Mothering › Forums › Welcome to the MotheringDotCommunity › Finding your Tribe › Tribal Areas › Florida, Georgia, Alabama › Dr Sevilla - pediatrician in Sarasota
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Dr Sevilla - pediatrician in Sarasota  

post #1 of 8
Thread Starter 
Hi everyone,

I had visited Dr Sevilla for my daughter's wellness check-ups after having read the post "pediatrician rave in Sarasota/Bradenton" and similar kudos to him. I am so glad to know he is tolerant of delaying and/or selecting out vaccines, but after two visits I know that is not his first option. I am not intending to critique him, just a report in case anyone finds it helpful.

I am on the fence about vaccination, and having told him so, he gave me his own opinion. In summary he said:

-the benefits greatly outweigh the risks
-vaccines are so good they are a detriment to themselves - we haven't had
these diseases for so long, they do not seem scary any longer
-he has administered 80,000 vaccines, has had no severe reactions but has had 3 or 4 cases with adverse reactions to dtap (crying for hours, fever of 104 degrees)
-there have been no founded correlations made between vaxs and autism, chronic diseases, autoimmune disorders etc
-measles is a serious disease
-he has never seen a case of measles
-CDC predicts a measles epidemic because of fewer people vaccinating

This is essentially the same thing my prior ped said. The difference between the two is that my prior ped was pushy in the extreme, and Dr Sevilla is subtle in his approach. But if it were up to him, he'd definitely vax. He did ask me how comfortable I was with vaccinations in general (scale of 1 to 10), probably in order to know whether to offer a vax at our last visit. I wonder if a ped gets paid more per vaccine administered?

The only certain discrepancy I noted was that measles once was not considered a serious disease for most. It was an expected childhood disease without lasting effects to the vast majority. I was surprised to see any scare tactics from him about measles. Again, not trying to annoy anybody here, just passing along info in case it helps (and to get this off my chest!).
post #2 of 8
Interesting. Thanks for posting. We see him too and I let him know at the first visit that we don't vax at all. He did say that the only vaxes he suggests are the 2 meningitis vaxes. I even asked if he thought DS1 should have it and he said "no, he has outgrown the risk". But I'm finding that everyone gets a different story from him. I do like that he's not pushy about vaxes but I do think that he is pro-vax.
post #3 of 8
I wrote the original "rave" post about him and stand by it. He definitely is pro-vax, but he is very respectful of parents who are anti-vax, choose a delayed schedule, a modified schedule, or simply want to sit and talk about the shots. From what I've learned, most local peds are not like this.
post #4 of 8
On the first visit I told him I don't vax and that I have no questions or concerns about it. He has never brought it up or discussed it with me. I never asked him his opinion about it. I would prefer a holistic ped but there aren't any.. so we have to make do, and he's the best option.

They definitely get paid for the vaxes they administer, and he's probably trying to protect himself, so if you are still on the fence A, I recommend doing your own research instead of asking the ped. And then you have to trust your own instincts because you will find information to support either decision you make.

I have never been vaxed so it was an easy decision for me. Good luck!

My only issue I have with him is that sometimes he seems really out of it, like he hasn't slept, and other times he's on the ball. DH said maybe he does rounds at the hospital or something.
post #5 of 8
He's our ped. too & we haven't vaxed. I tell him we are still researching and just taking it one day at a time (dd is 9mos). He usually just mentions it at each visit, wondering where we stand. We went to his vaccine talk a few months back and do know that he is pro-vaccine, but he doesn't force you to follow the cdc schedule or make you sign one of those papers saying you are endangering your kid. He respects the parents decision which is very important to me.
Now that you mention it, I think I've also noticed the out-of-it feeling from him, and he doesn't seem extremely knowledgable on things either. And I don't really care for his nurse. He's the best we've been to though. There was talk on local pediatricians not too long ago on this yahoo group: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/saraso...iousparenting/
Check it out
post #6 of 8
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by KalinasMom View Post
[We] do know that he is pro-vaccine, but he doesn't force you to follow the cdc schedule or make you sign one of those papers saying you are endangering your kid. He respects the parents decision which is very important to me.
That's where I am too. He is the best I've found, though I am willing to continue "comparison shopping" esp since we live an hour away. I don't like the idea of three peds in 2 years unless need be...

MJW - I agree there's no need to use the ped as a sole source of info. I just like to know that the one who would/does administer vaxes to my DC has a good understanding and at least tolerance of my decisions. Sevilla would, but not like I expected at first. I am doing the one-disease-at-a-time research a couple hours each week now. Info is power!
post #7 of 8
A- good to hear you are doing your own research too. I'll be interested to hear how you feel about it when you are done. I have a friend that is also having a hard time making a decision, so if you come across any good books to recommend to her lmk. It's been years since I have read up on it do I'm not familiar with the newer publications.

We had a good experience on our visit to Dr S last week. He recommended priobiotics for ds's frequent stomach pains (which I believe is right on the money), while our last ped ordered tests for them, that came back negative, and there was no mention of priobiotics and no solution found.
post #8 of 8
I've heard several people recommend him so thanks for giving your experience.
I just moved from Chicago and our family doctor came highly recommended - Dr. Marc Weinberg (close to beneva and fruitville). He is on the American board of Holistic doctors and is EXCELLENT. My dd has some issues so we have been to him quite a bit. On my very first meeting, he asked about my dd diet and if it was organic, her exposure to plastics and how careful I was with BPA in canned foods. He is very much for delayed vaccines and in some cases no vaccines. I just started to post on this board so I'm afraid I may not find this thread again, if someone wants more info, please leave me a message.
Erin
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Florida, Georgia, Alabama
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Welcome to the MotheringDotCommunity › Finding your Tribe › Tribal Areas › Florida, Georgia, Alabama › Dr Sevilla - pediatrician in Sarasota