Mothering › Forums › Education › Learning at School › Keeping DS home the first few months of kindy - bad idea?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Keeping DS home the first few months of kindy - bad idea?  

post #1 of 9
Thread Starter 
DS is (barely) old enough to begin kindergarten this fall. However our first choice (charter) school is totally full, current staff and siblings have priority and there is not a single space. Our second choice school will have a handful of spaces, the drawing for entry is in a few weeks. His odds are maybe 50-50 of getting in there. Maybe less, the school has had a lot of really glowing media coverage this past year and a lot of people want their kids to go there. Our neighborhood school is problematic for various reasons. Transferring to a different neighborhood school is a possibility but DH and I don't agree on this.

DS will be a VERY young kindergartener, he was born (early, in fact) just two weeks before the cutoff. If he'd made it to his due date he would not even be allowed to start this year. North Carolina's laws have changed so that starting next year the cutoff is August 31st (it was Oct. 16th up until this year). One effect of this is that the kindergarten cohort is expected to be 15% smaller next year. So what this means is (1) less competition to get into one of our preferred schools if he tries for kindergarten NEXT year as well as (2) the big clump of younger siblings at our first choice school got in THIS year, next year's class will have more openings and fewer applicants.

Furthermore, I will be on maternity leave until Nov. 1st. I am kind of heartbroken about the idea that after years of childcare, at the point I could actually be home for a few months, DS will be going off to a school I don't even want him in! We had really wanted to time it that I would be on leave with the baby and DS all summer before he started kindy, but I just didn't conceive in time. I am due in mid-August, right around when school would be starting.

Also -- I know quite a few people who did not get into the first or second choice school at the drawing, but a week or a month or two months into the school year, they got a phone call saying a space had opened up and did they want it. At that point it was a very difficult decision about disrupting their child from a different school that had become familiar, away from their friends, etc. Obviously if the situation was terrible you would just do it, but what if the situation were merely mediocre? And the child was upset about changing schools?

So it dawned on me last night -- why not just keep him home with me and see what happens? There's a roughly 25% chance, I'd estimate, that I will not go back to work at all. So even if he doesn't get a spot down the road, whatever, he's not legally obligated to be in kindergarten this year. I think it will be a lot more fun to be home with both kids, than just with the baby. Honestly I was bored to death when DS was a baby/toddler, but he's so much fun now! OTOH, even if I do go back to work, I think we can figure something out. I wouldn't want to try to enroll him in the neighborhood school several months into the year, and I wouldn't want to put him back into "daycare," but we might have a nanny, or he could maybe attend a private "transitional kindergarten" near us. It's kind of aimed at his demographic, like kids who are technically old enough for kindy but for whatever reason not enrolling in public K yet. They have 4/5 year olds for a half day, then they have aftercare as well for working parents. The class is TINY, like 10 kids.

Thoughts?
post #2 of 9
I would not think twice about holding him back another year. We lived in NC and my ds2 has a Sept b-day and I knew we would NOT send him according to their dates. He is one of the oldest kids (but not the oldest by any stretch) and it has worked out great. He is mature and ready to learn. I don't regret our decision one bit. As for your son being born early I would go with his 'adjusted' age and by that he doesn't make the cut-off. Boys typically mature at a slower rate than girls and why not give him the extra year to mature?

My mother-in-law still regrets that she let her dh insist on sending my Aug b-day dh to kindergarten! She knew he was too young but he met the deadline. 43 yrs later she still feels bad!

Just my 2 cents. Good luck!
post #3 of 9
Honestly, I'd just hold him back.

I have a couple kids in my K class that should have been held back a year. They're fabulous kids, but they're the only 2 that are really struggling emotionally and academically. The little boy fell asleep every day for the first couple months and still cries for his mom often. The little girl will get frustrated with her work and start crying even while someone is helping her. It's rough. They are both intelligent, capable kids, they're just not ready for the pressures of all day schooling.
post #4 of 9
Thread Starter 
DS has attended 3 years of full-day montessori preschool already, so I'm not so worried about separation issues or being able to handle a full day. I just kind of think there's no compelling reason to enroll him in a school I'm not excited about merely because he's legally (just) old enough. The compelling reason up until recently was, well, I work, and daycare is expensive, and public school is free. That doesn't look so compelling anymore.

DH and I went around about this some this morning. He thinks I'm looking for any excuse not to enroll him in our neighborhood school. I think HE thinks there's like liberal cred in proudly sending him to our "inner-city" school. He thinks it's a "great school" based entirely on, he attended a community meeting there once (in the evening, not during school hours, and not school-related) and walked around the hallways . Oh and supposedly the principal is a "great person", this is like third-hand from someone who knows someone who goes to church with her. Whatever.
post #5 of 9
Well, as a kid who moved A LOT, my two cents are that I would just hold him back the whole year. It is hard to come in as the new kid in the middle of the year. Everyone has already made friends and they all know the rules and the routine. So I would either send him to a school I intended to leave him at for the entire year or keep him back for a year.

Catherine
post #6 of 9
A different situation here, my kids were homeschooled for a couple years before I enrolled them in a local charter school in February. My DD is in kindergarden, and it has worked out really well for her. She's had no problems joining the class halfway through the year. In some ways, I think it was good that she stayed home in the fall and had time to mature a little before starting school.

If you feel strongly about a certain school, I don't think it's a bad idea to hold your child back until a space opens up.
post #7 of 9
Thread Starter 
I definitely hear you on that Catherine. I think the worst case scenario would be that come November, we decide it's necessary for me to return to work, but money is tight so we enroll DS in the neighborhood school after all. I would really really hate to do that and would try anything short of going that route. Sending him to the private transitional K that is more pre-schoolish in nature and has a smaller ratio would be preferable to me. OTOH if we were offered a spot mid-year in our first or second choice schools I wouldn't let the opportunity pass by, I'd go ahead and enroll him.
post #8 of 9
Oh man my post is missing

Well, anyway what I though was, you could call the charter and find out what they will be learning in the fall, you could homeschool you ds to make sure he isn't behind if space does open up this school year. If he doesn't get accepted till the following year he will just be a little ahead, but that isn't a bad thing. Do you know where his name is on the list. At one Charter my dd name was like 12 on the list so I was pretty certain it was not going to happen.

Also, take a look at his social maturity, do you think he will be able to relate to the children next year or will he be to socially advanced?? If you are not worried about it, I might try to find out how some of the kids that are planning to attend next year are, maybe set up playdates and also since he has been in full day prek, he might miss going to school, so you could try to find him a class that he is interested in

Good Luck, hopefully this one posts

Megan
post #9 of 9
I would hold him back until the following year.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Learning at School
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Education › Learning at School › Keeping DS home the first few months of kindy - bad idea?