Mothering › Forums › Health › The Case Against Circumcision › New baby boy and the close call (rant-y)
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

New baby boy and the close call (rant-y)  

post #1 of 23
Thread Starter 
My husband and I welcomed a beautiful baby boy to the world on Saturday, April 19th this year. His name is John Paul, but we call him Jack, in proper Kennedy form...
My husband and I decided to circumcise our son... stupid me did not research anything about it... left it to the person that has a penis, he must know best.
After my son was born, the nurse said that it looked like he had a birth defect called hypospadias, which is when the opening for the urethra isn't where it outta be, either it's somewhere else on the head of the penis, on the shaft, or beside the anus. I did not know this either, until yesterday... again, stupid me.
The hospital personnel had said they did not want to circumcise him, because with hypospadias, usually re constructive surgery is required, also sometimes plastic surgery as well. They referred us to a pediatric urologist and sent us on our way, my son still intact.
Fast forward 3 months... with the new mommy still not researching anything... like a complete moron...
We see the pediatric urologist yesterday, where he told us that our son doesn't have hypospadias, in fact, his foreskin just is not attached underneath, making it kind of like a cape instead of a tube... if that makes any sense. Great! awesome! Our son isn't going to need re constructive surgery!
What about the circumcision?
The doc tells us that in order to circumcise our son, we'd have to wait until he's 12 months old, he would be placed under general anesthesia, and they would surgically remove his cape, with stitches to follow.
My husband and I decided to let Jack decide if he wants it done when he's an adult. I'm not going to sign a paper for them to anesthetize my baby to do a procedure that isn't medically necessary. It just didn't make good sense.
After our appointment, I took my son to my parent's house, they watch him for a few hours on the days that my husband and I both work. I filled my mother in on our decision, and she and my father took turns "trying to be helpful" and telling me that I outta reconsider. Qua? you want me to sign a paper and have them anesthetize your grandson???!?!? to do something that has no impact on his health or well being????!?!?
Seriously... took turns, for minutes, telling me I should seek a second opinion from someone who isn't quite as "anti- circumcision" ... just to make an informed decision.
I have since researched circumcision and hypospadias thru and thru. The more I read the more nauseous I become. I was going to let them hurt my little guy. I wasn't going to stop them. I was going to PAY them to do it. Jesus, what is wrong with me???! I love this child with almost everything that I am, and I was going to hand him over for him to be, for all practical intents and purposes, mutilated... at only a day old.
It makes me sick.
I'm trying really hard not to cry writing all of this out.
So, I cannot even describe the guilt I feel over this. It was an enormous wake up call to me as a mother and as a person in general.
The next undertaking is to research vaccinations...
post #2 of 23
((hugs)) mama.... to MDC
ohh. little ones calling...
post #3 of 23
Glad you found out in time, please share your story with anyone who will listen.
post #4 of 23


I'm glad you found out before your baby was hurt.
post #5 of 23
Yes indeed, your son survived a close call and is very lucky!! Don't let your parents guilt you into anything. Remember, they are from the generation that bought into the mythology and didn't readily question much the medical establishment told them. They circ'd their sons and/or were circ'd themselves and will often validate that by urging others to do the same. As many say around here, you know better now so you can do better.
post #6 of 23

Kinda like stepping through to the Matrix, eh?
post #7 of 23
What an experience you've been through! I'm happy everything turned out OK! Go ahead and cry if you feel like it, you will probably feel better to let it all out.
post #8 of 23
I am so glad things worked out for your ds So many moms only find out after the fact and cant fix what was done. You were spared this thank goodness as was your ds.

Remember even though your ds is retractable on the bottom that still dosnt mean that anyone is allowed to retract him so be on guard about that with Dr's. The stickies at the top of the CAC forum explain why in more detail: A Warning To Parents Of Intact Sons and The Definition Of Retraction & Why It is BAD.
post #9 of 23
But IT DIDN'T HAPPEN! It wasn't done!! Jump up and rejoice!!! Shout out loud! Your boy is whole! :
post #10 of 23


I am glade you decided not to circumcise your son.
For me i didn't see the harm until I took my son in to be done.
But once they started I stoped the dr just in time before any cutting was done. My son was screaming.

I'm so happy you have found this place.
And that your little guy will be left intact.

:
post #11 of 23
Sounds like that nurse's concern was a blessing in disguise. You didn't know any better when he was a newborn, what's important is that it wasn't done. I didn't do my research until it came right down to it, and it sickens me too that I almost allowed it to be done to my son so I know that feeling.
post #12 of 23
I'm so happy your son is healthy and will not require any surgery. That's great news!
The wonderful thing about leaving him intact is the choice will now be his if he ever wants to get circumcised (and chances are very high that he will not).
If more parents knew the truth about circumcision they would not put their child through it.
I urge you to write both your OB/Gyn and the hospital where you delivered and tell them you find it negligent that they didn't inform you of all the losses and risks that circumcision poses to your son. Ask them to start doing a better job of educating parents about the benefits of a foreskin and the harm of circ. Tell all your friends and neighbors too. The truth is most people just never give circ a second thought.
As far as you mom, like someone else said, her generation was taught not to second guess doctors and that an intact penis was sure to lead to all sorts of ailments, which is totally false.
Please let her know regardless of your sons doctor being either anti-circ or pro-circ, the American Academy of Pediatrics does not recommend routine infant circ. I'm sure she's just concerned due to all the misinformation she's heard over the years. Maybe you might print off these resources for her:
http://nocircpa.org/4642.html
http://www.homiegfunk.com/RIC2.htm
http://www.healthcentral.com/drdean/408/9985.html
post #13 of 23
Thread Starter 
I know that I never gave circ a second thought. The creepy thing is my mother said her doctor told her the AAP doesn't recommend circ, and she had my little brother done anyway! She said, "Yeah, they gave me that song and dance with your brother"
You know... her and my father seem to think that there can be some kind of medical complication to my son NOT being circumcised! Like his foreskin is going to get infected and fall off.
GR. I wish they could just knock it off with the grinding me down.
post #14 of 23
Quote:
Originally Posted by leila1213 View Post
But IT DIDN'T HAPPEN! It wasn't done!! Jump up and rejoice!!! Shout out loud! Your boy is whole! :
:
post #15 of 23
What got my fil to finally back off was me telling him it wasnt my penis to cut on in a not so nice tone of voice after him bringing it up yet AGAIN :
post #16 of 23
I don't know you, but I could hug you! Hooray for your little boy! And hooray for you, mama!

Quote:
I was going to let them hurt my little guy. I wasn't going to stop them. I was going to PAY them to do it. Jesus, what is wrong with me???! I love this child with almost everything that I am, and I was going to hand him over for him to be, for all practical intents and purposes, mutilated... at only a day old.
This is so simple, but what RIC all boils down to... I wish everybody was able to see it for what it is.
post #17 of 23
I'm glad everything worked out for the best. Be easy on yourself, you were uninformed, but now you know and your ds is safe.
post #18 of 23
Quote:
Originally Posted by mamcfarland View Post
I know that I never gave circ a second thought. The creepy thing is my mother said her doctor told her the AAP doesn't recommend circ, and she had my little brother done anyway! She said, "Yeah, they gave me that song and dance with your brother"
You know... her and my father seem to think that there can be some kind of medical complication to my son NOT being circumcised! Like his foreskin is going to get infected and fall off.
GR. I wish they could just knock it off with the grinding me down.

Wow, a doctor who actually did the right thing. It's a shame he/she had an ignorant patient (your mom and dad).: eyesroll
post #19 of 23

Please Make Sure...

you and your dh read this
http://www.mothering.com/discussions...d.php?t=822675
post #20 of 23


It'll be alright. Your son is unharmed and that is the important thing to remember. Let yourself cry about it but don't let the guilt eat you up. Let go of the guilt and channel it into being a fierce protector of all little boys.

And celebrate that your son is whole! :::
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: The Case Against Circumcision
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Health › The Case Against Circumcision › New baby boy and the close call (rant-y)