Mothering › Forums › Pregnancy and Birth › Birth and Beyond › Healing Birth Trauma › Opinions on a birth trauma lawsuit
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Opinions on a birth trauma lawsuit  

post #1 of 43
Thread Starter 
I dont know if anyone here remembers my story, but I really value everyone on here's opinion and I really don't know anyone who has gone through something similiar to ask them.

The quick version: Back in January, after 3 hours of labor from start to finish (very quick) my youngest daughter was born at 1:15. Beautiful birth, all natural, in the water. At 1:30 I got out of the tub and moved to the bed to deliver the placenta. It came out pretty quick and my student midwife caught it in her hands. At 1:45 my doc came to my side to thank be for giving birth so quickly because she had to be in court by 2:30. So she hurried and left. Shortly after that, I became distressed, losing almost 40% of my blood volume. It took until midnight to get my first blood transfusion. They let me go home as normal after my 3 day stay. Upon getting home, I layed down and could not get back up, I was shaking, and couldn't feed my baby. My sister in law came to watch my newborn as my husband to me back to the hospital. My hematocrit was 7, so I received my second transfusion, which start with an anxiety attack that stopped it and they had to restart it. I went home the next day and tried to start enjoying my new baby, still feeling very weak and anxious. Everynight, my anxiety got worse and worse, i stayed up until all hours at night, thinking the other shoe was going to fall and I was going to start bleeding out again.

When she was a month old, it happened. Early sunday morning, i started losing blood like I had when she was born. I called my midwife and got whoever was on call. She said to call back if it happened again. That afternoon, it happened again, I called my doctor who told me it was just my postpartum period, to relax and it should subside. That night around midnight, it happened again, worse of all. I woke my husband feeling very woosey and told him we were just going to the ER. We got there at 11PM. 1AM I am still in the waiting room, bleeding through a blanket, hystrical that they were doing nothing to prevent me from dying, so they moved me to the standby waiting room to be by myself. At 2AM I got to a room, the doc did a quick exam, told me it appears to be my postpartum period and to go home and come back when I feel dizzy and am bleeding heavier. I asked, do you mean when I go into hypovolemic shock (I was a paramedic)? And he told me, yes. I went home crying, talking to my husband about what I want if I died from this.

First thing in the morning, I called my midwife and told her something had to be done. She ordered me an ultrasound for Friday. Friday I had my ultrasound and the tech said there was a blood clot, I would pass it over the weekend and be done with this. I spent all evening waiting, I couldnt relax, I couldnt sleep. I paged my doctor on saturday and told him I could not wait another day, something had to be done. He had be come to the hospital and performed another ultrasound and found a part of Madeline's placenta stuck in my uterus. I got a D&C and was out of the hospital within 4 hours. (WEEKS of pain and anxiety that was avoidable by listening to me that something was wrong and checking me out more thoroughly and doing a simple surgery!)

For weeks, I was anxious, feeling like there was something more that was going to happen. I felt chest pain every night. I was in the emergency room feeling like I was having a heart attack or a pulmonary embolism (That is a whole other story). The doctor prescribed me Zoloft for my anxiety and I began therapy. My therapist was not helpful at all, tried focusing on my childhood, not my trauma. I was on the zoloft for 8 months, before I felt safe to come off it and stopped having chest pains.

Now, all of this in consideration. (Which is more than I thought it would be.) Would you sue your doctor in this case? I don't know what to do. My statue of limitations is almost up. I'm scared I will go to have my yearly physical with my midwife and she will deny me as a patient. And therefore, I lost months of my baby's life being sick and I have lost a doctor I like. My midwife's student, emailed me for a few weeks after she was born, but my last few emails have gone unanswered and I feel like that is them cutting me off.

If you have made it through all of this, I really thank you. If you could tell me what you would do in this case, I would greatly appreciate it.
post #2 of 43
wow,lots of hugs mama

to answer your question.

No. i would not sue.
post #3 of 43
It seems like you could sue for medical malpractice as you did not receive the standard of care. Have you ordered all your medical records? You will need those as proof. Maybe contact a medical malpractice lawyer and see what they say. Some do free consultations.
post #4 of 43
I'm sorry I don't know. But I think that you deserve some acknowledgement and some help for your trauma.

post #5 of 43
Well, you could sue, but you might not get any satisfaction out of it. I am on another list for c-section support and recovery and there have been many discussions on there regarding suing for birth trauma. There is also a personal injury lawyer on the list. Basically we were told that unless you have some major personal damages (say if you had lost your uterus, or died - emotional trauma isn't enough). It is hard to get any sort of jury on your side. That being said, if you feel you need to go for it, go for it.
Another option would also be to report this doctor to your state's department of health so they can investigate.
post #6 of 43
I agree with the medical malpractice thought, it sounds like that is exactly that happened to you. You said that it was a piece of the placenta that remained in you uterus-did the doctor thoroughly examine the placenta to see if it was completely intact? Also, they should have done the ultrasound much earlier and taken your complaints more seriously. I would pursue it, because your persistence could keep this from happening yet again to someone else. I am sorry for your suffering.
post #7 of 43
I don't know how the law would work, but I had a very traumatic birth and you better believe that I would sue the Dr if I could. I hope you find healing.
post #8 of 43
Quote:
Originally Posted by jennica View Post
It seems like you could sue for medical malpractice as you did not receive the standard of care. Have you ordered all your medical records? You will need those as proof. Maybe contact a medical malpractice lawyer and see what they say. Some do free consultations.
:

I'm sorry you had to go through all of that, and it does not seem like you received the standard of care which is the basis for a medical malpractice lawsuit. I too would advise contacting an attorney with your medical records and seeing what they have to say; most will consult for free and tell you whether they think you have a case or not. My dad sued after almost dying from appendicitis that went undiagnosed after three trips to the ER and three days of waiting (his appendix did rupture and he spent weeks in the hospital but he did eventually recover)... anyway, the lawyers he saw didn't accept payment from him, only if they won the case so they wouldn't take it if they didn't think it was a good case.

If it will make you feel better and help you get some closure, and/or if you think it will prevent similar mistakes/treatment from happening to future mamas then by all means consult an attorney and see what they have to say.
post #9 of 43
Quote:
Originally Posted by jennica View Post
It seems like you could sue for medical malpractice as you did not receive the standard of care. Have you ordered all your medical records? You will need those as proof. Maybe contact a medical malpractice lawyer and see what they say. Some do free consultations.
:

to you. Just reading your story made me feel panicky. I hope you're able to find some closure. I would also try to find another therapist if the one you have is not helping.
post #10 of 43
(((((((((((hugs)))))))))))) No I would not sue.
post #11 of 43
What a horrible situation you were in. That sounds truly frightening. I'm sorry you had to go through that.

Personally, I would not sue. I would definitely write letters to everyone I could think of but I would only sue if there was going to be monetary cost to me due to permanent damage. Suing for money because of distress doesn't make sense to me. The money won't change what happened. I hope I don't sound callous when I say that because I don't want to minimize what you experienced. It's just my personal take on suing for medical reasons in general.
post #12 of 43
Thread Starter 
What everyone has had has been what I felt. I have a happy healthy baby. I was traumatized, but I have healed. I have even told my husband that I am willing to have more children (NOT right now, but in the future). I have not lost my ability to have children. And I really do like my midwife and feel she did the best she could and nobody could have known what was going to happen. I didn't care much for my doctor or the hospital, but I can't sue them without suing my midwife, who was the one who rushed off when I was in distress. I would like to continue being her patient.

I just have a co worker I told my story to who, everyday, asks me if I have contacted a lawyer yet. And she keeps getting into my head. Making me feel like I am making a mistake by not sueing. But how I see it, why should I mess up someone else's life. Mine was only messed up for a short period of time. I lived to be with my children. And that is more than enough for me.

Thank you for helping me justify that I have made the right decision for me.
post #13 of 43
I'm so sorry. I really can't say what I would do. I don't know. I can definetly make an arguement for suing and also for not doing so.

You have my support on this journey whichever you choose.

Again, I'm so sorry your midwife failed you. I am glad that you and your baby are okay now.
post #14 of 43
Quote:
Originally Posted by copykitten View Post
I didn't care much for my doctor or the hospital, but I can't sue them without suing my midwife, who was the one who rushed off when I was in distress. I would like to continue being her patient.
I'm confused, I thought you said your doctor rushed off when you were distressed?
post #15 of 43
Thread Starter 
I'm sorry. My midwife delivered Madeline at 1:15 and she had a court appearance at 2:30 she had to be at, so she rushed off when I was going into shock from blood loss. I feel my doctor, her attending physician, dismissed me by telling me i was bleeding from my post partum period.
Sorry for the confusion. But i really do like my midwife as a person, she is a wonderful caring person.
post #16 of 43
Quote:
Originally Posted by copykitten View Post
I'm sorry. My midwife delivered Madeline at 1:15 and she had a court appearance at 2:30 she had to be at, so she rushed off when I was going into shock from blood loss. I feel my doctor, her attending physician, dismissed me by telling me i was bleeding from my post partum period.
Sorry for the confusion. But i really do like my midwife as a person, she is a wonderful caring person.
Sometimes wonderful, caring people screw up. If you're going to sue for medical malpractice, you'll need to be able to prove that she (and others) did so in a way that could have been avoided.

I don't know much about this, really, other than having sat on a jury this fall deciding a medical malpractice suit. In the end, we decided that while what the family went through was horrible and sad, the doctor didn't do anything out of the ordinary or that conflicted with standard practice.

I wish I knew what to tell you.
post #17 of 43
If the doc had a court case, and could not give full attention during your birth, she should have recommended another doctor to attend you that day. What if your labor had taken longer, what if you had bled to death? What if, in her hurry, did not verify the placenta completely, which would have clued her that you were possibly retaining a piece or had a clot somewhere? Postlabor care is just as important as care during birth, and she absolutely should not have rushed off like that. This is why an OB (I presume she's an OB) has other OBs on call for situations like this. The level of care you received was unacceptable and downright neglectful and dangerous, not to mention disrespectful, If you can't give a patient your full attention, get someone who can.

I would at least notify the state board about this. What happened to you was wrong, and totally preventable. You can at least talk to an attorney and review your options, without commitment. But do something. You were wronged.
post #18 of 43
For what it's worth, I support your decision not to sue. I would however, write a letter and lodge some sort of complaint about the doctor who wrote off your legitimate concerns.
post #19 of 43
I would at least order all of my medical records and do some research on what the normal response to your complaints should be, what alternatives you think the doctor might have taken, etc.

to you
post #20 of 43
Copykitten> I will be honest, I didn't read your whole post because what I skimmed was so similar to my story and I have PTSD.

One of my biggest regrets is that I didn't pursue some sort of action re. my mistreatment. I don't mean suing for $ exactly, but it bugs me daily that I almost died, I suffered for 9 weeks with a retained placenta in my case, and they probably don't even remember me. But, at the time I just wanted to forget it completely and pretend it never happened. I thought I was fine, I thought I was moving on but I wasn't.

Now, 4 years later I am finally addressing the trauma and it's turning my life upside down. I have major depression and a panic disorder that gets worse around AF because of the reminders. I wish I had gotten help/counseling and taken an active stance in advocating for myself at the time.

I would recommend at the very least writing letters to the medical board. Also, what really would be the harm in contacting a lawyer? Just to further explore the possibility. No amount of money would have helped me, but an acknowledgment and even an apology from the doctors that ignored me for weeks would have been very healing.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Healing Birth Trauma
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Pregnancy and Birth › Birth and Beyond › Healing Birth Trauma › Opinions on a birth trauma lawsuit