Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Ages and Stages › The Childhood Years › S/O plastic toys and older kids
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

S/O plastic toys and older kids  

post #1 of 6
Thread Starter 
Okay, so it's easy enough for me to not buy plastics for my 8 month old. She prefers her soft dolls and wooden blocks anyway, and about the only non-natural-fiber/element things she plays with are books.

But I also have a 5yo self-proclaimed diva-girl who likes sparkles and play makeup and those jelly-clothes Polly Pocket dolls. She loves her wooden play kitchen, wool food, and playsilks, but would totally flip if she couldn't find her My Little Pony collection.

Then there's my 8yo son, who is a video game expert and loves collectible action figure toys (often purchase-able only via eBay). He collects rocks and plays with wooden swords, but he'd cry mutiny if I even suggested getting rid of the xbox (as would my husband!! )

Many things that older kids want to play with just aren't plastic-free. And the older they get, the more their opinions should be respected...right? So how is this issue navigated in your homes? Do you just ban all commercial, mass-produced toys regardless of age? Do you let them choose what they want to play with from the beginning and not worry about any potential risks from plastic? What are your methods and feelings, and why??
(yes I'm picking your brains )

Cause it's pretty defeating to have my 8 month old finding and mouthing my 8yo's Pokemon figures when I'm not looking!
post #2 of 6
What a great topic. Thanks for bringing it into the light. What I have found is that many of my friends who are into natural and/or wooden toys don't have older kids. Very few that have older kids are now trying to limit what comes into their home, and I believe it has a great deal to do with respecting the wants and feelings of the older kids. I am from the camp that feels respecting the child is of utter importance and that limiting the toys can cause contradiction in that repsect. (make any sense??)

So, what we have done (and mine are just about 5 and 3 years old) is always openly discuss the merits of the things we have and don't have. For example, we have visited my nephews often (they are 9 and 12) where the kids are exposed to the Wii, as well as cable television. These boys have loads of great things that are absolute eye candy to my LO's. While we are there, DH and I do not limit our kids play with any of it. *But* when we leave or get home, if DS asks about anything he's seen that he might like to have, we have a conversation about why we choose not to have it. I have been telling DS since he was very small that things made from plastic are "chemicall-y" and break easily (which he brings up in the stores now when he sees something interesting..."But, it's just plastic, so we probably shouldn't get it...")
My kids do know many of those highly commercialized characters, and they may have a couple of items here or there that friends have given them (and something their own father got simply because he knew they'd love it), but we don't go out of our way to get something simply because it's "Dora" or "Spiderman" and the kids would like it...We actually have avoided buying DS Legos modeled after Sponge Bob and shoes that had Spiderman on them, and he was frustated, but understood our feelings and actaully says he's glad since they wouldn't have fit in with the castle kingdom he now has.
It's tough. But, explaining to the kids why we make the choices we do has helped a lot. My DS could tell you exactly why we don't step foot inside WalMart or why we don't watch "regular" tv at home. Communicating this to him (and to our DD as she grows and becomes more aware of her world) will always be an important part of our relationship.

I am not sure if that helped or was in any way what you're looking for...
I am looking oforward to this thread growing to see what others have to say. It's really hard being a parent in this world.
post #3 of 6
My girls are almost 6, almost 7 & 9. I limit the amount of stuff, but not what the stuff is made from. I limit the amount due to they just don't need so many things. You can't get away from plastic, it's impossible. Furntiture, computers, cars, desks at school, their boots/shoes, etc all have plastic in them. I'm not going to fret over them, it's not worth the effort.

They play with barbies, bratz, polly pockets, littlest pet shops, board games, books. They all have harmful elements to them(yes even the books).

My kids don't put things in their mouths so I don't worry about things like that. Even when my 9yo got Aqua Dots for her birthday the week before they were recalled I didn't take them away. She's not going to injest them. I just make sure the floors are swept well after she uses them so the dogs don't eat them.
post #4 of 6
I think there is a natural difference between very young kids and older kids. Toddlers and babies haven't developed interests in the same way as older kids, plus they stick stuff in their mouths.

I pretty much get my daughter what she's interested in at this point. I try to stick with stuff made as locally as possible, or made places with good environmental and labor laws, or directly from the people who make it, whenever possible though.
post #5 of 6
My dd is 4.5 and I limit the amount of toys that are not wodden/natural etc. But she still has some that are plastic. She has a baby doll with a rubber who knows what it is made from.. arms and face. She loves it, she would flip if I took it away. But moderation is what I am doing and it is working so far..
post #6 of 6
I am on the moderation front. My sons are 2 & 5. Obviously at 2 I have all the say in what I buy him. The 5 yr old on the other hand is getting into all kinds of things. So we have started to discuss toys and good quality and things that break and the chemicals. I do try and steer him in certain directions and yes certain things have "disappeared". But if he uses his own money for a not so great toy that breaks in 2 minutes, then we have a learning experience. Like those stupid transformers. He LOVES the plastic transformers. The problem is the first time you transform them they start to fall apart. Now when he sees them in the store he will complain that they suck and will skip over them.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: The Childhood Years
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Ages and Stages › The Childhood Years › S/O plastic toys and older kids