Mothering › Mothering Discussion Forums › Education › Learning at Home and Beyond › Unschooling › xpost: Costco "magazine" debates certifying homeschool parents
New Posts  All Forums:
 

xpost: Costco "magazine" debates certifying homeschool parents

post #1 of 10
Thread Starter 
I received a copy of Costco's "Costco Connection" (tagline: a lifestyle magazine for Costco members) yesterday in the mail.

I start flipping the pages out of boredom, and see a section called "informed debate" that is titled "Should parents be certified to home-school their children?" (p. 16)

(eta: I tried linking to it but it doesn't work. Go to costco.com then look for their Costco Connections link. Click on the current issue, and it is a few pages into the "magazine" if you want to read for yourself)

It mentions the CA Court of Appeals decision ruling that parents who want to HS their children in that state must be certified teachers in that state. (hasn't that been overturned? I admittedly am not up to date...)

It has a sidebar saying 3 "Yes" opinions to their title....3 different individuals offering up opinions saying that parents should have to be certified (one guy is a taecher , one says that society struggles to find educated and well rounded individuals so we should require parents to be certified , and one says that certification ensures students are equipped with the right resources for a "quality education" ). Then they offer up 3 "No" opinions (even teachers doing a poor job/certification doesn't guarantee "quality", that a loving concerned parent can "meet or exceed" what a certified teacher would provide, and then someone saying that parents provide the "best environment and guidance."

Then, on the next page it has a blurb from the "experts" in the field. Marty Hittelman (LA community college math teacher and preseident of the CA Federation of Teachers) is the "pro certification" commentator. His states that parents "need to teach to CA or other state curriculum standards, and should be qualified in the subjects they teach their children." He says "Home-schoolers can contract with a public school, under the direction of a credentialed teacher, to offer instruction through independent study." (drumming up virtual schools...) He says "We'd prefer that HSing parents work with their local public schools so that all students are assured of a standards-based education."

The other "expert" is Michael Smith, president of HSLDA. He obviously raises the case against certification of homeschooling parents.

They have a sidebar saying "what do you think? Should parents be certifired to homeschool their children?" with a box for yes or no.

YOu can vote by faxing, mailing in this little coupon portion they have in the sidebar, email to: Debate@costco.com , or go online to costco.com, and click on Costco Connection Magazine.


I thought perhaps we should make our presence and opinions known
post #2 of 10
Already wrote my letter... it's over on my LJ:

http://mamagotcha.livejournal.com/185502.html

Thanks for the heads-up!
post #3 of 10
Great response! Hope they publish it!
post #4 of 10
whenever i try to respond to stuff like this, i realize that people who agree with stuff like this have no clue what homeschooling is all about...... and i can't imagine trying to explain why this makes no sense whatsoever....


i guess as i've gotten older i say "why bother?" more and more. my bad.
post #5 of 10
I AM a certified teacher (MI K-5, 6-8 in Lang arts and soc studies)and I'll be the first to say that my cert isn't worth poopoo in terms of actually *knowing* how to teach. My fancy education from a large state university wasn't worth much more. I came out fully certified not really knowing anything about teaching. Oh, I knew tips and tricks for wrangling a crowd into compliance, but that was about it in terms of actual useful knowledge.

Certification is NOT all its cracked up to be.
post #6 of 10
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by honeybeedreams View Post
whenever i try to respond to stuff like this, i realize that people who agree with stuff like this have no clue what homeschooling is all about...... and i can't imagine trying to explain why this makes no sense whatsoever....


i guess as i've gotten older i say "why bother?" more and more. my bad.
I understand what you mean. DS is still only 4.5 and DD under 2, so we aren't even officially HSers yet but I've been reading here for years. I don't really debate w/ people IRL. I politely answer questions and that's about it, unless they press me, at which point I will share more info then they probably want to hear.

However, in this case, I think it serves as an opportunity for advocacy. Just as a nursing mom getting harassed in a restaurant for BFing is an opportunity for advocacy (and I personally would hate to see people as saying, well, chalk it up to the fact that there will always be people that don't support BFing). It gets tiring standing up for something over and over, but I'd hate to see this national mailing that reaches both homeschoolers and public schoolers go out next month with a bunch of uninformed opinions in it (which truthfully is probably what will happen anyway.).
post #7 of 10
Thank you for posting this! I voted and will also email comments.

What really gets me is that "experts in the field" of homeschooling, IMHO, don't include "experts in the field" of education. Homeschooling is an entirely different creature than public/private schooling.
post #8 of 10
It just frustrates me that stuff like this is even up for debate... to me it's like people arguing over whether or not I have the 'right' to paint my living room purple... I feel like even getting into these sorts of discussions gives people the misguided impression that they have any say over the issue. To me the arguement shouldn't be whether or not homeschool parents need certification, but whether or not anyone besides the parent should have any input into educational choices, and the answer of course, is no, absolutely not.

Having said all that, great letter, SamuraiEarthMomma!
post #9 of 10
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ygle View Post
To me the arguement shouldn't be whether or not homeschool parents need certification, but whether or not anyone besides the parent should have any input into educational choices, and the answer of course, is no, absolutely not.
Wow. That quote rocks.
post #10 of 10
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ygle View Post
It just frustrates me that stuff like this is even up for debate... to me it's like people arguing over whether or not I have the 'right' to paint my living room purple.
New Posts  All Forums:
 
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Unschooling
Mothering › Mothering Discussion Forums › Education › Learning at Home and Beyond › Unschooling › xpost: Costco "magazine" debates certifying homeschool parents