Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Gma favoring one twin over the other? WWYD?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Gma favoring one twin over the other? WWYD?  

post #1 of 14
Thread Starter 
My MIL has always favored Kaytlin over Alivea. For instance tonite, my mom, MIL, the girls and myself were in the backyard playing on the swingset. The girls were sliding on the slide and my mom was lifting them up so they could go down (its a big swingset and they need a little help yet) and my MIL was standing at the base of the slide. Every time Kaytlin would slide down, MIL would make funny noises and faces and then pick her up, swing her in the air and walk her over to my mom. She did nothing with Alivea, not one single thing. There have been many other times she has shown favortism over one twin. Whenever she gives them a bath, she always baths and dresses Kaytlin. Whenever they are playing, she is very attentive to Kaytlin and doesnt interact much with Alivea. My dh and I arent sure what to do. I grew up with my parents favoring my brother and absolutely refuse to allow my kids the hurt that can cause. We arent sure if we should say anything or ? Guess we were hoping for that "once they get older it will change" but it hasnt. WWYD?

BTW, my twins are 26 months old.
post #2 of 14
I don't have anything other than sympathy to give.

Do you have any indication why? My MIL favors girls. DH and his brothers felt that way as children, and I see it with the grandchildren. DD is the only granddaughter they see regularly, and she definitely dotes on her more than DS or my nephews. I have no idea why. Luckily in our case, DS is usually playing with my nephews, so I'm not sure he notices.
post #3 of 14
Thread Starter 
The only thing that I can think of is b/c Kaytlin is more of a tom boy. My MIL was dissappointed when she found out we were having girls, she always wanted a grandson. And since Kaytlin is more like the "boy" over the two, maybe thats why? But that just seems silly to me....

Edited: Also the fact that Kaytlin acts and looks more like her father then Alivea does. Alivea is my twin in both looks and personality and Kaytlin is the same with her father, so maybe thats why? I dont know, I'm grasping at straws here.....
post #4 of 14
why not just ask her? do you think you can confront her without getting nasty mad?
post #5 of 14
My mother favors her grandkids who are able/willing/like to sit still and do puzzles. She pays much less attention to the grandkids who prefer to run around and play other things.

Some people are drawn to certain personalilty traits. I would bring it up with her. She might not realize that she's doing it.
post #6 of 14
Quote:
Originally Posted by angie7 View Post
Edited: Also the fact that Kaytlin acts and looks more like her father then Alivea does. Alivea is my twin in both looks and personality and Kaytlin is the same with her father, so maybe thats why? I dont know, I'm grasping at straws here.....
Ok, off topic for a second, but how can your twins be identical, but one looks like you and one like thier dad?

Ok, my kids aren't twins, but we have the same thing going on with both my parents. Of course, they favour the older one, because we moved away right after the younger one was born, and they haven't gotten to spend as much time with him as his brother, but it is pretty sad sometimes when we are all together. Or even when we aren't. My dad has called at least every 3 days to talk to my oldest on the phone since he could say only a few words. The younger has a vocabulary that far outstrips the one his brother had at the same age, but Dad still only calls for the older brother. When we are all together, he asks the older one to go for walks and shows him stuff, but not the younger, even though he is more interested, and he favours Grandpa while the older one favours Grandma. He gets so hurt when Grandpa excludes him, but my dad just doesn't think to include him. It hurts me too, on his behalf. All I can say to you is that you need to tell your MIL that her actions are hurting her grand daughter, because she probably doesn't even realize what she is doing. Good luck.
post #7 of 14
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Girlymomwithsons View Post
Ok, off topic for a second, but how can your twins be identical, but one looks like you and one like thier dad?
Most people cant tell them apart, but anyone who is around them enough can. They are ID, but not mirror image twins. Its mostly just the shape of their face. Kaytlin is a little more oval and Alivea's is more rounded like mine. They both have blonde hair and blue eyes...Here's a pic of them

Alivea (left) & Kaytlin (right)

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v4...ver5/00762.jpg
post #8 of 14
Oh my goodness, they sure are cute! Is this something your DH can bring up with his mother? It seems like you'd want to confront this now rather than later. I'm so sorry you're even put in this situation. Who could possibly resist either of your cuties?!

Leslie
mom to DS (08/03) and DD (09/05)
post #9 of 14
one of my children has always been favored over the other two. It is quite simply her personality. She just knew how to get positive attention from anyone and keep it.

perhaps your MIL just cklicks more with one of the girls. It would make sense.

However, she is a grown up and owes her grandchildren equal amounts of love and affection even if it comes more natrually to one than the other. Can you think of a gentle way to say "I know your relationship with K is really easy but A is feeling a little left out. can you work a little harder to find something special between the two of you." obviously those words are not the ones to use. . . .
post #10 of 14
Look like you are going hard on the non-favoured twin for a couple of days. She'll jump at the chance to dote on her then, to "save" her from Mommy.

Worked for us. Sadly.

We had this problem with my MIL. My first daughter takes after her and her family, and GMIL LOVED her. My second daughter looks like me, and takes after my family. So she was far far far less entranced with her.

Total not cool.

Thankfully between "siding" with DD2 "against" Mommy help, AND the fact that the little minx is a perceptive and manipulative little thing who watches intently for what people think is "cute" and then sets up oppurtunities to do those things. In the long run GMIL was going to be felled by her.

Quote:
Originally Posted by angie7 View Post
The only thing that I can think of is b/c Kaytlin is more of a tom boy. My MIL was dissappointed when she found out we were having girls, she always wanted a grandson. And since Kaytlin is more like the "boy" over the two, maybe thats why? But that just seems silly to me....

Edited: Also the fact that Kaytlin acts and looks more like her father then Alivea does. Alivea is my twin in both looks and personality and Kaytlin is the same with her father, so maybe thats why? I dont know, I'm grasping at straws here.....
post #11 of 14
Can you arrange for Gramma to spend time seperately with them, to "get to know" Alivea better? I don't have twins (or even children near the same age), but I was in a slightly similar situation at one point. My Father-in-Law literally worships the ground my stepdaughter (she's 7) walks on. She can do no wrong. My son (he's 12), though... well, it sure looked like he was scape-goated for a while there and it was really hurting him to see the difference. Anyways, the final straw was, about two years ago, both children were swinging on the swing set in my Father-in-Law's back yard. My little girl decided she wanted to hang and go across the top of the swing set (kinda like monkey bars), but she could only go half way across, because my son was swinging on the other side. She decided she wanted to go all the way across, so my Father-in-Law actually stopped the swing my son was swinging on and told him to get up so his sister could monkey across. When my son refused to get up, my Father-in-Law physically removed him from the swing and told him how selfish he was for not letting his siter monkey across. () My first reaction was to make sure my Father-in-Law never saw my son again!!! But what my Hubby and I did was, we started to (very disreetly) limit the time my Father-in-Law spent with my little girl and the time my Father-in-Law spent with both children together and (also very disceetly) to arrange situations where my Father-in-Law would have to spend time with my son. (This could backfire in some situations, but it worked in my situation.) In the end, my Father-in-Law "got to know" my son and now they actually have a pretty good relationship. My Father-in-Law still prefers my little girl ('Cause she's a girl? 'Cause she's younger? 'Cause she's very social, whereas my son is not? 'Cause she's his "blood" Grandchild? 'Cause she's obedient and eventempered, whereas my son is not? 'Cause she's named after his deceased wife?), but he's much more discreet about his preferences to my little girl, so most the time, the children don't notice and he is much more aware of both children's feelings.
post #12 of 14
Ugh. Inlaws. My mil favors girls, always has. James was pretty much sent away to live with relatives while they kept his sisters at home. It wasn't pretty.
Now she buys Amethyst gifts and treats, and Asheby is completely ignored. I hate it. Thank goodness we rarely see them.
post #13 of 14
Off topic.

They are beautiful! The funny thing was, without looking to see which was which, I guessed correctly, just by your description in your earlier post.

Anyway.. I can't understand why she would favor one child over the other. I suggest talking to her. It's possible that she has NO clue she's doing it. Ive done it with students or daycare kids and never even noticed it til someone pointed it out.

Also, it's possible that she feels like YOU favor one child, so she thinks it's up to her to favor the other. Maybe she feels like she's balancing the scales. (I'm saying you do, but she might have it in her head that you do)
post #14 of 14
Thread Starter 
Thank you to everyone that commented on how pretty my girls are!

I think we may just bring it up with her when she is doing it. Like the slide instance, just say "Alivea would like for you to do that too, Gma" maybe with little subtle hints she will get it. If that doesnt work, a more direct approach will have to happen...

Thanks for the suggestion about my MIL taking them for one on one but uh, no not going to happen My MIL is very accident prone and the kids are always getting hurt when she is around. Its like she doesnt think when she does things so all of us have to stay close and keep an eye on her. I'm surprised my dh survived long enough to be an adult in her care She also panicks easily and gives them things that they dont need at the slightest sound. We went out to breakfast with his family on Mother's day. The girls were super hungry, we put them in their chairs and gave them some crayons to play with. They were slightly annoyed, just making little whining noises so I was getting them a little snack out of the diaper bag and when I looked up, she gave them ink pens Needless to say, they had ink from head to toe, all over their clothes I was so pissed. We just ate and left...Why would you give a 2 year old an ink pen?? When they were 1 and we were visiting her house, I went to the bathroom and came back and she gave them pencils and they were running around the house with them! A 1 year old? Geez......
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Parenting
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Gma favoring one twin over the other? WWYD?