Moderator here, stepping in to remind everyone to keep this debate *friendly* please.
I think everyone agrees that toys that have been recalled should not be donated.
They should be sent back to the company that made them or otherwise disposed of (unless the family chooses to ignore the recall and keep the toy for themselves).
I can't see how donating MIC toys that have not been recalled is immoral. Everyone is free to make their own choices for their own families.
I know that I for one feel very strongly about the choices I've made for my family re: toys, but I can't imagine feeling strongly about the choices that other families make in regards to toys.
Please keep the User Agreement
in mind when continuing this discussion