OK, I posted above, but also wanted to add HUGS to you other posters too.
I have worked for years as a labor and delivery/postpartum RN, and am appalled at some of your stories about your care from your nurses/docs/midwives!


: !!!! There is NO excuse for that! I think birth is so powerful for some people, and alot of the hospital staff is taken aback by someone who needs to scream/roar and such to cope with it, (I have especially noticed it working in larger hospitals when almost every patient gets and epidural...they are much more apt to think that those pts that don't get one are more needing to "get a grip") and says things like not to yell and just hold your breath and push in order to "get the person under control"

:
I work with a South African doctor who said to me once after we had a delivery with a poor woman who was very vocal and had a fast labor that if this was in South Africa the staff (doc or nurse or midwife) would have just slapped her

!!! (he was very kind and nice to her though) I have heard that from more than one colleage from there about that is what typically went on there in the hospitals...the "culture" not being comfortable with such a display by the poor pt. Yikes. I think deep down we all have some sort of discomfort with screaming and "carrying on" even as laboring mamas, thinking that is what we shouldn't do and then we feel bad and suprised at ourselves for doing it.
I know I NEEDED to be vocal, myself, and was much more so with my second wicked fast labor. I could not have handled it without making some sort of noise. Just a (relatively) quiet "oooh, oooh... with dd, over and over, but absolute ROARING and screaming with ds. (and alot of "o gawd not another one {contraction}, I can't do this, etc) I blissfully cannot remember alot of my pain very vividly, but REALLY remember the feeling of being helpless and wanting to stop my body already, and how upset I was (at the moment) that dh did not know what to do with me, he was just as taken aback as I was I think.
Like other posters said, I just did what I had to do to "survive" and I too thought I would be peaceful and on top of things with my second labor like I was with my first (no drugs that time except just a bit of laughing gas through transition), had read Birthing from Within, etc. I too agree that alot of the "natural" childbirth movement does not touch on this issue, that it may be too much to handle.
Like I said to dh (regarding the above mentioned doctor's comment and after I had ds)...maybe he should experience a 40lb watermelon coming out of his...well, you know

...in one or two pushes and see how quiet he could be!