I chose Jennifer with A Woman's Place for the birth of my #2. I called late and the last part of the birth went very fast (homebirth) so she arrived after ds was born, but I have a very high opinion of her and will be hiring her again if I have a #3. I would agree that she is more medical than some midwives (though certainly much less so than a typical hospital-based midwife), but I have found her to be very interested, intelligent, and respectful of a mother's choices. The guildelines they do have are, in my opinion, truly in place to ensure good and healthy outcomes. The most important thing I can say is that I feel I've finally found a birth HCP that I can trust. I would also say that I do not have textbook births and she's been very supportive (validating rather than undercutting my experience of the birth or questioning my opinions/feelings/perceptions of the birth).
The only downside I can think of at the moment is that the appointments are a bit short for me, because I always have a lot of questions/things to talk about related to the pregnancy and birth. I'm not sure how long a typical appointment is there (maybe 15-30 min?), but I always needed more time. Plus it didn't help that I always had to fight traffic to get there and half the time was late myself.
Overall, I would highly recommend her.
Good luck to anyone trying to choose . . . it's not easy!