Just another vote for trusting your instincts. I will not leave my dd with my IL's. They are really nice and all, but 1.I don't trust that they can make good decisions/judgement calls especially in case of an emergency and 2.I don't agree with their parenting style, which if left with dd alone, they would be somewhat in charge and I am not comfortable with that. My IL's have never mentioned it to ME< but I know they've asked dh about it, and he's asked me about it. He (of course) thinks his parents are perfect and would be fine with dd. I'm not doubting she would be FINE, but I'm not ok with FINE. I'm very protective about how people speak, treat and relate to her. I feel that, at just 2.5 she still needs me around to advocate for her in case she needs some reassurance. Since I still have to intervene with them when we are all together, (often, not just once or twice) I'm not comfortable leaving her alone with them. It's not even 'big' stuff, it's just little things that I'm not comfortable with her having to deal with at her age. Things like teasing (even in love, she just doesn't get it yet) or 'play' threats (if you don;t give me a kiss, I'll take your princess dress back home!!) or bribes (if you want ice cream you have to give me a hug!). When she's older and more able to roll her eyes and say Yeah right! I might change my mind. But for now, she is at an age where she takes all of that seriously, and no aount of me talking to them has made them stop. So I dont trust them to keep from speaking to her like that. They also are HUGE into obedience, and while I KNOW they would never lay a hand on dd (like they did with their own kids, many spankings, from the ages of about 12 months to when FIL slapped dh across the face at 17 years


) I know they would drill it in her head to obey without question, and that is NOT something I want her ever to learn.
My dd has only ever been left with my mom, who believes in GD/AP ect. and who lives with us, so dd is very familiar with her.
I've read protecting the gift and it's wonderful. Mama instincts are very very very rarely off.