I am a Cricket fan, too, and I kind of hoped someone would say this. I think I'm going to end up getting her "Muse" by the Carus publishers. Fortunately, her mom told me today that she had already read all the Harry Potter books and a few of the Lord of the Ring books, so I know they're cool with that.
I'm just a little nervous because I got SIL a subscription to "Gourmet" one year, and unfortunately it was the year that it changed to "Gourmet: Food and Wine", so she canceled it. And, this same niece was my flower girl when she was three and couldn't wear the dress I'd made for her because it was sleeveless. I've been surprised by these things because my parents used to be mormon and I grew up somewhat active in the church, but my parents had much laxer standards. Anyway, I just want to be sure that she'll like it and my brother and SIL will be comfortable with it. So thanks for your input!