Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Ages and Stages › The Childhood Years › Help with an extremely picky eater
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Help with an extremely picky eater  

post #1 of 21
Thread Starter 
It seems I'm encountering a lot of kids this weekend that I'm not used to.

My dd's second cousins (actually my NIECE'S kids... so my sister's daughter's young ones) are here to spend a few days with her.

There are many things about them that break my heart. Perhaps one day I'll post about it, but the immediate problem at hand is this.

The 7 year old says she will eat only chicken mcnuggets, french fries, potato chips and hot dogs.

NONE of these foods are foods we eat, nor do we want to introduce them to our adventurous 6 year old with a palate that is set on "explore" (beside the fact that we simply do not eat fast food on principle). I'm convinced my niece will eat other things but I just cannot think of what to try. Tacos were vetoed as were spaghetti, grilled chicken, eggs of any kind, hamburgers, homemade chicken nuggets, and fish of any sort. Vegetables, even corn (which I though every kid would eat) are nixed. She would not eat my homemade yeast rolls either. She ate a few strawberries, but would not eat my fruit smoothie popsicles (wanted those sugar water tubes).

She is here for 3 more days. We are meat eaters, but the cornerstone of our diets are fresh fruit. We'll typically eat a light meal and have a couple pieces of fruit afterwards. We also love our fresh veggies, especially those that are coming on in our garden. Tonight I made a pasta primavera and she wouldn't touch it. Lunch was grilled cheese sandwiches (!!!) and she wouldn't eat them. I even bought an extra loaf of whole wheat white for them (that's what my mom eats and she lives with us). Finally I convinced her to eat a peanut butter and jelly sandwich, but she would eat only a few bites from each center.

I'm at my wit's end trying to figure out what she might eat. I am not willing to compromise my principles, but somewhere in there, a home-cooked, non-processed meal must exist that she'll try. I am grateful for any and all suggestions.
post #2 of 21
my niece was in town last week for an entire week visiting. she's 8. she's also a VERY picky eater. i mealplan everything and my meals are actually very kid-friendly. my niece didn't want to try any of it though (which was a pain because i mealplan on a budget).

i accomodated her and fed her the foods she wanted though (hot dogs a lot, etc.). she's not my child. she was my guest though, and i wanted her stay with us to be pleasant. my children still ate what i had planned with no issues. we had a lovely visit. hth!
post #3 of 21
Well since she will (even though reluctantly) eat a PB&J I would always let her make herself one once the meal was done. She won't starve. . .she will either try what you make or make the pb&j later. Since you only have 3 more days with her, I would stress about the nutrition factor of a continuous diet of pb&j.

I also wouldn't ask if something would be ok, I would just make what I made and serve her a plate. If she said she didn't like something, I would say that we all have different tastes--she isn't required to like what you like. And then I would say that after the meal was done, she could make the sandwich.

food ideas though--home fries with regular and sweet potato, home made pizza, offer dips to go with the veggies

Amy
post #4 of 21
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by elizawill View Post
i accomodated her and fed her the foods she wanted though (hot dogs a lot, etc.). she's not my child. she was my guest though, and i wanted her stay with us to be pleasant. my children still ate what i had planned with no issues. we had a lovely visit. hth!
This would totally not fly in our house. Dd cannot have processed food because of food sensitivities. She has asked me several times for hot dogs and I've explained that she cannot have the ingredients.

I will not bring hot dogs into this house and give them to my niece just because she's picky (absolutely NO food issues or allergies, just stubbornness) and deny my own child right in front of her. Niece will just have to live off of two bites of pb & j 3 times a day.

Pizza was nixed, too, pp. Potatoes are considered a vegetable unless in French Fry form. Thanks for the suggestions, though.
post #5 of 21
hmm, i'm not sure then. sounds like an uncomfortable situation for everyone. my sister and i discussed my niece's diet a day or two prior to her arriving...so i had some time to plan for it - plus i knew my sister was telling me that natalie was a picky eater so i could be aware of it and prepared. my kids and i didn't power struggle over my niece eating differently from us...it just wasn't an issue because the food i make is kid friendly and yummy. my niece is just weird - lol....totally kidding of course.

i think eating pb&j for a few days will definitely not hurt your niece i wish i had better advice for you. try to just have fun!!! enjoy your visit!
post #6 of 21
Call me a meanie and I'm sure lots of moms here will be horrified but I have 1 simple rule.

I cook it, you eat it.

You choose not to eat it, you go hungry. Period.

I don't bargain, or cater to picky children. I make food that is not weird or out there and it tastes good. It sounds like that child has been fed a steady diet of crap and needs her taste buds reprogrammed. Your job is to offer healthy food, if she chooses not to eat it then its not your problem. If she gets hungry enough she will eat it (you said there were no other issues) and if she goes hungry a few days so be it, it won't kill her or even really hurt her but it will drive home a point and may even open the door to discussions about rudeness and not being willing to try new foods that her mother needs to talk to her about.
post #7 of 21
I believe it's our job to prepare healthy, variety-filled meals, their job to eat it.

Never take on both jobs - you'll lose at least one side.
post #8 of 21
Quote:
I will not bring hot dogs into this house and give them to my niece just because she's picky (absolutely NO food issues or allergies, just stubbornness) and deny my own child right in front of her. Niece will just have to live off of two bites of pb & j 3 times a day.

I am not trying to be snarky here, but how do you KNOW there are no issues.? I mean, obviously there ARE food issues, she only eats 4/5 things.

Feed her what she eats. I mean, if you had my ds over, he is very very picky, and you had the mindset..eat what i cook like PP up there, he would not eat. Period. He would and has gone days without eating, and that, as a parent would PISS me off.

So if she doesnt eat what you cook, offer her what she will eat. You dont have to feed YOUR kids that stuff, and if they ask for it, tell them no. You are their parent and can do what you want with your own kids, but not with someone elses. How does your nieces parents handle her eating? Find that out--and do it.

I get very mad when people try to treat picky eaters as stubborn and not respect them as people. Rant over there!
post #9 of 21
Quote:
Originally Posted by Satori View Post
If she gets hungry enough she will eat it (you said there were no other issues) and if she goes hungry a few days so be it, it won't kill her or even really hurt her but it will drive home a point and may even open the door to discussions about rudeness and not being willing to try new foods that her mother needs to talk to her about.
imo, the child isn't being rude. the child is simply being a child. her mother should address this - i agree, but i just don't think the child is the one to blame. a visit should be enjoyable and welcoming. we're only talking about a few days here. i think letting the child eat pb&j is accomodating enough, especially if the op's own children have food allergies - but to refuse to make anything other than what i have cooked isn't being considerate of my guest, especially knowing in advance that my guest will not eat it.

anyway, all i know is when my best friend, my parents, my in-laws etc. come in town - i purchase things in advance that i know they enjoy (diet coke, half & half, beer, etc). these are all things i do not normally buy for my own family, but i'm comfortable accomodating my guests.
post #10 of 21
I do have a picky eater (and nieces). I tend to not ask the kid more than I have to about what they eat because I don't want to encourage them to think too much about it. Once they've stated they don't like something, they become much less likely to try it. So I'll check with the parents, find out what brands of ketchup, or whatever, the child likes (our kids don't switch brands of ketchup easily. I think they get surprised by the difference and then their taste buds go on guard).

I will get foods especially for my guests but I've always been able to find compromises about what foods I feel good feeding someone and what they like. For instance, frozen Bell and Evans brand chicken nuggets are good. They are white meat, raised with no antibiotics, even come in gluten free variety. You can also buy frozen french fries and bake them. These things cost a little more, but it's not too bad if it is just for a short visit.
post #11 of 21
Quote:
Originally Posted by Transitions View Post
I am not trying to be snarky here, but how do you KNOW there are no issues.? I mean, obviously there ARE food issues, she only eats 4/5 things.

Feed her what she eats. I mean, if you had my ds over, he is very very picky, and you had the mindset..eat what i cook like PP up there, he would not eat. Period. He would and has gone days without eating, and that, as a parent would PISS me off.

So if she doesnt eat what you cook, offer her what she will eat. You dont have to feed YOUR kids that stuff, and if they ask for it, tell them no. You are their parent and can do what you want with your own kids, but not with someone elses. How does your nieces parents handle her eating? Find that out--and do it.

I get very mad when people try to treat picky eaters as stubborn and not respect them as people. Rant over there!
I agree quite a bit with this. If my son went to the niece's house he would be considered a picky eater. He has tried hotdogs, chicken nuggets and all that and hates them. He won't eat meat and also won't eat any foods that are mixed together (soup, stew, casseroles, pizza, etc.). For him it is a sensory issue. He eats plenty of veggies (but only while they are still frozen) and he would happily live on wheat bread (thinks white bread is yucky because it sticks to the roof of his mouth), string cheese and fruit, but only if the last 2 items are cold. If he was a guest in someone's house I would not expect them to cook a tailor made meal for him, but please stick one thing he is known to like on his plate. So I agree with the posters who said, if she likes pb&j then she can eat that if she wants. Also you can make homemade chicken nuggets that are healthier than store bought and just serve them with zero explanation. Though you might want to add extra salt to hers because that is probably part of her palate craving due to all the processed food she eats.
post #12 of 21
Quote:
Originally Posted by straighthaircurly View Post
I agree quite a bit with this. If my son went to the niece's house he would be considered a picky eater. He has tried hotdogs, chicken nuggets and all that and hates them. He won't eat meat and also won't eat any foods that are mixed together (soup, stew, casseroles, pizza, etc.). For him it is a sensory issue. He eats plenty of veggies (but only while they are still frozen) and he would happily live on wheat bread (thinks white bread is yucky because it sticks to the roof of his mouth), string cheese and fruit, but only if the last 2 items are cold. If he was a guest in someone's house I would not expect them to cook a tailor made meal for him, but please stick one thing he is known to like on his plate. So I agree with the posters who said, if she likes pb&j then she can eat that if she wants. Also you can make homemade chicken nuggets that are healthier than store bought and just serve them with zero explanation. Though you might want to add extra salt to hers because that is probably part of her palate craving due to all the processed food she eats.

This doesn't appear to be a sensory issue but simply a kid who has been fed nothing but crap so thats all she will eat. I believe the OP said she did make chicken nuggets and the child refused them. Yes I agree she needs to talk to the mother but its not up to her to provide those crap foods. If her mother knows her daughter only is willing to eat crap then her mother should have either brought food for her or provided money to buy it. I know in my home were hanging on by the skin of our teeth and something as simple as buying french fries could send our bills into a tail spin our budget is so tight.
post #13 of 21
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Transitions View Post
I am not trying to be snarky here, but how do you KNOW there are no issues.? I mean, obviously there ARE food issues, she only eats 4/5 things.

Feed her what she eats. I mean, if you had my ds over, he is very very picky, and you had the mindset..eat what i cook like PP up there, he would not eat. Period. He would and has gone days without eating, and that, as a parent would PISS me off.

So if she doesnt eat what you cook, offer her what she will eat. You dont have to feed YOUR kids that stuff, and if they ask for it, tell them no. You are their parent and can do what you want with your own kids, but not with someone elses. How does your nieces parents handle her eating? Find that out--and do it.

I get very mad when people try to treat picky eaters as stubborn and not respect them as people. Rant over there!
First of all there are no issues. You will not convince me in a million years that there is some special eating issue that requires all meals to be consumed at McDonald's.

I actually asked her older sister how to handle this. She said that their mother just goes to McDonald's to get her nuggets and fries. I'm sorry, but I won't do that. I don't agree ethically with the way they produce their food and I won't spend my money there. And I sure as hell am not going to spend $10/ day for fries and nuggets for one picky, stubborn, indulged and spoiled child.

I make lovely nuggets from chicken breast with a nicely seasoned panko breading, sauteed, not fried that I keep in the freezer. She refused to eat the homemade version. I'm sorry, but if you will only eat McDonald's nuggets, and not homemade, that's not some sensory issue... that's being stubborn.

I'm totally with Satori on this one. We have peanut butter, we have jelly (homemade, but don't tell my niece that) and we have bread. She won't starve.
post #14 of 21
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by straighthaircurly View Post
For him it is a sensory issue.

<snip>

Also you can make homemade chicken nuggets that are healthier than store bought and just serve them with zero explanation. Though you might want to add extra salt to hers because that is probably part of her palate craving due to all the processed food she eats.
If your child has true issues then that's another story. This niece would not even TRY my homemade chicken nuggets.
post #15 of 21

Need advice with getting through to stepson

I am new to this site, and not sure if I am going about this posting thing correctly, so, my apologies in advance....

Here's a little back story... My husband and I live in Fl with our 15 mo. old twins, and my husband's son from his first marriage lives in Maine with his mother. (My husband's ex-wife) We only see my stepson (who's 8 yrs old) during the summer months, and every other Christmas. I have been "on the scene" for three years now, in regards to my stepson. But my friendship and presence in my husband's life has spanned over half our lives. We (my husband and I) have similar parenting viewpoints, but agree on most issues - comprising the ones we find ourself disagreeing on. My husband and his ex-wife have very DIFFERENT parenting approaches, and it is resulting in what I believe to be the "deterioration" of their son.

She, (the ex) lives in a 1 bedroom condo, less than 500 sq ft of living space, and uses the couch as her own bedroom. My stepson has the only bedroom in the place, with no room for a table to eat his meals in the kitchen, or comfortable place to unwind, or focus on his homework. Where we live in Fl is no mansion, but we have created a space for him that is his own, with a real bed and storage for his favorite things. He has his own bedroom, and private hideaways for his favorite toys and books - as we HAVE to be creative to outsmart the curious minds and prying hands of the two little ones under foot! All that being said, in the BEST of families, I can imagine that divorce is STILL difficult and every child needs reassurance and help understanding what is going on in their life, due to the changes their parents have made. But, in my stepson's case, it seems neither parent addressed the concerns he (my SS) may have had at the time of their divorce. They finalized their divorce in early 2003, and less than two years later, my husband's ex told him she was taking their son and moving to Maine. Not exactly a day's drive from Fl.... But, my husband said he wouldn't stop her. ( which he knows now was probably the wrong decision, but he honestly thought she would get up there, realize that her son's whole support system and bulk of his family were all in Fl and Ga, and she would eventually turn around and come back home) Well, it's four years later and they are still in Maine.

She (the ex) doesn't communicate with my husband on any issues regarding their son. She does lots of small things that drive me bonkers- I could go on and on - but I'll just list a few.... Due to her lax views on parenting (I suppose she thinks he's going to raise himself!), she hasn't instilled in him BASIC everyday practices that teach a child responsibility and overall confidence in his appearance or capabilities. While living under her roof, my stepson only receives three haircuts a year, goes to school with wrinkled clothes, and doesn't bathe or comb his hair on a daily basis. He is going into the third grade, and only first learned to tie his shoes LAST SUMMER, when I went out and bought him a pair of laced shoes. (he showed up on our doorstep with half a dozen pairs of Crocs and no REAL shoes) This summer when he arrived - yep, four pairs of Crocs, (even the ones with the fleece lining - like he'll need those for summers in Florida!) and one pair of Spiderman velcro latch tennis shoes one size too small. There's a major lack of common sense on his mother's part. Within the first week he was here this summer, my husband took him to get a haircut and I went out and bought him another pair of tied shoes. He told us his mom threw away the shoes we bought him last summer after he returned to Maine. Nice work, Mom.... He lacks overall pride in his appearance and thinks it's crazy that I expect him to bathe everyday that he's here!

I would love for someone to tell me I'm knit-picking, but I have another thing that really drives me crazy. When he arrived here for the summer, he had one humongous piece of luggage, and a backpack that he used as a carry-on for the plane ride. In that big piece of luggage were only about five days worth of clothing, and 26 stuffed animals. Most of them were those tiny Webkinz ones, but there were a few over sized ones that could've clearly stayed in Maine. If it were me, I think I would've let my son pick maybe his two favorite ones, and leave the rest behind. Doesn't his mother think about all the things he'll acquire while being here for three months? We now have no room to send him back with any new clothes that FIT, or any special things he gets on trips with us or mementos he wants to have from his time here. I told my husband a few days ago that maybe we should sit him (SS) down and tell him to pick his favorite one or two, and let him know we'd pack up the rest, and they would be waiting for him in Maine at the end of the summer. My husband thought it was harsh, and that his son might think he did something wrong and was being punished. I told him we could explain to him otherwise, but he wasn't receptive. I also think that it's not teaching my stepson any boundaries, if he's allowed to bring a caravan of toys with him everywhere he goes.

He has this one little animal, that he has named Little Black Bear. LBB has traveled with him on all the jaunts from Maine to Fl. This bear sleeps with him at night, and HAS to be sitting next to him when he watches tv or even plays a board game. As a little girl, I never had a specific security blanket, or doll, or Barbie - but I understand why some children do. Especially one that was ripped of his security when his parents divorced when he was only 4. That being said, I think he has a slightly unhealthy attachment to LBB. Last summer, (at age 7) my husband took him to see a movie, and we spent twenty minutes explaining to him that LBB couldn't go, too. I should've been able to say, "Hey sweetie, let's leave LBB behind", and it should've been OVER. My husband thought I was being mean by asking him to leave it at home, if it was something he loved so much. I thought they were both crazy, because we were talking about a two hour movie! I didn't understand why there were floods of tears over leaving it at home. My husband told me later that night that his son cried the whole way to the theater about not being able to take his bear. If it was me, I wouldn't have rewarded him with the movie at that point. I would've turned the car around and said that, "if he didn't dry it up and stop complaining, that there would be no movie." But, then again, my husband thinks I am sometimes too rough. My rationale is that he was not 3 or 4, he was 7. At some point, if not already, other kids would start to make fun of him for having this little stuffed animal with him all the time. Kids can be cruel, and I would hate for him to experience that. But, something tells me that if his mom is letting him go to school with shaggy, dirty bed-head, and wrinkled clothes - kids are ALREADY making fun of him!

And food. My nemesis at this point. His mother refers to him as a 'picky eater'. I blame his mother for creating a monster. I dread the day my little twins look at me and say they don't want to eat my food. But, boy, am I getting my practice with my stepson! In the short time he's been here this summer, I have watched him spit out my food, pretend to choke on it, and weave a tapestry - scattering it around his plate to have it appear that he's eaten it. I am so fed up. I have talked to him endless to get him to tell me what kinds of food he likes to eat. All I can come up with (from HIS mouth!) is that his mother never cooks, they eat hamburgers from a gas station around the corner almost every night, but manage to squeeze in child-favorites like pizza, french fries and chicken fingers. And, I'd been willing to bet that the SEVEN cavities he had last year came from the marshmallow fluff spread and peanut butter sandwiches his mother packs in his lunch everyday! I have informed him that although that MAY BE the food he's used top eating, he's going to be expected to eat, or at least TRY the food I put down for him. He's found ways to get around eating different fruits and veggies, and plays my husband like a fiddle. With me, there's no bargaining. I don't bribe him with dessert, or soda to get him to eat (much less finish!) the meals I cook for him. At this point, I know it is going to be very hard to "reprogram" the brain of a little boy who thinks the normal food I'm feeding him is horrible. I even played dumb in a recent email to his mother. I tactfully mentioned that his "taste buds were a lot different from last year" and asked her for some tips on his favorite dishes - instead of flat out saying, "stop feeding your kid crap, and show him what real food is!!" My mother-in-law lives just 2 miles away, and sees her grandson a lot during the time he's here. I've enlisted her help on getting him to change his eating habits. She makes his grilled chicken that he loves, with mashed potatoes and green beans. The poor woman makes it every time she visits with my SS! She has agreed to start subbing her green beans for carrots, and her potatoes for salad, or rice. Not that her original meal is bad for him, but just to get him tasting other things. And, to my chagrin, he eats it all - but because his beloved Grandma makes it! She could smear poop on toast, and he would think it was a delicacy!! I am not irritated with mother-in-law - I'm glad he's eating new things. My husband has supported me in my food efforts with his son, but I know he would love to let him leave the table without even trying veggies or salad. That way, a battle is avoided. But, we solve nothing that way. I am not giving up, though. I'm disguising veggie purees in other dishes, and starting with small amounts of new vegetables, to let him get his feet wet. As irritating as it is - I keep reminding myself, I can't be mad at my SS, but his mother is to blame for not feeding him healthier things. My husband enters the discussion, already defeated - saying that we can feed him good food and teach him to take care of himself, and comb his hair and brush his teeth, but if every time he goes back to Maine, his ex will not support or continue any of it - what good are we really doing? I disagree. I feel that as a parent, and a stepparent, it is our responsibility to make him feel good about himself, and take the best possible care of himself - from the food he puts in his body, to the clothes we put on his back.

I am trying hard to be a positive third party for my stepson, because I know we all love him here in Fl, and we are taking better care of him here than she is, in her shack in Maine. I am not very optimistic of the coming years, as he becomes older and hones his personality and overall attitude. I feel like he is going to be a handful as a teenager and I don't want the lax teachings of his mother to infest my household during the small amount of time he spends with us. I have tried to discuss my concerns with his mom, and talk to her as a fellow parent, and two people that both love her son and want what's best for him. But, as expected, she's like talking to a brick wall. I don't know what to do. I struggle with basic things like "yes sir and no ma'am" and down to picky eating and not cleaning up after himself. I am trying to wrap this up, but I do have to ask this. My husband was raised in Georgia, and I, in Florida. His ex is form Ga, put has been in Maine for almost five years now. Being form the South, I was always taught that you spoke to all elders, and anyone in a position of authority with "yes sir, no ma'am" and all that. As was my husband. We both still do it to this day, and plan on teaching that to our twins when they start talking. My SS, however, addresses everyone with, "yeah, nu-uh, okay, ..etc..." It drives me crazy. I correct him, and continue to reiterate the yes, no, ma'am and sir vocabulary. My husband says I shouldn't expect him to speak that way because it was a very "northern thing" not to. I told him he sounded ignorant by saying that, but, in all honesty, I have never lived up North, so I'm not sure if the lingo is more casual there. My only personal knowledge of it is from my dad, who grew up in Indiana in the 50's. According to him, his dad would've beat him upside the head if he actually addressed an elder WITHOUT saying sir or ma'am! So please, any ladies from the northern states, PLEASE enlighten me!! I have to imagine that no matter where in the US kids are brought up, any parent would want to be treated, and talked to, respectfully.

I am fairly new at being a stepmother, and just want to find a way to co-exist. And hopefully, to bridge the lack of continuity and structure he's receiving from his mother with the different value system his father and I have here. I would love input from anyone who's been there. I am determined to resolve this, and committed to not let it tax my marriage. It is already driving a wedge between my husband and I because he wants desperately for his son to just have fun during the small amount of time he does get to spend with us. And I want to teach him that fun, comes responsibility, and if you take care of yourself (by performing basic tasks like brushing your teeth and bathing everyday, and eating good food), you'll feel better about yourself and have more confidence. He lacks self-esteem and cries at the drop of a hat. He doesn't make eye contact and says he doesn't have many friends. I feel his mother is doing him a huge injustice, and I just want to show him that he CAN feel good about himself, and have fun being a kid. But, I have to find a way to do that without letting my personal feelings for my husband's ex-wife show to my stepson. I know I won't gain his trust or respect by downing the one person he is with the most. But, I don't feel my husband and I can successfully make any headway with his son, unless his mother is on board. And I can't exactly pick up the phone and attack the way she raises her son. I feel very stuck. Any advice is greatly appreciated. Thanks!!!!
post #16 of 21
sngmommy - You know, I can tell that you really care for your stepson but I do think you're a bit nit picky. My son is the same age (will be in 3rd grade in the fall) and I can tell you that aside from the very picky eating (that would be my 10 yo!), he is very much like your stepson. He could care less about taking a shower or combing his hair. He never wants a hair cut (his hair currently looks like Shaggy from Scooby Doo), can't tie his shoes yet and I could definitely see him packing up 26 stuffed animals as part of his "essential" travel gear.

I'm sure this situation is hard for you (I've never been a step-parent so I can only imagine). But just remember that although this boy is much older than your twins, he's still a little boy. All the stuff you described is pretty normal for 8 yo. You can't blame all this stuff on his mom, that isn't fair.

There is also a Blended and Step Family Parenting group here, maybe you could get some good ideas there: http://www.mothering.com/discussions...play.php?f=333
post #17 of 21
I agree with the PP, you are being nit picky and I will go further and say, overly tough on this little boy. I have an 8 year picky eater, he wouldn't eat junk like hamburgers or hot dogs though -- and the thought of having to eat strange (to him) food would cause him tremendous anxiety, so good for DSS's g'ma for making food he likes and enjoys. My boy isn't much into showers either, but he will when asked, and he certainly looks like Shaggy (check out his picture) and maybe has one hair cut a year, because I happen to think that long, shaggy hair looks cute on 8 year old boys. . While DS can tie laces, he prefers to shove his feet into Crocs (much quicker) unless he is playing soccer then they are a hindrance. I am sure his mother isn't the best mother in the word and certainly isn't up to your standards, but I am absolutely sure she loves him more than anything in the world, which at the end of the day is what counts.
post #18 of 21
While I certainly appreciate the feedback, I must be being misunderstood. What exactly, (from an outsider's opinion looking in) shows you I'm being overly tough on my stepson? I simply ask him to bathe everyday and comb his hair so I can see his handsome face. And, yes, kudos to my mother-in-law for feeding him food that he likes. However, he lives with me and my husband-not his grandma. So, when I put something on the table, I expect him to eat it. I'm not asking him to eat crazy, exotic food, or leaves and twigs, or anything like that. We're talking, chicken and yellow rice, three cheese tortellini, and pot roast with scalloped potatoes. I remember that it was that simple when I was growing up, and I guess parents today give their children freedom in ALL their choices these days. It's just not something I am used to. I remember growing up in a house with three children, and my mom made one dinner. One. Not a different thing for each child. And there was no swaying us with dessert or anything like that. And, if we had the audacity to tell my mom we didn't want to eat her food, (after she'd worked all day, then came home and ran the house and cooked us dinner!) that was fine, but it was understood that was all we'd have the opportunity to eat until breakfast the next day. I understand that some kids are picky eaters, and you have to try different approaches. I ask him to cook with me. To pick one of two choices for veggies with the meal, and I don't give him adult sized portions that will overwhelm him. I am doing the best I can, without any help from his mother.

It's interesting that I shared my story, and posted something in an attempt to get help from other moms, but I'm getting told I'm rough on my SS and no mention is made of how his mother lets him eat crap everyday, or walk around looking homeless. Forgive me for wanting him to be clean and healthy. He's a kid - and looks to the adults in his life for guidance. If, in a few years, he wanted to smoke cigarettes, or drink alcohol, or skip school, would I let him? NO. If he wanted an allowance, but didn't complete chores or do anything worthy of it, should my husband hand over his hard-earned money? NO. If he walked around smelling like BO, or didn't brush his teeth for a few days - am I supposed to consider that 'freedom of expression', or a boy just being a boy? I must be a very "square" lady, because I think all of that is unacceptable. Do you ladies really think it's okay for a child to do all the things I just mentioned, or as their parent, wouldn't you want to steer them down a better path?

With food as our issue, it is a daily battle. And, I'm no "Soup Nazi" or anything. I never asked my mother-in-law to NOT cook the meal he loves. It was HER idea to introduce new things on his plate, to HELP her son and I show my stepson new things. I appreciate her help, and I think what we're doing is good. I will not let him eat crap - his mom will have to do that all on her own. All I can hope is that when he returns to Maine after each visit, he will start to take more and more pieces back with him. He will hopefully one day, understand that we ALL love him very much and just want him to be the best version of himself that he can. I have never, ever said anything to my stepson that would lead him to believe his mother doesn't love him. I'm sure she does. I know I would feel incredibly threatened by anyone who dared say that I didn't love my babies. I am not his mother. But I am his stepmom and I have a responsibility to him, as do my husband and his ex-wife. And when he's with us, it's my job to take care of him. Part of taking care of him is making sure he has a well rounded diet and a positive sense of self. All I was trying to convey to other mothers was that I am having great difficulty doing everyday things with my stepson, and asked for advice from women who were in similar situations. I assume these everyday battles are easier when it's your own child and your authority doesn't step on anyone else's toes - but as a stepparent, even in the best of circumstances, it may not be harder, but it's definitely thinner ice. I am so sorry that I was misunderstood by the other posters. :
post #19 of 21
Thread Starter 
SNGmommy - while I have no problems with you highjacking my thread, I think that as a new poster, you might consider that you get to know the place a little bit.

For starters, any use of the work "Nazi" is seriously frowned upon. Secondly, you are talking about exerting your will on another person (even if it is a little person) without regards or respect to what he wants. That's hard for Attachment Parenting/Natural Family Living advocates to swallow because most of us try to gently guide our children while respecting their needs as well. In my case, it was a problem with a child who only would eat McDonald's... and ultimately not my kid, so I found a solution (pb&j) and tomorrow she leaves and we're all happy and I didn't have to force anything.

Spend some time getting to know us here at MDC.

Good luck with your step son.
post #20 of 21
First of all, OP, sorry your thread got hijacked.

Now the newbie, from FL. I grew up pretty much the same way you did. I grew up in GA. South, to be exact. My mom cooked one meal. I had to say yes sir, no sir. We live in So. Ga now. I do NOT make my sons say yes sir no sir anymore. This is how I live now. There is nothing wrong with it, most northerners also do not say it.
I dont think you are being tough on your SS, but I think you are expecting him to jump in this new family, in this new house and abide by new rules, too quickly. He is only 8. You might not be used to 8 year olds, thats ok.

It sounds like you are really angry at the boys mom, you are very judgemental as well. My son(who is 4) had SIX cavaties last year. He did eat all organic, no sugar, etc, but OMG he still got SIX cavaties, what does that say about me as a parent? In your eyes I would be considered neglectful, but it is actually something that is in your mouth, a thing called GERMS that causes cavaities. SOme people get em, some dont. My older son has never had a cavaty in his life, and he eats a lot of crap. And then the stuffed animals--poor kid left his MOM and your complaining about stuffed animals? GEEZ. I think you need to accept him as he is and give him lots of love and understanding. Calm down, you will be fine with him, just give him time. Also, this site is a family parenting site that promotes gentle discipline for kids, so you may get a few people rufflin their feathers at you.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: The Childhood Years
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Ages and Stages › The Childhood Years › Help with an extremely picky eater