I had braces from 3rd-10th grade in the 90's. My lower jaw stuck out farther than my upper jaw. I had 10 teeth pulled during that time (a lot of my baby teeth were fused to the bone). After I got my braces off, I didn't keep up with my retainer for very long, so my teeth have shifted a little, but I still get compliments on them being straight.
I have 2 lingering issues though:
1. I had the braces so long (I was my doc's longed running patient at the time) and have stains on a few of my teeth from the glue (i.e. my other teeth got darker, but the place under the braces stayed white). I suppose that could probably be fixed, but I really hate people messing with my mouth after all that and it doesn't bother me much at all.
2. My upper and lower teeth still don't really line up. I can make them line up, but if I just close my mouth naturally, they don't. Also..and this may or may not be related, my upper and lower incisors don't meet when I close my mouth, so I have an awful time trying to bite things (food things...pizza, corn on the cob, anything that's not super soft)...I have to use my molars which is pretty difficult and annoying. It's always been that way, so I'm used to it, it's just annoying.
So overall, I voted other. I think having braces was overall a positive thing for me and my teeth would be a lot worse if I hadn't had them. It was really a pain though (in all senses of the word).