Mothering › Forums › Natural Family Living › The Mindful Home › Frugality & Finances › Is your DP a car person?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Is your DP a car person?  

post #1 of 15
Thread Starter 
Okay, frugal mamas, I would like some advice.

My DH and I try to live frugally, which for us means living in a small, old house, freecyling, bargain hunting, and cooking from scratch, buying used, etc. We also both WOH in family-friendly jobs. The one major expenditure we have is that we pay for top-quality childcare and feel it's well worth it. Other than that we live very comfortably but frugally, with no major expenditures. We have managed to put aside a good emergency fund and have paid down our outstanding debt so we have no debt except our mortgage.

My DH and I are in agreement as to everything frugal except for one thing, and it's making me crazy. :

The problem is that DH is a car guy. He is NUTS about cars. He reads car magazines, he can tell you every single car fact there is, etc. etc. I totally do not get the interest at all but it's his hobby and I support him in that.

I would be fine if he just went to car shows and read the magazines, but now he wants to BUY a fast, ridiculously expensive car. He says that we've saved money for things like this and we should be able to enjoy our savings. I say that is a fine philosophy for the occasional new dress or computer game but NOT for a car that will probably cost like $20,000 to $30,000 *used* and God forbid, maybe even more. It's a price I can't even wrap my head around because it would take us so long to save that amount of money back up. [Edit: Even with digging into our savings, we'd have to get a loan for some of it. After we worked so hard to be debt-free other than the mortgage, too! :]

I don't even like driving, and I think our used 10-year-old car is doing a fine job for us. We don't have long commutes and live in a metro area with lots of good public transit. Basically DH wants this car because he is a car guy and it would be a car dream come true for him.

He is very respectful and is not hassling me about it. Maybe the absolute shock that I showed on my face when he suggested it must have made an impression or something because he hasn't brought it back up. But now I'm worrying that I'm denying him something he really, really wants.

Do any of you live with car nuts? How do live frugally with a car nut? Does your DP crave a ridiculously overpriced car, and how do you deal with that?

What IS it about cars, anyhow? I so do not get it.
post #2 of 15
My DH is a car guy too-not to the extent of yours, though. However, DH also realizes the financial side of it. There's not only the cost of the car, but repairs, higher insurance, etc. That kind of brings him back to reality.

One idea is to maybe rent one of his dream cars for a weekend. Would that work?
post #3 of 15
My DH really enjoys cars. We have 4 vehicles and 2 drivers in our household

I guess I'm lucky that my DH is (mostly) content with older cars. He enjoys working on and driving his 70s muscle car during the summer. He's had that car since before I met him 10 years ago.

A few years ago DH decided that he wasn't content driving the cheaper, dependable 10 year old commuter car. We talked about what would be appropriate with our budget. After much research DH decided to buy a 7 year old sports car for about 10K. That was the most we'd ever spent on a car, and it was a big deal for us. I didn't limit DH to a specific budget, but he knew how I felt about it- I didn't want him to buy something overly expensive. Basicly, DH prioritized what he wanted in terms of car specs and prices, and searched for months before finding a good deal from a dealer on eBay.

DH still thinks and talks about buying a nicer, more expensive car. I don't understand it either, because it's just not important to me. But at this point in time, I think DH is content to dream and wait until our kids are out of the house before he finally gets a luxury car. DH realizes that there are other things that are more important right now.
post #4 of 15
Hmm, DH wannted a nice car,we bought a used 1995 firebird. DH sdid some custom work to it but it didn't cost much. DH just wanted something nice that he could sshow off and be proud of. He removed the door handles LOL

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v2...g?t=1195906845
post #5 of 15
Quote:
Originally Posted by annethcz View Post
... A few years ago DH decided that he wasn't content driving the cheaper, dependable 10 year old commuter car. We talked about what would be appropriate with our budget. After much research DH decided to buy a 7 year old sports car for about 10K. That was the most we'd ever spent on a car, and it was a big deal for us. I didn't limit DH to a specific budget, but he knew how I felt about it- I didn't want him to buy something overly expensive. Basicly, DH prioritized what he wanted in terms of car specs and prices, and searched for months before finding a good deal from a dealer on eBay. ...
I was going to suggest something along this line
~Cath
post #6 of 15
Tell him to forget new and sporty...go with all muscle.

We have a muscle car. We are a car FAMILY though. We re all equally crazy about cars. The great thing about our car is it seats 5

You can get an awesome 60s-70s muscle car for less than 10k and a lot below 8k. If you are willing to spend about 5k on something it will be HOT! You ca almost guarantee it.

Check out this:

http://cincinnati.craigslist.org/car/470040584.html

This guy wants to trade us this for our car...if we didn't need money we totally would!!

http://cincinnati.craigslist.org/car/484461895.html

http://cincinnati.craigslist.org/car/484461895.html

I might trade my oldest for this car (not really)
http://cincinnati.craigslist.org/car/453163955.html

This is our car
http://www.cardomain.com/ride/2344738
post #7 of 15
My dh isn't a car person (or a sports person, thank goodness! ) but I can definitely understand the urge. It does kind of suck that his hobby is this very expensive thing, but that's life, right? And remember that money is just a tool. So I definitely wouldn't recommend forbidding this item. He's right, the reason you live frugally is so that you can spend money on things you care about. You just don't happen to share this desire with him.

I would really sit down with him and hammer out details. Give a price range (even if it's out of your range right now, he can save for it), tell him no debt to get the car, etc etc. Allow him to find something he loves and has really worked for and he will be one happy dude!

BTW, I think it's really wonderful that you have lived frugally and now will be able to enjoy the fruits of your labor....just don't let your dh go overboard with the car thing!
post #8 of 15
wow... to be completely honest, i was surprised there were so many people on MDC who have muscle cars.... the whole environment/global warming thing. :

i agree with others who say to research what he wants and to get an older muscle car. talk to him about what he wants. you dont have to pay $30,000 for a "cool" car. (well, one of my friends did. he got a 1980 delorean. but he doesnt have a wife, kids, etc. even though i just saw pictures, it is pretty sweet. he's still trying to get that darn flux capacitor working.)

plus, these classic cars keep their value. so its not like buying a brand new car and losing 25% of the value the minute you drive it off the lot.
post #9 of 15
The important question here is what kind of car?
post #10 of 15
I'm glad DH isn't a car guy, but my FIL is. He recently spent 30K on an old restored car. He's driven just a few times and otherwise it hides under a cover thingy in his shop. He's scared the kids will scratch it so they have to stay far away from it, he's always worried something will fall on it and damage it. Frankly it's more trouble than it's worth! He's always said he wanted one, so he finally bought one, and now that he has it I don't think he's as happy as he thought he'd be b/c it just costs too much $$! It is one of the classic ones that don't loose value, though. I'm sorry I can't tell you exactly what it is, but I'm not a car girl, so I really didn't pay much attention! It's red and older and does look good!

I'd tell DH if he wants a new car, figure out how much is reasonable and find something that fits your needs and still has eye appeal. I think it's the Dodge ??? that DH liked (it won't fit 4 kids, but before we knew it was twins we considered it).
post #11 of 15
I'm the car fanatic in our family. Renting the car may satisfy him or it may do the opposite and really make his desire for one increase. I know that after I test drove our current vehicle that my desire for it just went through the roof. Until I'd driven it I'd had my eye on it for a few years but after I drove it, it was all over (so to speak).

Lots of good ideas in the thread here. Good luck to ya!
post #12 of 15
Thread Starter 
Wow, you guys are great! These are all great suggestions. I hadn't even thought of muscle cars, but I bet DH would be willing to compromise on a cheaper muscle car. He's definitely as much of a believer in frugality as I am, so I think he'd go for that. Its_our_family, thanks so much for those great links (and your car is super cool), and Sharlla, I love your super cool picture too! I feel a lot better now that I see what you can get for less money.

I think I'm going to bring up the issue of a car for DH with him. I don't want him to think I'm avoiding the issue, and I suspect that he's been mulling it over as well, trying to get to a cheaper solution. I will also suggest the rental car option and see what he thinks (though, as a PP mentioned, that might just make the itch worse)!

You guys are the best!
post #13 of 15
Quote:
Originally Posted by Azuralea View Post
Its_our_family, thanks so much for those great links (and your car is super cool), and Sharlla, I love your super cool picture too! I feel a lot better now that I see what you can get for less money.
If one more muscle car fanatic is born......

MOPAR!!!
post #14 of 15
My DH is a car and truck person. From day one of our marriage, it's been a battle over how much he is spending on his latest project. This last year he rebuilt a 77 Chevy K10 and it ended up costing WAY more then he thought it would. It's such an expensive hobby, and it doesnt help that I'm not into it at all. Right now he needs $900 for something that broke and now the truck won't run till he has it. He already has a list of more stuff he wants too. I hate that any extra money is going towards a vehicle!

Sorry I'm no help, but I feel your pain.
post #15 of 15
My dh is most certainly a car guy! Fortunately, he is also a motorcycle guy, so he is able to buy/sell/fix/restore those rather than cars and trucks....bikes are a much cheaper hobby project. As soon as we can afford it, though, he is going to get a classic car to restore.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Frugality & Finances
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Natural Family Living › The Mindful Home › Frugality & Finances › Is your DP a car person?