Mothering › Forums › Health › The Case Against Circumcision › A little sad today
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

A little sad today  

post #1 of 6
Thread Starter 
A co worker of mine who I was pretty close to had her baby boy yesterday. She said she wanted to leave him alone but her DH wanted him cut. I sent her some info to share with her husband but I think that today is the day. I think she humored me because she knew I felt strongly on the issue and didn't want an argument. I sent her a nice email a couple weeks ago explaining my position and everything but I doubt she will keep him intact.

I have another co worker who is due next month. She said her dh didn't care which I thought was great. She did some research and talked to a urologist : so she said that she is going to cut him because of STDs. ugh. I sent her some info but I doubt she is going to change her mind.

Now for the happy! My brother called today and said that he is expecting a boy in January. (he has 3 girls already). He heard from my mom that we didn't circ Lincoln and told me that he things that its there for a reason (foreskin)! He wanted to know about care - he said "you just pull it back and clean it right?" so of course I told him never to retract until the boy does and it doesn't require any extra cleaning. i also told him to watch the doctors because many don't seem to be aware of intact care. I told them the only thing they learn in med school about it is how to cut it off. I told him that he has to make sure his wife is on his side because they will usually ask the mother. Apparently she deferred the decision to him (this is the first time I'm actually happy to hear that statement!!). I'm sending him a copy of the mothering magazine circ reprint booklet to read and share with his wife. I'm so excited because I never expected this from him. He is kind of macho and not exactly the progressive type! If he can leave his son intact, anyone can! :
post #2 of 6
Hooray for small victories! One out of 3 is better than none out of three! I'm so glad you are trying, and who knows maybe you have planted doubt in those other people's minds too
post #3 of 6
That is good news about your brother. I'm sorry that you couldn't reach your coworkers, but you never know...maybe you changed their thinking on it just a little anyway.
post #4 of 6
WOO HOOO!! Great news about your future nephew!!!!
post #5 of 6
Quote:
Originally Posted by jamie7100 View Post

I have another co worker who is due next month. She said her dh didn't care which I thought was great. She did some research and talked to a urologist : so she said that she is going to cut him because of STDs. ugh. I sent her some info but I doubt she is going to change her mind.

I also spoke with a urologist before deciding whether or not to circ and he mentioned nothing about prevention of STD's and stated that in his experience uncircumcised men have no more problems than the circumcised ones and that really, it is just a ritualistic thing Americans have taken on.
I hope she decides to research this more before deciding!
You're a good friend to be providing her with information
post #6 of 6
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by ~NewMa~ View Post
I also spoke with a urologist before deciding whether or not to circ and he mentioned nothing about prevention of STD's and stated that in his experience uncircumcised men have no more problems than the circumcised ones and that really, it is just a ritualistic thing Americans have taken on.
I hope she decides to research this more before deciding!
You're a good friend to be providing her with information
Apparently when she asked the urologist, she phrased the question "What problems do you see with uncirc'd males?" and his response was "STDs". I'm thinking he may have had the same response if she asked what problems he sees in males generally. This person is a vet and doesn't really trust anyone's opinion unless they are a doctor. Which I think is silly. Whatever. It frustrates me to even think about it. We actually used to share an office to pump and I was also bummed when one day I asked something about nursing and she commented that the only reason why she pumps is because its cheaper. I pumped for a long time and that reason, although valid, is not why I tortured myself for 11 months.

I don't think she is going to research anymore and she actually seemed very proud of her decision. I had really hoped that she would have gone the other way but I think that doing what is "normal" and "accepted" is easier than going against the grain.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: The Case Against Circumcision
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Health › The Case Against Circumcision › A little sad today