Mothering › Forums › Archives › Birth Professional › Is it fair to ask my doula...
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Is it fair to ask my doula...  

post #1 of 9
Thread Starter 
I have a doula for our upcoming April birth who I really, really like and respect. She's attended over 300 births all over the area, she does hypnosis for pain relief, and she seems *really* excited to work with us since we're already "on the same page" and need a lot less education about birth choices than I guess her typical client. ;-) She has nice things to say about the practice we're currently planning to birth with.

We had an annoying appointment with one of the midwives in the practice (there are four; it's a hospital-based practice) which, depending on whether this midwife was on-target or totally off base, may lead us to investigate other care providers and delivery locations. At issue is me refusing the GTT and instead opting to check my sugars 4x/day at home; one MW was fine with that plan, another (the one we saw on Tuesday) said they'd have to transfer my care if I don't get the GTT, because I'm a VBAC. (Yeah, because THAT makes sense, but anyway.) I'm planning to call the "lead" midwife after the New Year and double-check this, but if it's true, I have a tough choice or three to make:

1) Take the GTT anyway to stay in their care
2) Choose another hospital practice (which would be an OB; I know who my first stop will be already)
3) Reconsider homebirth (I've talked to an HB midwife practice that's highly recommended and seen an OB who is willing to be back-up care, but didn't pursue it further as I realized I felt more comfortable with a hospital environment)

So, I want to ask my doula for advice. After all, she knows practically every freakin' practice in the greater metro area, and has seen people through sooo many births that she's probably seen all sides of GD and has a feel for it. BUT, she is not a medical practictioner and cannot give me medical advice. I totally get that... would it be putting her "on the spot" too much to ask her for a more personal opinion on my next steps and options? What do you folks who are doulas think? Would you be bothered by such a question, and is there a way to ask it that would feel less like "overstepping" the birth support role you're trained and experienced for?
post #2 of 9
I found conversations with my doula gave me great insight into what practices respected her as a doula and mothers she's worked with - ask her for her experiences, not medical advice, and I'm sure she'll be happy to share it.
post #3 of 9
nak

asking, "what's your opinion? What would you do in my situation?" is probably fine.

i'm always happy to discuss the pros/cons of any given situation with clients.
post #4 of 9
Ask for her input instead of advice. Then go have a homebirth
post #5 of 9
I agree with pp; asking for her experiences with care provider's is not asking for medical advice. Sounds like you're already very well-informed, so if you need to do additional research on gd, I'm sure you well.
You vbac's have such an uphill battle in the hospital. I honor your strength and courage in seeking the best birth for you and your baby.
post #6 of 9
For a brief hijack here...

What the heck is

nak

?

I think I've done pretty darn well at interpreting things here...FWIW, ITA, amd all the things you guys make into acronyms...except

NAK

!

Please enlighten me

thanks
post #7 of 9
nak = nursing at keyboard
post #8 of 9
I would phrase your question to ask if your doula would be willing to help you figure out the best decision for you, rather than for her opinion. Asking a doula for "advice" or for her personal opinion is a tough thing. It is (and should be) ultimately your decision, so a good doula will not disclose her own opinion. With all of her experience, she sounds like the perfect person to be able to help you to figure out the best choice for you.
post #9 of 9
Thread Starter 
Thanks so much, ladies, for the help on wording. I've got a clearer idea now I think of where to go with this!

(No worries about the mini-hijack... it's a useful abbreviation. ;-)

If there's any other contributions or opinions, please feel free to continue to post them... I think my next step is to wait until after the new year, then contact the MW office for clarification on their policy/stance/whatever, and *then* I'll ask my doula for her input on my decision.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Birth Professional
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Archives › Birth Professional › Is it fair to ask my doula...