Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Gentle Discipline › Sibling Rivalry with 10 month old sister. HELP!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Sibling Rivalry with 10 month old sister. HELP!  

post #1 of 4
Thread Starter 
DD1 has been so mean to my little one lately. She takes every toy that she picks up and sometimes every throws them across the room. I have done everything I can think of but sometimes she pulls chairs that DD2 is pulling up on away and makes her fall. I have hardwoods so this is dangerous. She used to be so good with her but now it is just getting frustrating.

Any suggestions?
post #2 of 4
http://www.naomialdort.com/articles4.html

The above is a link to an excellent article that may help. Within the article, the author talks about a similar situation between her two youngest children.

I find anytime DS is behaving in a way that suggests that he's in emotional turmoil, this article really helps get perspective and help him deal with things and therefore be able to adjust his behavior accordingly.

I wish I had some sage advice. I do know that when the younger ones get mobile, that is often the time the older sibling begins to act out so you're not alone.

Hang in there, mama.

Em
post #3 of 4
Interesting article! Not sure I can see myself telling my child "you're wonderful" just at the moment they are in trouble....seems disingenuois (sp?). But still it's interesting.

For my part, I try to address the underlying issues, like the PP suggested. It's really all about jealousy. So I have a hard and fast rule "no hurting" but other than that, DD is allowed to express her feelings. We do alot of "playful parenting" techniques to let her "play out" her feelings about things like her brother. I also try to make sure that my rules apply to both kids.

It's an ongoing monitoring of their relationship from my perspective...but in some sense I feel like I'm teaching DD how to interact with others. I'm just not a "hands off" parent and let them figure it out - because to me, there is too much lord of the flies behavior. I try to model the kind of behavior I'd like to see them have towards one another and I'm hoping that after a while it will be second nature to them. To me, this relationship offers lots of teachable moments.

That said, I try not to take sides (except to state the universal rule - "ask, don't grab" for example) or clamp down on expressions of how they feel about each other. I also try not to assume that because DD is older she should "act better" than DS. I give her lots of opportunities to "regress" for a bit (have a bottle, pretend to be the baby, etc) to reassure her that it's okay if she doesn't want to act like a "big girl" just then. I think that can put alot of pressure on a kid to hold them to a higher standard than their siblings.

ETA: I've had good luck also playing "sharing" games with DD. I'll pretend to be a kid saying "mine, mine" and then offer to share something with her - I also use lots of positive reinforcement on the issue. If she offers to share something (or her brother does) it gets a big positive reaction...that seems to also work well for her.

Anyway, those are some things I do....hope that helps....
peace,
robyn
post #4 of 4
Quote:
Originally Posted by hippymomma69 View Post
Interesting article! Not sure I can see myself telling my child "you're wonderful" just at the moment they are in trouble....seems disingenuois (sp?). But still it's interesting.
I see what you're saying, it would be hard, but I don't really see it as disingenious. (It really helped me to listen to Aldort's seminar on tape because she elaborated on this very subject and this very incident and it really made sense and at the end of the day, her approach was effective not only in eliminating the behavior, but also in restoring the good feelings her son needed about himself to regain his composure and learn to deal well with his strong emotions about sharing his mom with little brother.)

The point that she's making is that it's important to let our children know that they are not judged on what they do, but by who they are. That our love exists for them whether they are behaving in a way we like, or don't like. A person can do a bad thing, but still be a good (or wonderful) person, etc. Additionally, recognizing that the child doing the hurting is also in pain. That it's exactly in the moments when our children are at their worst, that they need us the most. By being given the gift of unconditional love, they have the security they need to feel better and therefore change their behavior. Treating the underlying issue/emotion, so to speak. And of course, this is just what she was doing "in the moment." She was also recognizing many other areas to "treat" her son and help him deal with his problem (giving him power in other ways through play/games, and getting alone with just after the moment and giving him a safe alternative for his actions, etc.)

Just an interpretation. My .02, for what it's worth.

The best,
Em
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Gentle Discipline
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Gentle Discipline › Sibling Rivalry with 10 month old sister. HELP!