Mothering › Forums › Breastfeeding › Lactivism › Children's Author refuses Nestle book prize
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Children's Author refuses Nestle book prize  

post #1 of 24
Thread Starter 
Well, Mamas, what do you think of this?

I am a huge fan of children’s literature. Last year, while shopping at my favorite bookstore, I was so disappointed to see that one of our family’s favorite authors endorses Nestlé. Every year, Nestle gives out children’s book awards. The book gets a big gold, silver or bronze sticker on the front and Nestlé gets to market itself as a company that cares about children. This sort of endorsement by association allows companies like Nestlé to manage their reputation, at, I believe, the expense of the reputation of others: including - in the case of Nestlé, pediatricians, hospitals, and it would seem, children’s books.

So this year, I was impressed that the Gold Award-winning author has turned down the prize money, stating concern with some of the company’s practices, including their interpretation of the International Code of Marketing of Breast-milk Substitutes. Because although Nestlé says it strictly abides by the code this is clearly not the case.

You can read about it here:

http://www.thebookstandard.com/books..._id=1003685452


Or here

http://www.babymilkaction.org/press/press12dec07.html




I was feeling really excited about this….thinking that I’d go out an order a few copies of this book myself. Thinking, wow, I hope people really get behind this author for standing up for breastfeeding….something many health professionals and lots of governments around the world certainly are not doing. But I actually feel let down when I look at the fine print. I’m not sure that by not taking the money it does anything at all….because the publisher is still pushing ahead with endorsement of this book. A book that I now feel even less inclined to buy.

I feel a letter to the publisher coming on.
post #2 of 24
I think it's that he is refusing any part of the award. I just wish everyone would kick Nestle's : to the curb and get them to straighten up.
post #3 of 24
Well I now know what book I am off to buy for all my kiddy friends and for my future baby. Way to go, I hope this gives Nestle a lot of bad plublicity
post #4 of 24
I'd not be buying any book with a Nestle sticker on it, regardless of whether the author refused the check or not. If he was truly sticking to his principles, he'd've sought another publisher or insisted that they not associate his work with Nastle.
post #5 of 24
Thread Starter 
Quote:
I'd not be buying any book with a Nestle sticker on it, regardless of whether the author refused the check or not. If he was truly sticking to his principles, he'd've sought another publisher or insisted that they not associate his work with Nastle.
That's what I am thinking. On the one hand, I'd really like to congratulate the author for the gesture that he's made, but on the other hand, I feel I just can't buy the book with the Nestle sticker on it.
post #6 of 24
Thread Starter 
I found this contact on line for the publisher in case anyone else wants to write to them.

http://www.orchardbooks.co.uk/contact.htm
post #7 of 24
A link to the book itself, for those interested
http://www.amazon.co.uk/When-Monster.../dp/1843623552
post #8 of 24
Getting published is SO hard and I can only sympathize with the author that his publisher is taking his work and associating it with Nestle. I think refusing the money is bringing attention to the issue and he's doing the right thing. He could lose his dream of being a published author (or published every again) if he did more, and I wouldn't ask that of him. Applause for Sean Taylor!
post #9 of 24
Quote:
Originally Posted by MaryJaneLouise View Post
I think it's that he is refusing any part of the award. I just wish everyone would kick Nestle's : to the curb and get them to straighten up.
post #10 of 24
I agree. The author has done what he can do. He has a livelihood to protect and contracts to honor.

Kudos to him and I for one think any step in that direction is a step that should be recognized and praised.
post #11 of 24
Quote:
Originally Posted by Meiri View Post
I'd not be buying any book with a Nestle sticker on it, regardless of whether the author refused the check or not. If he was truly sticking to his principles, he'd've sought another publisher or insisted that they not associate his work with Nastle.
I suppose, but this is how he earns his income... you know?
post #12 of 24
I think he did the right thing. If he had just removed his book from the short list prior to the awards being announced (which Nestle say they gave him the opportunity to do) he wouldn't have been able to draw attention to Nestle's practices, because there wouldn't have been the publicity that has since occured.
i don't buy books with Nestle (or other types of junk food) promotions attached to them, and I am sure that the author knows a lot of people would have been turned off by the sticker. maybe this way he increases his sales because all of us boycotters will want to support him?
post #13 of 24
That is awesome!

How many books are associated with Nestle by now?

I wonder if Nestle has issued a statement regarding his refusal!
post #14 of 24
Wow, I think that's awesome!

Quote:
At Wednesday's ceremony, the author accepted the award—voted for by thousands of schoolchildren across the U.K.—but refused the check.
I think the fact that the books were voted for by children is another thing to consider... I can see how he is in a tricky situation, but I think accepting the award but not the money makes a big statement!
post #15 of 24
Quote:
Originally Posted by Meiri View Post
I'd not be buying any book with a Nestle sticker on it, regardless of whether the author refused the check or not. If he was truly sticking to his principles, he'd've sought another publisher or insisted that they not associate his work with Nastle.
It's definitely not that easy.

I'm not in publishing, but a librarian so I know a little bit about this. There can be years between when the contract for a book is signed & it's actual publishing date and after it's published & up for an award there's nothing that can be done with the association with that publisher.

Also, the writer/illustrator has very little influence over anything once the contract is signed. Often times, a writer can't even choose the illustrator s/he wants to work with. They definitely cannot say don't associate my book with this company.

FTR - I totally agree with what this author did. He is bringing attention to the bad practices of Nestle & targeting an audience (parents of young children) that has the most influence on them. It is also an award from the children, so even though the sponsor is distasteful, he is honored by the children.
post #16 of 24
Quote:
Originally Posted by St. Margaret View Post
Getting published is SO hard and I can only sympathize with the author that his publisher is taking his work and associating it with Nestle. I think refusing the money is bringing attention to the issue and he's doing the right thing. He could lose his dream of being a published author (or published every again) if he did more, and I wouldn't ask that of him. Applause for Sean Taylor!
:
post #17 of 24
That is awesome! They should make him his own sticker that says "refused nestle award" i'd buy the book if I saw that sticker on it in the store!
post #18 of 24
Quote:
Originally Posted by bu's mama View Post
It's definitely not that easy.

I'm not in publishing, but a librarian so I know a little bit about this. There can be years between when the contract for a book is signed & it's actual publishing date and after it's published & up for an award there's nothing that can be done with the association with that publisher.

Also, the writer/illustrator has very little influence over anything once the contract is signed. Often times, a writer can't even choose the illustrator s/he wants to work with. They definitely cannot say don't associate my book with this company.
Yup. I've been in this business for a long time -- both as a staff editor for various children's book publishing companies and as a writer of children's books. This author did everything he could.
post #19 of 24
well that is pretty darn cool
post #20 of 24
Thread Starter 
Quote:
They should make him his own sticker that says "refused nestle award" i'd buy the book if I saw that sticker on it in the store!
Now that is a terrific idea.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Lactivism
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Breastfeeding › Lactivism › Children's Author refuses Nestle book prize