Mothering › Forums › Breastfeeding › Lactivism › On the topic of "donor milk" replacing formula
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

On the topic of "donor milk" replacing formula  

post #1 of 14
Thread Starter 
The thread regarding formula being available only by prescription got me thinking. Pardon my rambling as this may not even make sense. If that were the case and donor milk was the "option" where would all this donor milk come from?

I'm a full time work out of the house mommy bfing my 3rd child. (#1 bf until 10 months when I moved her to formula because it was impossible to maintain a supply with the job I was at which required me to travel overnight 3 out of 5 days a week.......that i made it to 10 months was a miracle. #2 bf until 22 months when my milk must have changed late in my pregancy w/#3. #3 is 7 months old and will wean when he's ready. Thankfully, I no longer travel for a living.

Having had to pump for my kids while I work I can tell you that it is a huge challenge for me to make sure I'm doing all the right things to keep a healthy supply. I pumped from day 1 to build a monster stash and pump 4 times a day at the office. That being said, I don't have a single spare ounce to "donate." I hoard breast milk because I know, eventually, my child will need it.

I find it amazing and truly a wonderful gift that so many women are able to donate milk. So incredibly generous.

If, however, formula was not easily available, the supply of "donor" milk would not come close to meeting the needs of babies who's mommas just can't get the ounces together as easily (and it isn't easy) as I am.

Maybe I'm a cynic but I keep invisioning women getting jobs as "milk mommies" not unlike....and pardon the vision but it's what I see when I think about it........a dairy farm. Even if every woman physically able to bf did bf so many things are tough to overcome when mom is separated from baby by work or other obstacles. (for the record I love my career and after a small trial stint of staying at home w/the kids I quickly learned that everyone in my family was happier if momma is working, so yes I do choose to work and am comfortable with that choice)

So, my question is: Do you think the supply of human milk would meet the demand of the babies who need it?
post #2 of 14
I have no problem with women being paid for milk. No problem at all.

That said, currently there's no way for supply to meet demand. It would have to be gradual.

And yes, it wouldn't be easy.

In *theory* I think it WOULD be possible to meet the demand for moms who truly can not make milk or make enough milk or have true medical issues.

Would there ever be enough for tons of moms to CHOOSE not to breastfeed? Probably not.

-Angela
post #3 of 14
Quote:
Originally Posted by alegna View Post
In *theory* I think it WOULD be possible to meet the demand for moms who truly can not make milk or make enough milk or have true medical issues.

Would there ever be enough for tons of moms to CHOOSE not to breastfeed? Probably not.

: There would have to be a much larger support network and better lactation eduction to keep people from THINKING they can't nurse or don't have enough milk after getting bad advice/improper support.
post #4 of 14
My issue would be "safe" milk - SO many kids have so many other issues these days. WOuld there be a stock of dairy free BM and a stock of soy-free Bm? What about top-8 free? Etc. I am able to donate (amazingly ssince I ama BFAR mama), but at best I think I managed a little over a gallon donated with DD....maybe a tad bit more. IN a year, with her unable to take any milk from when I wasn't on a TED (therefore I had no choice but to donate it). I think it would be ahrd to get enough safe donor milk even under the best of circumstances, but I think if more women had better resources, more would BF. And then there would be more of a pool for informal donaion....which is the only kind I ever did. Call the local MW and she callsher mamas in need to come get it
post #5 of 14
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kierdan'sMom View Post
My issue would be "safe" milk - SO many kids have so many other issues these days. WOuld there be a stock of dairy free BM and a stock of soy-free Bm? What about top-8 free? Etc. I am able to donate (amazingly ssince I ama BFAR mama), but at best I think I managed a little over a gallon donated with DD....maybe a tad bit more. IN a year, with her unable to take any milk from when I wasn't on a TED (therefore I had no choice but to donate it). I think it would be ahrd to get enough safe donor milk even under the best of circumstances, but I think if more women had better resources, more would BF. And then there would be more of a pool for informal donaion....which is the only kind I ever did. Call the local MW and she callsher mamas in need to come get it
Yes, specialized milk could still be a problem. And in some of those cases a medical formula would still be needed. Formula has its place, and severe allergies can be one of those places.

-Angela
post #6 of 14
Well even just safe milk in terms of no drugs (and I mean prescription, OTC, etc.). Theres just such a huge difference between formula which is essentially one recipe all the time (Hopefully!!) and BM which changes from minute to minute and mother to mother. None of the moms I donated to cared if I took a couple ibuprofen or a benadryl if I needed it. But were it for my child (Without her food allergies obviously!) I wouldn't want milk containing tylenol as she's allergic....And that would be a harder little thing to screen for. Or moms with a family history of peanut allergy who wanted peanut free milk.

Don't get me wrong. I want it to work, but anymore it seems there are soo many variables that would make it hard to actually make it doable. I'm glad that at least with Kyler having to wean, another mamas baby was able to have several days of good fatty mamas milk as I pump weaned!
post #7 of 14
I am interested in this from a histroical perspective- and I am guessing the key is that a lot of babies died??? Because say 200-300 years ago, if you c/wouldn't nurse and you were middle class and up, you got a wet nurse, and as I understand if you were poor and couldn't nurse your baby died or you had a sister or friend nurse. So even if you say that 10% of babies died 300 years ago due to nutrition issues, that is still enough bmilk for 90% of babies.
post #8 of 14
I would do it. :
post #9 of 14
I think it's mostly SAHM that have plenty of milk to donate. I used to nurse Timmy on one side, and hold a cup under the other side. It would just run out. Then when I outgrew that I could pump on one side, and nurse on the other.....and get 10 oz, just from one side. At first I was doing it to build up emergency stash, then I was doing it for a friend's baby. I have her more than her son could take becuase I just pumped every time my son nursed (unless I was out of the house).
post #10 of 14
Quote:
Originally Posted by moondiapers;11184415[B
]I think it's mostly SAHM that have plenty of milk to donate[/B]. I used to nurse Timmy on one side, and hold a cup under the other side. It would just run out. Then when I outgrew that I could pump on one side, and nurse on the other.....and get 10 oz, just from one side. At first I was doing it to build up emergency stash, then I was doing it for a friend's baby. I have her more than her son could take becuase I just pumped every time my son nursed (unless I was out of the house).
Not to mention women who miscarry relatively late.
post #11 of 14
I'm a milk donor and plan to continue.
I do think it'd be interesting to see how to provide allergy free milk in a checkable way- not just the honor system.
post #12 of 14
Aw I would love to be a milk donor. But as far as I know there's nowhere in Arizona that does that. I looked into it a bit.

I have several 1-3 oz bags of milk in the freezer and I kinda don't think they will ever get used... My son doesn't really take a bottle. You can kinda coax him to take half an ounce over the period of about 40 minutes but that's hardly a feeding. He is 3 months. :P The last time his daddy tried he kept sucking Daddy's thumb in between gulps. We think he likes to taste the skin since he is used to the breast? Haha I dunno.

But I can't imagine how heartbroken I would be as a mama who was dead set on breastfeeding, couldn't because of medical issues, and couldn't afford breastmilk because it was more expensive than formula. There should be a way for mom's who can't breastfeed to obtain donor milk at little to no cost.
post #13 of 14
Teyu,

You can find a real person to donate your milk to (no middleman) on Milkshare.com. Maybe there's a family in your area that needs milk!
post #14 of 14
Quote:
Originally Posted by MaClaire View Post
Teyu,

You can find a real person to donate your milk to (no middleman) on Milkshare.com. Maybe there's a family in your area that needs milk!
Oh cool. I am having troubles with this site though. Every link up at the top links to http://milkshare.birthingforlife.com/ and I can't get through to the Share/Find Milk link? Weird.

ETA: Nevermind. Something with my Adblock was wonky and I couldn't view the pulldown menus without disabling Adblock. Thanks for the site! I will look into this.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Lactivism
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Breastfeeding › Lactivism › On the topic of "donor milk" replacing formula