Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Ages and Stages › The Childhood Years › Hannah Montanna/High School Musical
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Hannah Montanna/High School Musical - Page 2  

post #21 of 24
i'm okay with a limited amount of both.

as far as role models outside of the immediate family, it could be much worse then HSM and HM. DD (5) loves to sing and dance and both of these shows promote that which is what makes her enjoy them. As far as HM lyrics go, they have not shown a negative effect on DD.
post #22 of 24
We love bth HSM and Hannah - honestly if you watch both (and believe me I have) there is really very little negative to be found in either.

HSM shows how kinds from all different "groups" at school can come together and enjoy the same things. The basketball hero makes the lead in the school musical along with the smart scholastic bowl girl. They both are shown going against what their friends believe because the musical is what they really want to do. In the end, all of therse kids become friends regardless of their likes and interests.

Hannah really does have a good message if you watch. While she is very popular when she is performing as "Hannah", Miley is an outcast at school, chosen last for gym class, bumped to the worst locker so the new cool guy can have hers, the popular girls don't like her, she's just your average kid. She chooses not to let everyone know about her "Hannah" alter ego because she doesn't want kids to like her/treat her differently because she is a celebrity. She wants to just be a normal kid. She lives in a single parent household and honestly, and talking back to her father is minor and is always followed up by an apology or talk with her dad.

Honestly, there are many more cartoons out there that have a much worse message than HSM or Hannah. (And I really like the songs in both!)
post #23 of 24
I've got a 5 year old dd that hasn't seen either, she'd much rather watch something about dinosaurs or horses, lol.
Here is what I am wondering. Do you think that it makes these little one want to be/act like older ones? Even if there is noting really "bad" in them I'm still wondering if it would make her want to emulate theses teens. And I'm trying so very hard to preserve her childhood. Do you understand what I'm asking? we watch older musicals and PG movies so it's not that we really limit her exposure. I guess I'm just wondering if you guys think those types of shows make them want to be "just like the characters". Like I remember reading little house on the prarie and wanting to be Laura so, so bad.
This is really not an issue at all since like I said she's pretty animal focused, I'm just curious.
post #24 of 24
My dd is too little to really like her shows yet (age 3), but she really likes Hannah Montana's music, and we encourage that since the themes are *so* positive. (Loving yourself, you can be anything you want, etc)
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: The Childhood Years
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Ages and Stages › The Childhood Years › Hannah Montanna/High School Musical