or Connect
Mothering › Mothering Forums › Mom › Parenting › Multicultural Families › Anyone live with an in-law? Multi-generational living? Extended family living?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Anyone live with an in-law? Multi-generational living? Extended family living?

post #1 of 26
Thread Starter 
My husband and I recently moved in with my mom. It's challenging, but it's worth it, I think. I also know that we may be the exceptions in America, but this kind of living is very normal in other places.
I'd appreciate anyone who is willing to share their experience living in a non-neolocal kind of household. How did you cope living with a parent in adult-hood? How do you deal with people who think you should "get a place of your own"?

Thanks!
post #2 of 26
Well, my situation is a little different, as MIL lives with us part time. Mother living with adult daughter is common in DH's culture. It is not so common to live with an adult son, and it entirely depends on DIL - me! DH wanted to give his sister a break, as MIL has been living with her for over 20 years. She is now blind from glaucoma, although otherwise in good health. She was with us for 3 months last winter, and we will have her come this winter. The house we are building has a room for her, and we look forward to her coming.

I tell you, I earned a LOT of points by having her stay with us last winter. SIL finally likes me, I think. MIL told everyone that I treated her like my own mother, which was a HUGE compliment. It wasn't that hard, as I genuinely like her. And, DH had time off due to parental leave, and he took over much of the cooking while she was here. And that sometimes required 2 dinners, as she is a strict observer of lent and did not eat any meat during that time. (DH is a big carnivore. I would have been fine with fish or vegetarian during that time, but DH made a fish dinner every night, and usually a meat meal, too). That made things even better! It may change this winter, as he and I will both be working full-time, and DS will be in daycare. But, with the new house, more space, I think we can manage.

Our house is also open to my extended family, should any of them need or want to live with us. Not likely to happen for quite a while, though.

SO, the conditions are quite a bit different in our family compared with yours, but I wanted to throw it in the mix!
post #3 of 26

.


Edited by RainCoastMama - 2/26/14 at 9:41pm
post #4 of 26
Our situation was like ASusan's... my MIL lived with us for a year and may live with us again. She watched DD while we both WOH full-time.

I'll be honest: it was rough. There were some benefits, but I had severe depression which made the whole situation intolerable. Now that I'm medicated (lol!) and healthy, we're willing to consider it again. We parted for good reasons on good terms, so it's a definite possibility. One thing that was helpful was to be clear about expectations and flexible in things around the home. One part that we would have to do a better job about next time is making sure that we all have outside interests and lives, because that reduces the stress placed on our relationships inside the home and gives us all a bit of elbow room.
post #5 of 26
My mother lives with us. So the in-law is for dh. Sometimes I get tired of *never* having my home to myself. I get tired of the 3 of us (dd is an only) never going out... just the 3 of us. But overall, it's a great arrangement. In Dh's culture, it is *not* normal to not live with other family... at least in the same building. When I mention that I'm tired of her living with us, dh is her advocate. It's normal for him. They get along well.

In our situation, my mother lives with us and we support her. In dh's culture, that is the way it works. A child who lives with their parent is the primary breadwinner... not the parent. That would be, well, extremely taboo, if a child was living with a parent and the parent was making the living instead. But "getting a place of their own" would put my mother on the street, so it's quite easy to explain.

We built a MIL quarters onto our house for my mother. She has her own living room, bedroom, bathroom. She eats all meals with us, as she doesn't have a separate kitchen.

Also thought I'd mention that dd loves that my mother lives here. They are extremely close and it's wonderful to have multi-generational interactions. My mother, unless it's truly by accident, does not interfere or make any comments about the way I raise dd.
post #6 of 26
Slightly different situation here...
We are living with my ILs in their house and although we have separate bedrooms, bathrooms and kids' room everything else is shared.
In addition, my DH's grandmother is also living here, always at home.
In some ways its been really nice to have them in the house, and they do help ALOT with the kids.
On the other hand, I often feel like I am not able to live my life and live by my rules. I pretty much never have complete privacy, since most of the time we spend downstairs with the grandma in site.
post #7 of 26
We are living with dh's parents because we a poor. IT SUCKS BIG TIME!
post #8 of 26
MIL lives with us-- full disclosure, we are Dh is indian, and I'm a first gen american.

I'll come back and post later-- got to get to bed!
post #9 of 26
velochic-- your set up seems similar to ours. Do you think things would be better if your mom had her own kitchen?

that's my latest fantasy.
post #10 of 26
Hi there! We have had one mom or another living with us for nearly our entire relationship. His mom was "visiting" when we met, and lived with us for 5 years. Just as she moved to live with my SIL my mom came to stay.
It has it's challenges, ours is different in that it is a parent living in our home, but we try to focus on the positives. When someone questions our living arrangement I say: My son has always been cared for at home by someone who loves him rather than a day care (I work). He is so secure knowing that all these people love him. He has had the time to develop really great relationships with both of his grandmas.

A big thing for us always has been that we have to have boundaries. Sure, they are our moms and we love them, but our focus is on our relationship and our son. We don't let the moms get involved in our relationship....we don't invite them in (so I don't complain about my husband to my mom and vice versa). I think it gets too messy when they get involved. We always make decisions between the two of us before involving the parents so there are no taking sides.

It can work out, but everyone has to be patient and willing to let the other one have some slack once in a while.
post #11 of 26
Quote:
Originally Posted by aquarian View Post
velochic-- your set up seems similar to ours. Do you think things would be better if your mom had her own kitchen?

that's my latest fantasy.
In our situation, no, a separate kitchen would not be a good thing, because cooking is my passion. I *often* spend the entire day tinkering around in the kitchen. My mother cannot cook and the few food that she would cook are simply not allowed in the house (hot dogs, ham salad made from bologna).

That being said, because I do hang out in the kitchen all day, my mother is constantly coming in to get coffee and I do miss my privacy. Not that I need privacy to sit here at the computer or to chop onions, etc. but it's like a mental interruption. When I am close to starting my period I get particularly testy about my mother "bugging" me. I have to remind myself that she gave up a lot to move in with us.

I can imagine, though, that if a parent could cook, a separate kitchen would be a huge help!
post #12 of 26
Just wanted to come back and write a proper response.

I grew up very comfortable with the idea of a joint family-- but like pp mentioned, (heather8!) it's been really, really, really tough.

I stand by what I've said in the past-- it can be great, if done right.
post #13 of 26
Quote:
Originally Posted by velochic View Post
That being said, because I do hang out in the kitchen all day, my mother is constantly coming in to get coffee and I do miss my privacy. Not that I need privacy to sit here at the computer or to chop onions, etc. but it's like a mental interruption.
I feel this way all the time. Thanks so much for answering my question velochic.

As I was falling asleep last night I was thinking that it may have been too personal of a question.
post #14 of 26
i live with my mil and i find it to be better for everyone involved. She's been living with us on and off for the last six years but since last October we decided it should be permanent. She's really laid back and easy going which is great. She also thinks I'm a really good mother (which is always nice to know).
post #15 of 26
We've been living with my mom for 3.5 years. It was supposed to be temporary until we could find a house we'd like to buy. I'm very close to my mom, but living together under 1 roof has its ups and downs. My kids, on the other hand, have grown attached to her and now I don't know how we'd ever move them away from grandma.

When things are good, my mom and I are like close friends. When things are not so good, I stay away from her space.
post #16 of 26
We lived with my inlaws frm the time I was preggers till ds was about 18 months! And it was PURE hell!...I hated it, I lOVE LOVE LOVE LOVE my inlaws but I can't live with them...we actually love them so much we bought the house next door and believe me thats a vacation!...I really admire people who can do it, i just personally couldn't. Right now Im staying there cause there is construction at my house and its not good with a two year old and me being preggers to breathe paint in...BUT i get a break cause i can still go over there and get away!...this is hard enough!
post #17 of 26
I love them but could not live with them!
post #18 of 26
Quote:
Originally Posted by aquarian View Post
I feel this way all the time. Thanks so much for answering my question velochic.

As I was falling asleep last night I was thinking that it may have been too personal of a question.
Not at all. If it was too personal, I would have just not replied.

Being an adult and co-existing with your adult parents... sometimes (in my case) even *elderly* parents... is a special situation that others cannot relate to unless they are in that situation. It's good to have others to talk to about it.

I can imagine that they dynamics are also completely different when an adult child moves in with a parent vs. a parent moving in with an adult child. In my case, my home is *mine*... truly mine because I bought it before I was married. My mother is the interloper. My task is to make sure that in spite of all my misgivings, I make her feel at home here. I can speak to that situation whereas an adult child moving in with a parent must have a completely different dynamic that needs to be addressed.

It's good to have people to talk to about this. I could nearly write a book about the situation of co-existing with parents. (Oops... almost have already!)
post #19 of 26
My SO and I live with my parents. Its a pretty common thing in my family... I grew up living with my parents and grandmother, and my mom grew up living in a large apartment building with her whole family (about 45 people).

We originally moved here with the intent of staying a few months, then moving on. 10 days later, we found out I was pregnant, and made the decision to stay until after the baby was born. We live in a large, 3 bedroom split plan house. Our '2' bedrooms (ours and babies) is on one side, and theirs on the other. We share all of the other areas of the house.

Its been mostly smooth, but there have been a few rough patches. My mom is neurotic about keeping her kitchen clean. Which, sure I like a clean kitchen, but you can't so much as set your drink down, and go to the bathroom without coming back to find it in the dishwasher.

Now that the baby is here, its nice to have help with her, especially considering I just spent a week in the hospital having surgery. My mother can be kind of overbearing about it, and has implied that I am doing quite a few things wrong. Thankfully, my SO is a really easy going guy, and is able to ignore most of what she says. He also has a night job, and keeps quite a different schedule then they do, so their interaction is pretty limited. I mostly have to deal with the brunt of things.

We're moving in May, and while I am THRILLED that is happening, I will miss my parents. If they lived in an area we could survive in, we'd stay here, but they live in a retirement area with low wages and high unemployment rates, and BAD schools, so its just not something we can do.
post #20 of 26
Quote:
Originally Posted by velochic View Post
I can imagine that they dynamics are also completely different when an adult child moves in with a parent vs. a parent moving in with an adult child. In my case, my home is *mine*... truly mine because I bought it before I was married. My mother is the interloper. My task is to make sure that in spite of all my misgivings, I make her feel at home here. I can speak to that situation whereas an adult child moving in with a parent must have a completely different dynamic that needs to be addressed.
that's a very good point. in our case, we also support MIL. (I wish it was the other way around, I'd move in a heartbeat!) However-- she's been living with us since we got married, ect, so I guess I don't feel that same way about it being totally my house, and her being the interloper. And she's not very good with boundries. Anyways... enough with the complaining! Thanks so much for the advice Velochic.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Multicultural Families
Mothering › Mothering Forums › Mom › Parenting › Multicultural Families › Anyone live with an in-law? Multi-generational living? Extended family living?