Mothering › Forums › Education › Learning at School › I taped the PT conference; 3rd grade.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

I taped the PT conference; 3rd grade.  

post #1 of 9
Thread Starter 
Parent/teacher conference the same week as the attendance review board meeting.


I bring a tape recorder because, 1), I REALLY wish I had with the review board--they were like NAZIs! and 2), because I have tried to have discussions with this teacher about various things, like things my dd has been confused by and clearing up misunderstood instructions, and have found that this teacher is very, very difficult to confer with. She will not discuss, she will only pontificate. She denies any and ALL accusations, despite virtually ALL of the kids complaining to their parents about what she is saying to them (several variations of "you're dumb, you are not going to pass into the next grade"). I've sat in on the school day on several occasions to help my dd understand this teacher's harebrained instructions, and so dd could feel the support and full backing of her mother... she needed for me to see how this teacher IS, because the complaints, frankly, were so numerous and bizarre, I did wonder if dd was exaggerating. She wasn't.

I did not bring the recorder out right away at the PT conference, and hoped for the best. Dd's report was excellent, except for one area, and I wanted to discuss this area, as dd and I have discussed it at home, and I wanted to get on the same page with the teacher so as not to give my dd mixed messages. She did not want to discuss it, she did not care what I was concerned about, she would not hear me out AT ALL; she wanted to move on, and, she just barrelled on with "I don't want to talk about that, we just have fifteen minutes. She's got this grade and that grade, blah, blah," (it's all printed out clear and plain, the subjects and the grades which I can see at a glance are virtually all As and Bs. Teacher is not explaining anything, she is just reading what I can easily read myself.

So I want to have the CONFERENCE part of this session, and get clear on this grammar question because it is confusing to dd that I correct something she is doing, when she says the teacher wants it this way (which looks grammatically incorrect to me and therefore, "can't" be what the teacher wants) and she'll get in trouble if...

At this point, where the teacher is refusing to have a conference with me, but instead is forcefeeding me her monologue, I ask her if I can record our conversation, she says, "sure, but I want the principal here." Well, now I have her and the mamby-pamby principal on tape BOTH refusing to discuss this with me, refusing to hear me out, dodging the issue in every way, deliberating changing the subject to something completely different, literally responding to calm, intelligent questions with stupid, inane remarks punctuated with moronic exclamations as one might do with 2 or 3 year olds who one is trying to distract from whatever they're focused on.

"Oh, look how GOOD she is doing on this and this! Wow!" the principal says when I asked him a direct question about the "problem." I have said, "I do not need to talk about any of these grades, which I can read; I need to talk about the grammar confusion and the extremely hostile way this teacher is responding to my need to get clear on it." They both go on harping on tangents, and the principal trying to be Mr. Pollyanna, with "Oh, btw, your dd always has the BIGGEST smile on her face...," "OH, look, her overall score, the most important thing of ALL, is 80%! Wow! You get a free ice cream sundae!", like I'm a hmmff idiot. They interrupt, and she (the teacher) interrupts me to accuse me of interrupting her. It was an episode of Keystone Cops, absolutely mayhem.

I can hardly believe my ears. I listen to this tape tonight, and I am just SICKENED by the rude, stupid, useless, trouble-making approach of both of these supposed educators. I think how embarrassed they would be if they heard it, but I really wonder if either of them could see themselves.

BTW, all of the other parents of kids in this class are up in arms about the things their kids are telling them about her, and their own attempts at discussions with her. I have met SEVERAL other parents in various social situations who are LIVID, including at least two I know who have complained bitterly to the principal, to no avail, and in one case leading to my dd's best friend being yanked out of the school by her mom who just could not DEAL with this crazy lunatic teacher and mamby-pamby principal for another second, even though the family lives RIGHT across the street from the school and the mother volunteered virtually every day of her children's attendance there.

I ended the PT conference by begging the principal to get my dd out of the classroom; that I MUST be able to confer with my dd's teacher, and he has just HEARD how that is clearly IMPOSSIBLE. And he mamby-pambied the whole thing, as if it was a case of two children fighting over a tootsie roll.

I wish the parents of previous years had fought to get rid of this teacher. I do not want to transfer my dd from the school where she has made so many good friends, where she is familiar, etc. I am preparing to fight, obviously, since I am TAPING the PT conference, and I guess I am looking for some support. I wish my dd's best friend's mom had stayed, and I know that she is SAD that she had to leave that school, though her children are both so much happier... it's just tough on the mom, because she has to drive them now, it's all new kids and new parents, and it's because this teacher is WHACKO! The mom feels so let down, and betrayed. It's awful to be so in the right, and be the one who has to leave, you know? And I get that this is how she is feeling. Not to mention the kids... sure, they're happier with the school and the teachers, but, they had so many friends and familiar, convenient routines for ALL of their school lives so far. I'm so tired of this kind of sh*#!

It's so wonderful and rewarding and fantastic when the teachers and school staff are great... and so demoralizing when they are the opposite.


Thank goodness I have the weekend right now. And MDC to talk about it.

Thanks for listening.

VF
post #2 of 9
Please, please, I know it costs money, but confer with a lawyer before you take any more steps. You've tape recorded, and now you have made yourself vulnerable to a preemptive lawsuit. If they're the jerks you say they are, they just might cause a lot of trouble. And even though your dd has made friends with the other kids, I may consider another school.
post #3 of 9
Is there any way you can get your DD out of her class? I've heard of parent removing their child from a particular classroom...is that an option here?

Best of luck...this is just awful.
post #4 of 9
Thread Starter 

Getting my child out...

Quote:
Originally Posted by SkiMama36 View Post
Is there any way you can get your DD out of her class? I've heard of parent removing their child from a particular classroom...is that an option here?

Best of luck...this is just awful.
I have tried to get my dd transferred to one of the two other teachers of 3rd grade there, but there is "no room." Other parents have tried also. It's really frustrating. So many kids are STUCK with this nutball. I found out one of my neighbors' sons, now grown and moved OUT, had this teacher and terrible problems with her. The young people who work at the aftercare program are familiar with her, one as a former student, one having heard this teacher call the students stupid as they lined up for aftercare, right in front of her.

Sickening...

VF
post #5 of 9
You need to get the superintendent involved as well. Other than that, I would pull your child out of that school, period. I know how expensive private schools can be, and homeschooling just may not be an answer for you--but that is just a toxic environment for your child.

Ugh...there is no easy answer, is there?

So, so sorry that your family is having this problem.
post #6 of 9
If you think the environment is toxic for your DD, you need to insist they transfer her classroom(write a letter, I find they respond better to letter. Ask for a timely response in writing, too).

There is no reason they should not accomodate you on this.

However, if they refuse:, you should change school or homeschool, even if it is only for the remainder of the year.

If you do not think the situation is toxic, but rather annoying, irritating, etc, you could leave her in the class.

I would work on explaining the weak area (grammar?)or area of confusion to your best ability. A little after-school homeschooling You are also modeling with your DD how to work with difficult people, which is a good thing.

I would weigh heavily whether or not to fight the school. My own belief is that fighting the system is a long, bureaucratic process. You wouild have to be doing it for "all kids" not just your DD, as it a long haul. Become very clear on what you want, and how to go about getting it.

Good luck. My DS has a crazy-ish teacher (although in an opposite way...only focuses on the bad, never on the good). I also having difficulty hearing the teacher, because I am so ticked with her, which is not good. So I am trying to keep an open mind. I am also walking a fine line - my DS is in her class, I shouldn't undercut her (and I try really hard not to) but at the same time, I cannot let him think what the teacher does is OK. I try to focus on her actions, or lack thereof, instead of the fact I think her and your DD teachers are long last twins. I also point out when she does something I think is right.

((((HUGS)))))

Kathy
post #7 of 9
I would make attempts to speak with the principal again with a lawyer and when that doesn't get you anywhere go on to the next step.. Have you tried to get all the parents you are in contact with together? maybe it's time for a meeting with the superintendent of your school system. Get a lawyer to represent you and all the other parents. Have the lawyer go with you to the meeting.

I had a teacher in high school that was horrid! He would tell us the first day of class "I don't care if you pass or fail cause you will ahve me next year. And if you try summer school, I teach that too. And at Sylvan." My parents thought it was just me for the longest time. Finally we started talking to other kids and parents and found out it was all him. I wish someone had stood up to him and his 'tenure'.

You may need to take her out for a while and homeschool while you 'fight the battle' but do it for her and all the other kids putting up with her and her tactics.

Best of luck!!
post #8 of 9
Thread Starter 

Taming of the Shrew

[QUOTE=kathymuggle;9765853]If you think the environment is toxic for your DD, you need to insist they transfer her classroom(write a letter, I find they respond better to letter. Ask for a timely response in writing, too).

There is no reason they should not accomodate you on this.

The only reason is, I believe, that there would be nobody in this classroom but the teacher and a few kids.

I would work on explaining the weak area (grammar?)or area of confusion to your best ability. A little after-school homeschooling You are also modeling with your DD how to work with difficult people, which is a good thing.

Yes, well, I've been taking that approach, that I'm teaching my dd about how to deal with difficult people... and that she will almost certainly have some teachers in the future and all of life who are just like this teacher, and it's good to learn to read people and do it their way if your grade/paycheck depends on it. And I'm going to help her out on grammar...

I would weigh heavily whether or not to fight the school. My own belief is that fighting the system is a long, bureaucratic process. You wouild have to be doing it for "all kids" not just your DD, as it a long haul. Become very clear on what you want, and how to go about getting it.

Yes, actually, I'm thinking why didn't all these parents before me fight to get this teacher out? The fact that so many other parents are feeling the same way I'm feeling, and have spoken to the teacher AND the principal, greatly reduces any self-doubt I might have had about whether or not I'm being reasonable and fair. I'm really trying to make this work, since I don't want to break dd's heart and move her AGAIN, and since I don't want to ruin this teacher's life. One wonderful FAMILY has already left this school because of this very issue... and it's sad! They all LOVED this school, and everyone at the school loved all of them until the elder child got this teacher and the mayhem ensued.

Anyway, I've got the two of them, the teacher and the principal, on tape, just making absolute fools of themselves. She is a horrific shrew, and he is a simpleton. Nobody could listen to this tape and not freak out that these people are running an elementary school.

I will be contacting the other parents... because you know what? What if my neice or nephew was going to get this teacher next year...? She needs to be stopped. I've been warned it would be a long, bureaucratic process by one of the school admin staff, interestingly, who fought the school board herself on behalf of her child, and won. It took her a year, and the teacher who was ruining her son's life was put out to pasture in the end. I actually had thought she was like all the rest, but as time has gone on, I finally heard what she was saying between the lines all this time: fight this crap. Course, she had to spell it out the other day for me to see that she'd been saying it all along, while at the same time toeing the party line in the interest of her paycheck.

And adtake, I like your idea of a lawyer to represent all the parents, and meeting the superintendant. The principal is hopeless; it's like his mind is not there. Seriously.

Okay, thanks Mommas!! You are the the wind beneath my wings on this.

Monday, Monday...

VF
post #9 of 9
I have read of parents pulling students out for a year due to a bad teacher. If it were a teaching style conflict I would help my dc get by,but if the teacher was calling her and other students *stupid*(or other negative comments) then I would remove my child for a year. Given the other issues with the school I am not sure I would want to return my child at all.
Best wishes resolving both problems!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Learning at School
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Education › Learning at School › I taped the PT conference; 3rd grade.