Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Gentle Discipline › fighting fighting fighting!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

fighting fighting fighting! - Page 3  

post #41 of 46
Quote:
Originally Posted by allgirls View Post
Well it's not about how they get along in that moment..it's about not letting the intensity build into a bigger, more intense fight most of the time.

And I never ever ever in my entire life told my kids it doesn't matter how they feel. I just neutralise the situation first because letting each of them tell me their side of the story, each trying to out yell the other so I believe them only makes the fight worse.
In our home, neutralizing the situation usually involves having kids take a break from each other. But it often also includes comforting one or more kids, giving hugs, listening and validating feelings--helping kids calm down, and know that their feelings matter. It's just the problem-solving part that we save for when everyone is calm enough to think more clearly.

Better to step in, have everyone take a little break, help everyone get calm than to let it mushroom into something much bigger. It's much harder to deal with things when everyone gets very, very worked up.
post #42 of 46
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kessed View Post
The problem with do it out of ear shot of the other child is that then both kids think they're right.

And that leads to even more problems. (which is why my parents claim they wanted to stay out of it entirely).
Well generally a fight starts because each person thinks they are right

But I believe that sympathising with someone and understanding their point of view is completely different than agreeing that they are right. And in my discussions with the kids I generally talk about how they feel about what happened instead of what happened. They get to tell their side and then I validate their feelings because no matter who is right and who is wrong both of their feelings matter greatly.
post #43 of 46
Sorry--I need to figure out how to mark threads without posting. This thread was a fascinating read and I want to be able to find it again in the future (like if I ever have another kiddo...) Thanks everyone for taking the time to write out your thoughts and examples!!!
post #44 of 46
Quote:
Originally Posted by Carlyle View Post
Sorry--I need to figure out how to mark threads without posting. This thread was a fascinating read and I want to be able to find it again in the future (like if I ever have another kiddo...) Thanks everyone for taking the time to write out your thoughts and examples!!!
I agree..it was a good discussion.

post #45 of 46
I just wanted to say thank you to everyone on this thread. This has been hugely helpful to me as what Kessed has described of her own experience is what I have been concerned about with SWR and Jason's Breathing on Me books. I read both books and really like them but worried about the things you have said, Kessed.

Thank you allgirls and sledg for sharing your experiences and perspectives...this has helped me to digest the material so much more deeply and meaningfully. I feel much more confident in the approach that I've taken so far but it is hard with the ages of my kids now - one is 5, the other 2.

Personally, I've found the sibling stuff to be the most challenging. I think my kids get along really well, for the most part. But one is a toddler and exhibits some typical (annoying) toddler behavior and that's hard on my 5yo. Allgirls, it sounds like your kids are similar ages. How did you do this with a toddler? I struggle with my toddler pulling hair and hitting...it's really hard because my older child can't really use his skills that effectively yet with his brother because of the younger one's limited skills at this point.

Anyway, thanks everyone...very helpful stuff!
post #46 of 46
Quote:
Originally Posted by swampangel View Post
Allgirls, it sounds like your kids are similar ages. How did you do this with a toddler? I struggle with my toddler pulling hair and hitting...it's really hard because my older child can't really use his skills that effectively yet with his brother because of the younger one's limited skills at this point.

Anyway, thanks everyone...very helpful stuff!

My kids are similar in age...my littlest will be 3 in October and her sister will be 5 in July.

What I found was that at that age I had to be right there as soon as I sensed it escalating..not to take sides or interfere but to make sure there was no hitting going on. My little one was a bit of a slugger around the 18mos mark to 24 mos maybe, but not terribly so and generally if she was well fed and not tired they were absolutely fine..so I watched the clock a lot to make sure snacks were on time etc. and naps were paramount.

I also spent a lot of the little one's naptimes with my older daughter and if there had been problems we'd talk stuff over, a lot of "Martina is frustrating when she...Isn't she" and me letting her get this stuff out. We talked a lot about patience and that she was just two. I taught her about trading toys...I explained that she didn't understand taking turns at 2 and that we could help her learn. I did a lot of getting her involved in the problem solving and let her vent her issues.

One advantage I had is that I have very verbal girls. They are both very expressive and can get a lot of their frustration out that way. My littlest one can string together a large paragraph quite well..that is a HUGE advantage.

If we were having a really tough day Marti got to ride in the Ergo a lot which is like baby atavan for her..it really relaxes her

It's a process and it takes time to develop. The key I found in the book was to get involved as soon as it starts to bother YOU. Don't let it escalate. Get in then and seperate and don't wait for the intensity to go up. Of course sometimes you miss but it really cuts down on it getting out of hand.

It does take some practice. It didn't flow naturally at first but now it's just the way I do things..it's like anything new.

I like the way SWR was about allowing children to verbalise their emotions and I incorporate that as well.

My older one said just yesterday "I wish sissy was 4" and I said "then you would be 6" and she said "no I wish she was 4 when I was 4 so she could just understand"

kids are so cute!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Gentle Discipline
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Gentle Discipline › fighting fighting fighting!