Mothering › Forums › Natural Family Living › Books, Music and Other Media › TV-Free › Want to share your "tv lightbulb moment"?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Want to share your "tv lightbulb moment"?  

post #1 of 8
Thread Starter 
So, I thought maybe it would be interesting to share the "moment" when you decided to go tv-free... what was the "thing" that did it.

Here's my story... So, it was a winter's late afternoon. My husband is a large animal veterinarian, so he has some irregular hours and I was alone, in our little apartment. I had a mug of hot chocolate, I was cozied up on the couch and was nursing my 3 month old son who was quickly falling asleep. I was watching Oprah, enjoying the warm TV flicker and banter, the cocoa, the darkness of winter and a nice blanket. I fell asleep too. I woke up some time later to see my 3 month old "watching" Dr. Phil (who must have come on after Oprah ). Dr. Phil is screaming at these people- a couple dealing with drug abuse and infidelity- they are crying and yelling and begging... and though I know my 3 month old wasn't "watching" it like we would think, he still must have heard those sounds and voices of anger and desperation. I thought (I remember this clear as day) "Is THIS what I want to be his first ideas of the world and family?" I quickly flipped, but that night I told DH how much the idea disturbed me. That I didn't want him to grow up around those voices and pain and the adult world too fast. That his baby and childhood should be calm and safe without the intrusion of adult worries and complexities and responsibilities.

We decided- OK, no "adult" tv for baby or around baby where he could hear it . So as a SAHM, I'm looking for other things to do that do not involve me watching my TV during the day. It was hard, but I did it. And I did it because I knew I wanted something for my son that was important- a sense of peace and calm and childhood.

But I, being of the TV generation, looked up when Sesame Street came on and planned on being home for that . It came on, and I plunked my 3 month old DS in front of it to watch it. I mean, who doesn't love Sesame Street? Its harmless enough and maybe he'll like it. After about 2 minutes he was bored. I was trying to get him to watch the TV, stop putting his attention elsewhere. Another epiphiny- "I am TRYING to get him to watch TV instead of playing with his toys!" I snapped that off. Again, DH and I talked. We started researching. And while the TV was off (no "adult" tv in front of baby! Our tv was cut WAY down...) we started realising how addicted we were and how much of our (former!) lives were centered around tv and how much everything seemed to be "lighter" without it all the time. We realised that "baby TV" and kid TV was taking time away from playing- even play that seemed "meaningless" to us was important to DS in developing.

The final straw was the cable went out. We never had it fixed. We moved 8 months later and the TV went into the garage, abandoned.

After the dust settled, we came to understand that it was a major choice we made in the health and direction of our family. We understood it may be the single most powerful decision we have made yet as parents- to choose to be with eachother instead of just sit next to eachother. We came to understand how it changed our relationship as a married couple, how it shifted DS's values away from commercial influences, how it changed our use of our time- our lives really. Occasionally DH and I will rent a DVD for the computer for after DS goes to bed and we order pizza nad have a bit of a "date night", but I could never again imagine a TV in the livingroom or watching on a daily basis. Good riddance!

So- anyone else have a moment (or two) where the light bulb went off and you said "Hey- this isn't really a good thing..."?
post #2 of 8
I don't know that I rally had a lightbulb moment. I'm a former preschool teacher, though, so I've witnessed some of the TV's negative influence on children in my care. I just always new that I did not want to raise a child that was so wrapped up in TV characters that it would mean that we were always buying things w/ said characters. Teaching has also made me question the real value of "educational" programs, b/c from what I've observed, a developmentally appropriate environment does way more for a child's development. I have also worked in less than stellar childcare centers, ones that use the TV heavily, and the way that TV sucks children in has always frightened me.

So I guess I had the opposite of a lightbulb moment. Mine was more of a years-of-observation-and-reflection moment.
post #3 of 8
I've always understood that TV was not good for children and had no intention of letting my children watch it until they were older but I had a few moments that have turned me against it totally.
1.) Before I had my girls my nephew was visiting and I was watching Law and Order:SVU. I really didn't think about it much until he says "What's that?" I realize he's asking me what the half-naked dead girl laying in the street on TV is. He was 4! Talk about an epiphany.
2.) One day I was folding a pile of clothes on the bed with my oldest dd playing on the bed. The TV was on and I was watching it. I heard myself tell her to be qquiet and leave me alone more than once because I was trying to hear what the some inane character on the TV was saying. How important was that compared to my dd wanting to play with me? It was just a stupid tv drama show (I really like police dramas). Introduce another epiphany.

So from now on - no TV for me or my girls. My dh still likes to watch news, college football, and the history channel but he's the only one watching and we play in the other room or what not. Nope, in my house TV is EVIL!!!!!!!!
post #4 of 8
My lightbulb moment was seeing my DS staring slack-jawed at the TV watching some inane children's programming. Fortunately, DH saw it as well and was onboard with ditching the cable. Our no TV decision is reinforced every time we travel and let the kids watch TV in the hotel - children's programming seems to suck out their brains. Now when the kids have infrequent access to a TV, they're limited to channels like The Animal Planet. We still have media, and plenty of it, but we choose when and where and what - with no advertising.
post #5 of 8
I don't want my daughter watching tv at all for the first few years, based on the research that I've read about how it affects their brain development.

A couple of months ago, I was talking to a three and a half year old boy, and he walked over to the TV and started watching it while we were talking -- he was actually in the middle of a sentence and he stopped talking, walked away, and sat in front of the TV. It was so bizarre, it was like he was a zombie or something.
post #6 of 8
This was 6 years ago, when dh and I were newly married and kids were not really a consideration yet. We were visiting Dh's family, who lived about 10 hours away. We picked this particular weekend to visit because his great aunt and uncle were also going to be there, also from out of town. So we got to the party where the whole family was and the TV was on. We tried to talk to the family we came all this way to see, and instead great uncle snapped at people because he wanted to watch the tv. It was sad that people didn't want to visit with the family they rarely saw (and this family doesn't have major issues, everyone gets along fine). We still had TV after that, but it was an eye-opener.
post #7 of 8
I don't know- it was really building up for awhile before we removed the tv from the house. Just realizing that we were being programmed by a consumerist driven society, to feel like crap and buy more, really did it. I cant pinpoint the exact moment though. But since getting rid of the tv I've had a lot of 'light bulb' moments. It's truly liberating!
post #8 of 8
Quote:
Originally Posted by ~threemoons~ View Post
But since getting rid of the tv I've had a lot of 'light bulb' moments. It's truly liberating!
This is definitely true for me. It's amazing how differently I see the world now that I don't have tv. Honestly it's a little spooky - like I've unplugged from the matrix...
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: TV-Free
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Natural Family Living › Books, Music and Other Media › TV-Free › Want to share your "tv lightbulb moment"?