Mothering › Forums › Parenting › 4 yo disappointed with birthday presents
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

4 yo disappointed with birthday presents  

post #1 of 12
Thread Starter 
Please help- I have no idea how to talk about this with my son. He has been crying for the last hour because the dollhouse he got for his birthday was not the one he wanted (I didn't know he wanted one that his friend has). He is also crying because apparently DH asked him what he wanted at the bookstore 2 days before his birthday and let him pick out a bunch of things that he would like, and he is disappointed he didn't get any of them (I had no idea that DH did this). Even the miscellaneous junk he got from my brother he says he didn't want and wants me to throw away. He has been playing with all this stuff since his birthday a few days ago, and he just now told me this.

On the one hand, his little heart is broken because he didn't get exactly what he wanted. On the other hand, I just want him to feel grateful people got him things. They're only things, and I don't want him to be so wrapped up in things.

How to deal with this?
post #2 of 12
I don't know how I would handle it.

Is it possible to take the dollhouse back to the store and get the one he wants? I know that when I receive something I don't want, I exchange it for something I do want. Would it be a bad thing to do that for kids too? (Maybe it would. I'm not sure....)

About the things he says he doesn't want..... maybe make a big donation box and let him decide what goes in? He can donate those toys?

About the bookstore.... it's sad that dh set up his expectations about what he'd be receiving and then didn't follow through. I think I'd be disappointed if someone said, "Pick out some things you'd like" and then never gave them to me.

But I get what you're saying about just wanting him to be grateful. I don't think that's something you can teach, though, not directly, at least.

I'm sorry he was disappointed.
post #3 of 12
It sounds like the root of all of it may be his disappointment at not getting the things he picked out that he was expecting, which is so understandable.
I would let him exchange the dollhouse for the one he wanted, and get him the books he picked out--that's pretty harsh to build up his expectations and then fail to meet them. (Not saying it was intentional on his dad's part, just from a little one's point of view.)
I would help him write thank-you cards for the other things he got, and if he still doesn't want them, I'd let him exchange them(or sell them and pick out another toy).
post #4 of 12
Thread Starter 
Unfortunately the dollhouse is one that was given to us and refurbished with hours and hours of work by me (but it does look great, just not in his eyes), so I guess we could give it away and buy him one he likes, but we can't just take it back. DH feels that it is spoiling him to get him new stuff just because he didn't like what we got him.

According to DH, he didn't say "pick out stuff you want for your birthday", just "pick out stuff you like". The stuff that he picked out wasn't books, just some plastic junk they had in the kids' section (at Border's). This is not stuff we would ever normally buy but I see how DS feels misled.

So if we do fix this situation, where can I look for help on how to help him deal with disappointment on the whole, because it won't always be so easily fixable? What about this attachment to stuff and how can I teach that "the best things in life aren't things."

I ask because I can totally relate to his situation. When I was a little girl, I wanted a Barbie dollhouse. My parents made me one but the rooms weren't tall enough to fit Barbies. It was a nice dollhouse, but not what I wanted. 30+ years later, I still remember this. I also remember making huge lists of stuff that I wanted for Christmas and not getting it all (of course).

How can I help him not be disappointed if something like this happens again? Of course, we can learn from this particular situation, but he is so sensitive.

Younger DS loves all the stuff older DS got that he says he doesn't want (particularly the dollhouse)...should we let younger DS have the stuff older DS doesn't want instead of giving it away or would that hurt older DS more?

And what should I do about Easter? We've traditionally done a small basket of necessities for Easter- new sunhat, socks and some other non-candy but summer things (which of course I've got completely put together, the bargain shopper that I am). Now I wonder if I should do nothing for either kid because it seems what upset him is that he didn't get what he fantasized about...maybe we have made too big a deal about stuff. Maybe it would be better to not do any gifts for a while. I just don't know. He doesn't watch tv, he doesn't go to pre-school, if he's getting the message that stuff is important, it must be from us.
post #5 of 12
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nosy View Post
How can I help him not be disappointed if something like this happens again? Of course, we can learn from this particular situation, but he is so sensitive.
I don't think you can prevent him feeling disappointed, and I'm not sure you'd want to. You wouldn't want to cause it uneccessarily of course, but this is an opportunity to give him some tools for dealing with life's disappointments. Sometimes we can change things, and when we can we do BUT, we wouldn't want to get into the habit of changing reality for our kids.

You can however, validate his feelings and help him work through and adapt to reality. He does sound very sensitive (my DS is as well, but not in this particular category so I'm no expert to be sure). Honestly, I would just validate the things he's telling you. When he's talking about his frustration over the doll house: "You wanted another doll house, but received this one instead. You feel disappointed. I understand." As to the DH/store scenario I'd say, "You thought Dad was going to get you all of the things you picked out. When your birthday came and went and you didn't receive the items, you felt disappointed." And then, "The items you received from your uncle weren't really your thing. You'd rather have received something different. I understand."

Truly, validation is the only way we get through these things. Warning: he may cry harder AFTER you say these things. That's ok. He's doing what he has to do to work through it and move on, deal with the disappointment. I love Naomi Aldort's saying: "children can deal with any trauma, any upset so long as they are able to express it." You can't change reality for him, but you can help him adapt to it. This is a skill that will serve him very well, I assure you. After he's had time to cry, be upset, see if he doesn't relax and eventually move on... until the next time that is.

Some suggestions for when things are calm, for helping now, and for the future: look for opportunities in your lives to show your DS about disappointment, gratitude, etc. Let him see you receive a gift and be thankful. Let him see you not get the last pretty blue shirt on the rack and witness how YOU deal with disappointment. You can share with him stories about your own life (my DS LOVES and his helped immensely by the most upsetting times of my childhood!). You can share about times when you wanted one thing and received another and felt disappointed. If you happen to receive a gift in the here and now and it doesn't do much for you, you can be grateful and thankful to the person who gave you the gift, and then later confide to your DS: You know, this cake pan isn't really one I'm going to use, but it was so thoughtful of Auntie to give it to me. I love that she thought about me in this way..."

As to feeling grateful, I've been around the block on this one and the only thing I've come up with is that you can't make it happen per se. It is a product of maturity. You can model gratitude, nurture attachment, validate and wait... you'll see glimpses of beautiful gratitude and at other times total breaches of courtesy (well, I shouldn't assume) but it's all normal. For my DS, we just talk often (and in particular before things like Christmas get togethers with the family and the like) about how nice it is that people think of us. We may not receive everything we'd like, but it's nice to have been thought of. We can show our thanks to them, but we don't have to say everything we think out loud... he can always confide in you later and receive again, validation.

We're also sticklers for writing thank you notes together... and DS always likes to give gifts as well (he draw pictures for people usually). Also, you could play a game about gift giving. Play is a powerful way to deal with disappointment and can often take the sting out of the real moment when it should arise. DS likes to gather things in his room and put it in a box and "wrap it up" and give it to me. I'm always VERY grateful! You could encourage him to give you something you'd LOVE and then something you WOULDN'T and then act accordingly... being grateful for both no matter what they are. KWIM?

I hope this makes sense. My DH and DS are playing very LOUDLY and I'm having a hard time concentrating and keeping this from being wordy.

The best and hang in there, mama!

Em
post #6 of 12
Oh, one more thing I wanted to add: this could be a reacton that is not proportionate to the stimuli so to to speak--could just be overwhelmed by all the gifts. In other words, it could be something completely different from what it appears to be.

Sometimes after Christmas and birthday (which are very close for DS), DS has a meltdown of sorts. This year he received several items that we a little above his level and it was frustrating and he got angry. Once he was able to express it however, he calmed down and enjoyed them immensely... with our help initially and now mostly, on his own (the legos are still tricky!)

As to the gifts your DS received, they're his, and his to do with what he likes. I wouldn't act hastily, or take it upon myself to give them away, donate or exchange. I'd give him time to adapt and then see what happens but in any case, they are still his and his to decide whether or not to keep.

Okay, I'll stop yapping now!

Em
post #7 of 12
For the dollhouse, I would take the "when life gives you lemons, make lemonade" approach. Ok, this isn't the exact dollhouse you wanted. What do you like about the other dollhouse? What can we do to make this dollhouse really great for you?

If it was a money issue (only refurbished this dollhouse because it was the affordable option), I might help dc sell the dollhouse and put the money toward the one that he really wants. Dd generally gets birthday money that she could pitch in, possibly making up the difference. But 4 might be a little young for that, depending on the child.

But, with disappointment in general, I agree with Embee. Help him to express the emotion, let him feel it, and then help him to move on.
post #8 of 12
Umm...is it possible that he needs a nap? -- OK, not to dismiss his feelings or to sound cliche, but it really does seem that his reactions are a little elevated. I agree w/ pp who mentioned that he might just be overwhelmed. I mean, he has been playing with the stuff for several days...

I dunno, I suppose I can understand his disappointment about the stuff at Borders, and I would probably take him there and let him pick one or two of the things to bring home.

About the doll house...have you tried telling him how hard you worked on it? How much time you spent to make everything just right especially for him? My kids are really into that kind of thing. If I knit my ds (who will be 4 next month) a pair of socks, he tells everybody and shows everybody for months, and then weeps like you would for a departed friend when he outgrows them.

Whatever you decide to do, please don't feel guilty (not saying that you are), you can't really tell how kids are going to react sometimes.
post #9 of 12
I know how you feel. I recently gave dd a Cinderella princess sweat suit that I thought she would love. I had said, "Dd, I have a special surprise for you," and I went in the other room to get it. When I gave it to her, she burst into tears.

I asked her why, and she said she thought she was going to get something "bigger." We had just been to her friend's house and her friend had gotten this baby doll changing table thing, and somehow dd imagined I was going to give her one, too. So she was sad.

I admit that at first I was hurt and disappointed that dd wasn't grateful for what she did get. But then I realized how similar my reaction was to hers! I told her I understood the feeling of disappointment, and that I was sorry the gift wasn't what she had envisioned. She still doesn't have the doll changing table, but she loves the sweat suit.

I hope he feels better. Happy b-day, little man!
post #10 of 12
I can understand a child being disappointed not getting the present/s he wanted; but throughout his life there is going to be disappointments so you could use this as a learning experience so he knows he’s not always going to get the toy he wants, the job, etc sometimes it not possible to get everything we want in life but we enjoy what we have and be thankful.

Nowadays children receive an avalanche of toys from family and friends for Christmas and birthdays and they really don’t need that many. They outgrow them so fast and then they sit forgotten in the toy cupboard. Don’t get me started on advertising geared towards children
post #11 of 12
My kids don't do very well with surprises. I really try not to surprise them very much. Christmas and bdays I try to be very clear with them with at least one main gift, so that it isn't a surprise. Dh always wants to surprise them, but they don't like things (even good things) sprung on them. They like to process. I'm not sure what I'd do now that the day is passed. It is so hard to know what a kid has built up in their heads. I think as adults we are just as dissappointed with gifts sometimes, we have just 1. learned how to be polite about it and 2. learned not to count our chickens. I can see how a 4 year old wouldn't have that yet.
post #12 of 12
Quote:
Originally Posted by Embee View Post
I don't think you can prevent him feeling disappointed, and I'm not sure you'd want to. You wouldn't want to cause it uneccessarily of course, but this is an opportunity to give him some tools for dealing with life's disappointments. Sometimes we can change things, and when we can we do BUT, we wouldn't want to get into the habit of changing reality for our kids.

You can however, validate his feelings and help him work through and adapt to reality. He does sound very sensitive (my DS is as well, but not in this particular category so I'm no expert to be sure). Honestly, I would just validate the things he's telling you. When he's talking about his frustration over the doll house: "You wanted another doll house, but received this one instead. You feel disappointed. I understand." As to the DH/store scenario I'd say, "You thought Dad was going to get you all of the things you picked out. When your birthday came and went and you didn't receive the items, you felt disappointed." And then, "The items you received from your uncle weren't really your thing. You'd rather have received something different. I understand."

Truly, validation is the only way we get through these things. Warning: he may cry harder AFTER you say these things. That's ok. He's doing what he has to do to work through it and move on, deal with the disappointment. I love Naomi Aldort's saying: "children can deal with any trauma, any upset so long as they are able to express it." You can't change reality for him, but you can help him adapt to it. This is a skill that will serve him very well, I assure you. After he's had time to cry, be upset, see if he doesn't relax and eventually move on... until the next time that is. Em
:
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Parenting
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Parenting › 4 yo disappointed with birthday presents