times. A few minutes later I went to get each of them and held them and said that our family rule is to use kind words, kind tones and kind touches. I repeated that you can be mad, but may not hurt. I hugged them and asked if they were ready to play gently and that was that. *I* feel more calm because I knew that there was an end in sight, it wasn't going to just be nonstop fighting. I felt like I was much more able to be calm and deal with the issue.
Well, if I were you, I'd congratulate myself. I think that's a great way to handle it, and as you said, you were able to stay in control because you felt like...things weren't out of control? That's a weird way to say it, but maybe you know what I mean. And it had to be a little bit of a relief for the kids to have you stop them from hurting each other, when they clearly couldn't stop themselves.

Quote:
Originally Posted by lovemyfamily6 View Post
This parenting stuff is hard. :
I agree!
post #14 of 18
I have this on-going internal struggle about TOs. I stopped when DS1 (now 4 and 4 months also) was about 3.5 b/c not only did they not "work", they also exacerbated the situation 100 fold. He became very agitated, huge temper tantrums ensued. But now, as the aggression is continuing and taking on a new style -- just lashing out at DS2 when DS1 is in a bad mood -- I am reconsidering them. I think for aggression (hitting, kicking, pinching) they might be appropriate. I don't know, I'm really struggling as I said. But I think that if doing 1-2-3 Magic allows you to restore balance without losing *your* cool, then it's not such a bad thing. (I guess this also depends on how you implement the TO - a more gentle regrouping period vs a GO TO TIME OUT RIGHT NOW AND SIT YOUR BUTT THERE UNTIL I SAY SO.)
post #15 of 18
Mother of 4 ages 7 and under going through VERY similiar things.
post #16 of 18
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by maryjane View Post
But I think that if doing 1-2-3 Magic allows you to restore balance without losing *your* cool, then it's not such a bad thing. (I guess this also depends on how you implement the TO - a more gentle regrouping period vs a GO TO TIME OUT RIGHT NOW AND SIT YOUR BUTT THERE UNTIL I SAY SO.)
Right, that's what I think too. And we aren't having any rules like one minute per year of age or anything. More like helping them learn that when they're upset, they need to take a break, not hurt someone.

Does anyone watch Jon and Kate Plus 8? I watched the one this week last night and one of the 2 year old's blew a raspberry at the table (which I would have totally ignored and let it go, but...). Anyway, with no warning or anything, she cooly said "Okay, it's straight to timeout for you. Goodbye." If anyone has seen The Weakest Link, it reminded me of when she says "You are the weakest link. Goodbye." I get that she has 8 kids and is stressed, but I felt bad for the little boy. Then when she talked to him after the timeout, she said "Daddy said you are to obey me when he's at work. You need to obey. Try better next time." It annoyed me because "obey" bothers me, plus he wasn't "dis-obeying", simply made a frustrated gesture. It seemed like it was made into a more stressful situation than necessary. Seeing timeouts in action for every issue is what makes me not want to do them. I think we'll stick with a cooling off break for hurting though.
post #17 of 18
Quote:
Our oldest just turned 6. We have 4 year old twins. Our baby is 6 months
First of all.... God bless you

Wow that sounds tough. I suppose my question is, it is annoying you or bothering them? In other words, if my 4 and 6 year olds were arguing and weren't asking for my help and no one was getting hurt, I would use that time they were busy to make myself a cup of tea I joke, but I mean, at those ages I am for letting them work it out -- again, unless someone is getting hurt or being ganged up on or emotionally beaten down.

As for the twins bothering your son, is there a way he can wear earphones in his room and listen to some music when we wants alone time? Just make sure he doesn't turn them up too loud! Also, those noise cancelling earphones are supposed to work really well. I realize not everyone can run out and spend that kind of money (we can't!) but it is an option if you could. Similar ideas is when your 6 year old wants a break to get the twins involved in doing something they like to do.

How are the toys in your home? I think *zones* are a super idea. For example, say one four year old likes trains, one likes art, the 6 year old likes legos --- I would keep those individual interests as far away from eachother as possible so the children will naturally gravitate to their interests and the added bonus is that they will be naturally seperated ...

Maybe instead of saying to all of them (in the moment of stress) "OKAY IT IS TIME FOR A BREAAAAAAAAAAAK!!!" which doesn't sound very relaxing (I am only joking, I don't know how you are saying it lol) perhaps you can try to cut them off at the pass and suggest things individually.

In other words, do you notice any trigger times for the behavior to get less than desirable? When they are hungry/bored/tired etc -- or any verbal or bodily indication things are going downhill... a snappy word between them before it gets into full blown craziness? Perhaps if you cut it off at the pass by saying something like, oh twin 1, didn't you want to draw today? Why don't you go grab the crayons? Oh 6 year old, you told me earlier you wanted to go play puzzles for a while... while you do that, twin 2 can help me wash the vegetables for dinner ---

Basically you would be seperating them and getting some down time between them without actually announcing that they need to be seperated and it is time to relax. When you say it is time for a break, often children hear, "It is time to stop having any kind of fun" If they begin to equate down time with fun time, they may be more receptive to that down time.

Do they get a lot of outside activity? I realize it is getting cold in most areas, but I would take them and wear them out as much as you possibly can ( I realize it must be difficult with 4 children under 7!!)

I mean, does it really matter if they fight with eachother? I remember my sister and I used to fight ALL the time at certain ages (we are very close as adults!) --- of course no one wants anyone to get hurt, but at the same time, after making yourself available for help if they need it and also advocating for them when they want/need it and making sure no one is being injured --- I would really just leave it be.

Running away can be dangerous, but I wouldn't punish for that. We do a *version* of counting in situations I foresee as being dangerous (running toward a road or something with cars) where dd knows that counting means I will help her avoid a dangerous situation if she doesn't have the restraint to ya know, not run into a busy road. There is no *punishment* other than if she feels punished by me helping her avoid danger (read, not allowing her to run into a busy road).

I don't get the replies that say they don't *accept* tantruming and whining. Yes, it can be annoying and I am sure if it was amplified by three I may not be so zen but to me, dd is in control of her own expression and whining or tantruming doesn't hurt me at all above being mildly annoying (if I allow it to be).

Anyway, hope that helps a bit. Remember to be gentle with yourself and any moment you have, I would be doing self care before any housework or chores or whatever. Something has to give and I would rather it be the dishes than your self care (or any mom's self care). That helps a LOT.
post #18 of 18
Thread Starter 
Captain Crunchy, I didn't see this thread again. I apologize for not responding. Thank you for all your suggestions.

For the fighting, I do try to stay out of it. They do hurt each other though. The twins especially, have bruises and little scabs all over their lower arms from the pinching. We seem to be moving a bit beyond that and more into pushing now. Not that it is a lot better, but I can sometimes anticipate when a push might be coming more than a pinch.

We have a nice fenced in back yard. I'm terrible about letting them go out there though. We have an 8' square of dirt. When we moved here and they laid sod, we had them leave that because we were going to plant a garden. Then we had the last baby so it just hasn't happened. The boys play in it all the time. I didn't mind at first, but they get SO messy. They'll turn on the water on the side of the house and use whatever they can find (their hands if nothing else) and put water in the dirt to make mud. Then they paint the fence/house/each other/outside table and chairs/etc with mud. And get so filthy that there is no way they can come in the house without getting mud all over. So I have to carry them upstairs one at a time to the tub. I don't mind this all the time, but sometimes I just need them to play in something besides dirt. They know this, I tell them but I think they just can't help themselves once they see it. My friend gave us her leftover roll of that stuff you put down under rocks when you're landscaping. I have to find something to hold it down and hopefully that will eliminate the dirt pile problem.

Self care seems to be a big thing that comes up a lot. I'm really not good at it and need to do better.

Thanks again for your reply. I appreciate it.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Gentle Discipline
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Gentle Discipline › I don't know how to GD 4 year olds effectively. Help!!