Mothering › Forums › Health › Nutrition and Good Eating › Traditional Foods › Filet mignon! -- Give me your best ideas
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Filet mignon! -- Give me your best ideas  

post #1 of 12
Thread Starter 
We're celebrating Christmas twice, once fairly simply on Christmas day, just the four of us. And then again two days later with my mom, who can't come before then. I'm thinking that the first will be filet mignon. It's special but pretty simple, and something we already have in the freezer from our quarter cows.

Problem is, I've never cooked it before, so I don't quite know how to make the most of it. Any ideas for how to make it delicious and special, but still keep it simple? I've heard of cooking it with bacon, but we don't eat pork, so that's out.

Oh, and we're GFCF and don't eat grains (usually doesn't matter with meats, but thought I'd mention it just in case).

Any thoughts?
post #2 of 12
A little salt and pepper, seared on cast iron. Really, filet doesn't require a whole lot.
post #3 of 12
Mmm... yummy! I've never cooked it before either so :
post #4 of 12

re: filet mignon

You could just make it like an upscale steakhouse dinner -- we cook our filet on the grill, then serve with baked potatoes (I can't think of a great topping for the filet unless you cook it in the oven, then you could put the juice on the potato), asparagus with a little fresh tomato and onion on them, and some fruit salad. Mmmmm. It's 8:30 in the morning and I want steak now!
Kathy
post #5 of 12
If you're looking for a topping for the filet, sauteed mushrooms are good... or hollandaise or Bearnaise sauces are fabulous (serve it with roasted potatoes or rice and a green veggie like asparagus, green beans or broccoli).
post #6 of 12

re: filet

I second the bernaise sauce. Fabulous on the asparagus or broccoli too.
post #7 of 12
We cook good steaks (incl. filet) as follows:

* Let them sit out at room temp. (still covered in butcher paper) - you don't want to cook them cold. Let them sit for about an hour before moving to the marinating stage.
* Get a large plate or dish sufficient to hold the steak. Add enough soy sauce to coat the dish but you don't want a big pool of it either. Add a generous pinch of sea salt, and fresh ground pepper.
* Make sure steaks are held together with butcher's twine if needed (if it's the whole tenderloin (i.e., a big long tube of beef) you should wind it around it a few times (like barber shop stripes, lol). Single steaks you might want to put twine around it on the outside edge to keep it from falling apart while cooking.
* Place steaks on plate, sitting in the soy sauce, flip/dredge a few times to thoroughly coat. Turn occasionally and let them sit there (exposed is fine) about 30 min.

* In the meantime, get ready to cook:

If you are GRILLING...
- Get fire going nice and hot, but steady. Scrape the grill to clean it.
- Get a small amount of olive oil in a little bowl and a marinade brush.
- Sear steaks on each side to seal in juices.
- Cook on high but even heat (not the center, but not the far outside of the grill either) until desired doneness. Filet tastes AWFUL overcooked, so watch it carefully.
- Brush steaks occasionally with a little olive oil to keep juicy.

If you are using an OVEN...
- Turn on broiler if you have one.
- Put cast iron skillet in til hot.
- Open oven, put steaks in cast iron skillet, and return to broiler.
- Sear steaks on both sides to seal in juices (repeat for second side).
- Reduce heat to 450 and cook til desired doneness. Filet tastes AWFUL overcooked, so watch it carefully.
- Brush steaks occasionally with a little olive oil to keep juicy.

* This is important: Remove steaks JUST before you think they're done to a clean platter. LET THEM SIT on the counter for 5 minutes, covered in a tin foil tent. (They will continue to cook some.)

* Eat immediately.
post #8 of 12
I would be seriously tempted to do steak tartare with a lovely bit of filet. But that might be a bit too adventurous for Christmas dinner.
post #9 of 12
Thread Starter 
Thanks for the good information. A couple of questions for you. Do filets fall apart and need to be tied? Can they be seared on the stove and then put in the oven to finish cooking? About how long do they need to cook once seared? Do I need oil in the pan to sear them? Do you think I could make a bernaise or hollandaise with coconut oil instead of butter? Ds can't even tolerate ghee.

Periwinkle, what would you sub for the soy sauce? Lemon juice? Vinegar? Just skip it?

Should the steaks be dry when I put them in pan? I mean, should I pat them dry, then put the salt and pepper on, and then put them in the pan?

Thanks everyon. I'm a very good cook. Really. And I can manage most things in the kitchen no problem. And I can make a fabulous turkey dinner. But I feel so bumbling when it comes to steaks.

One last question. We love asparagus, so relly like that idea. And I'll probably make mashed potatoes (ds loves those, and I don't make them often). But, I usually roast asparagus, but this time I bought some frozen (great price on organic at Costco). Do I just steam it? What would you do with frozen asparagus?

Thanks again everyone.
post #10 of 12
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by spughy View Post
I would be seriously tempted to do steak tartare with a lovely bit of filet. But that might be a bit too adventurous for Christmas dinner.
Yeah, my son is pretty adventurous, and likes his steaks rare, but I'm not sure he'd go for raw. And honestly, I'm not sure about dh and me, either. I' immagine we'll get there, though.
post #11 of 12
Thanks for the good information. A couple of questions for you. Do filets fall apart and need to be tied? Can they be seared on the stove and then put in the oven to finish cooking? About how long do they need to cook once seared? Do I need oil in the pan to sear them? Do you think I could make a bernaise or hollandaise with coconut oil instead of butter? Ds can't even tolerate ghee.

Filets falling apart depends on whether or not you have a solid piece of muscle. If the piece of meat is solid, no they won't fall apart. If you have a piece of silver skin or fat running through it, holding together two pieces of muscle, yes, it may fall apart.

They can be seared on the stove and put in the oven. How long they need to cook will really depend on how thick they are. Definitely oil the pan first, filet is quite lean (hence being wrapped in bacon so often).

I have no idea about the hollandaise/bearnaise with CO. The flavor would be a little different, but I don't see why the basic premise wouldn't work. If you try it, be sure to let us know.

Should the steaks be dry when I put them in pan? I mean, should I pat them dry, then put the salt and pepper on, and then put them in the pan?

Unless you like being spattered, yes, dry them first.

One last question. We love asparagus, so relly like that idea. And I'll probably make mashed potatoes (ds loves those, and I don't make them often). But, I usually roast asparagus, but this time I bought some frozen (great price on organic at Costco). Do I just steam it? What would you do with frozen asparagus?


Frozen asparagus will probably be a bit mushy because of the freezing process. I definitely wouldn't steam it, as it doesn't need the softening or the extra water. I'd probably roast it to get some good flavor on it, and pull out some of the water. Pop it into the oven still frozen. Usually I reserve frozen asparagus for soup where I can puree it.

And don't feel bad about not being familiar with cooking steaks. I ruined a good many steaks until I learned to tell the difference between "still raw" and "well done" in the pan. A meat thermometer helps, but if you press on the raw meat with your tongs (just press the top of it), you can feel how squishy it is (squishy like a non-BF breast). As it cooks, it will firm up... so if you like a medium steak, you want it to be somewhere between squishy and firm (kinda like the cartilage in your nose). If it gets to firm (like the heel of your hand), then it's fairly well-done.

HTH
post #12 of 12
Thread Starter 
Thank you for such a detailed response! I'll let you know if I try the bernaise/hollandaise with CO. I'm still unsure about what type of sauce I'll make. I might just make a gravy with some of my beef stock. I'll probably ask ds what he'd like to do. Sure wish we could eat mushrooms. That sounds sooo good!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Traditional Foods
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Health › Nutrition and Good Eating › Traditional Foods › Filet mignon! -- Give me your best ideas