Mothering › Forums › Health › The Case Against Circumcision › A Nurse Hath Offended Me
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

A Nurse Hath Offended Me  

post #1 of 20
Thread Starter 
An acquaintance of my dh's, who happens to be a nurse, told him that intact penises are dirty and she'd never put one in her mouth.

WT% !!!!!!!!!?????????

First...I can't imagine why she feels like that is an appropriate comment to tell my dh:...she is married and older...but still!! And secondly...I've read some crazy stories here and understand that there are all sorts of uneducated people out there, including many many many (most) health professionals, but I am still in complete shock that she would put it in that particular way.

I am so tempted to print out information about intact penises and drop it off at her house right now. I was literally shaking with anger last night. My dh and I don't exactly see eye to eye about circ...but it's for religious reasons and clearly I'm not going to get into details here. I am just so saddened that this kind of thinking pervades our culture. My father is from the UK and is intact as is my brother. I grew up in a hippy town in Colorado where most boys were left intact. I find it apsolutely sickening that the sexual preference (if you can call it that) of and adult would be a justification for circing baby boys.
post #2 of 20
I would have replied that it's such a relieve to know that my son's penis will never end up in her mouth
post #3 of 20
Quote:
Originally Posted by Yulia_R View Post
I would have replied that it's such a relieve to know that my son's penis will never end up in her mouth


I'd never put one in my mouth anyway, circ'd or intact :
post #4 of 20
Quote:
Originally Posted by CallMeMommy View Post


I'd never put one in my mouth anyway, circ'd or intact :
haha, thats the thing. Its funny when people call uncut penises gross, because to be honest, genitals in general cut/uncut, male or female are kinda "gross" and no more or less gross then another.

Whenever I hear a woman say that an intact penis is gross, I want to say "well all a vagina is, is an inverted foreskin, thats about 5 times deeper, wetter, and twice as slimy. So really, you shouldn't be talking."
post #5 of 20
Just imagine a male health professional saying that he would never go down on a woman with uncirc'd vulva as part of a conversation about infant female circumcision. It boggles my mind the way men's sexuality is denigrated and that it is acceptable to speak this way about a BABY.

Horrifying, actually.

I would have had a very hard time not punching that UAV nurse.
post #6 of 20
I think many of us were told when we were young that baby boys needed to be circumcised because the foreskin would make the penis "filthy, dirty, gross" etc. All of us have come to learn that it's simply not true and that basic daily hygeine is all that is need to keep clean and presentable for come what may....I wouldn't kiss anyone who didn't brush/floss their teeth...a freshly showered penis is a clean penis, intact or circumcised...the same goes for women. And I loved Yulia's response!
post #7 of 20




Holy shamoly! Obviously that poor woman either underwent a MouthFilterectomy at some point or is suffering from a severe case of StupidMouthitis and surely cannot control what comes out. Sad, tragic really, considering what kind of trouble that must get her into.

And, I'm sorry, but I really wouldn't have chosen the jawdrop smilie for this particular post. : Honestly, her comment is just so absurd, I have no words! But the previous posters have had some doozies!
post #8 of 20
Quote:
Originally Posted by MommaLauraRN View Post
I think many of us were told when we were young that baby boys needed to be circumcised because the foreskin would make the penis "filthy, dirty, gross" etc. All of us have come to learn that it's simply not true and that basic daily hygeine is all that is need to keep clean and presentable for come what may....I wouldn't kiss anyone who didn't brush/floss their teeth...a freshly showered penis is a clean penis, intact or circumcised...the same goes for women. And I loved Yulia's response!

I dont know if its because I am male, or because of my age, but I never heard anything negative about the intact penis when I was a kid. I never felt the foreskin it self dirty. I was never told it was dirty. The only thing I remember is back in 5th grade I remember hearing how smegma was not dirty (on howard stern of all places) and remember being surprised. But nothing negative about the actual foreskin.
post #9 of 20
Maybe you could point out that a foreskin makes an eccellent shallow woman filter.
post #10 of 20
Her loss.

Quote:
Maybe you could point out that a foreskin makes an eccellent shallow woman filter.
It really does.
post #11 of 20
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ann-Marita View Post
Maybe you could point out that a foreskin makes an eccellent shallow woman filter.

Yep, that's just another wonderful function of the foreskin!
post #12 of 20
Quote:
Originally Posted by Yulia_R View Post
I would have replied that it's such a relieve to know that my son's penis will never end up in her mouth
:
post #13 of 20
So...she's saying that intact is perfectly fine in any other place, just not her mouth!
post #14 of 20
Quote:
Originally Posted by perspective View Post
...."well all a vagina is, is an inverted foreskin, thats about 5 times deeper, wetter, and twice as slimy. So really, you shouldn't be talking."...
BWAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA....that's totally an awesome reply! I *have* to remember that one!
post #15 of 20
I have a friend who insisted on circ her son because her ONE experience with an intact penis left lint in her mouth. She says "His future girlfriends will thank me for it!"
post #16 of 20
Quote:
Originally Posted by pantufla View Post
I have a friend who insisted on circ her son because her ONE experience with an intact penis left lint in her mouth. She says "His future girlfriends will thank me for it!"
I hope she insists on circing her girls because when they wipe they get lint that can be left in a guy's mouth. Her future boyfriends will thank her for it.



post #17 of 20
Other than the fact that she even thought about your son's penis in that way...talk about gross!! It's just more proof that foreskin is a shallow woman deterrent!
post #18 of 20
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ann-Marita View Post
Maybe you could point out that a foreskin makes an eccellent shallow woman filter.
I would say she made that point better than any of us ever could. It really is absurd. I'm more shocked that she would think that is an acceptable thing to discuss with someone else's husband.
post #19 of 20
Quote:
Originally Posted by perspective View Post
. Whenever I hear a woman say that an intact penis is gross, I want to say "well all a vagina is, is an inverted foreskin, thats about 5 times deeper, wetter, and twice as slimy. So really, you shouldn't be talking."
laughup That was priceless!
post #20 of 20
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tinker View Post
I would say she made that point better than any of us ever could. It really is absurd. I'm more shocked that she would think that is an acceptable thing to discuss with someone else's husband.

ummmm... exactly what I was thinking!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: The Case Against Circumcision
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Health › The Case Against Circumcision › A Nurse Hath Offended Me