or Connect
Mothering › Mothering Forums › Natural Living › Nutrition and Good Eating › Evaporated Milk as formula?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Evaporated Milk as formula?

post #1 of 25
Thread Starter 
Opinions?

I was at register had my daughter with me so we were talking about babies. The woman said she has a three month old who is fed evaporated milk. 'I got it I'm fine'.

She said she tried a formula but her son didn't like it and there is too much junk in it.

I told her about 'babies only' formula, she said she doesn't care and said again. 'I got it I'm fine'

She said well he spit up lots, I mentioned reflux, she said there is no such thing.

I said well you could always try a homemade formula, I know some good recipes[Weston Price] and she said 'no, I dont have time for cooking'

I'm still in shock and I wanted to cry for that poor baby.
I did call CPS[they said they can help her with WIC or reflux if thats it], I feel bad now though but I do not believe a baby can properly grow on evaporated milk. Brain or body.

Like I said,.. opinions?
post #2 of 25
Formula is the only thing that can be substituted for bm. Evaporated milk waaay waaay doesn't cut it.
I could maybe see it if the mom was mostly bf'ing or FF'ing and the evaporated milk was an occasional thing, but as the whole nutrition source, no way.

That said, it was what a lot of us got ( I got evaporated milk + corn syrup as "formula"), so it's probably not the hugest deal. But it can and does cause problems a lot more often than "real, modern formula".
post #3 of 25
You are correct evap milk alone will not give that baby he needs that is so sad.
post #4 of 25
that poor baby!
there are so many formula options if one is bothering him, evaporated milk is just not an option.
poor baby!

My MIL was fed evaporated milk and corn syrup too... I wonder though if the evaporated milk was different then?
post #5 of 25
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dea View Post
that poor baby!
there are so many formula options if one is bothering him, evaporated milk is just not an option.
poor baby!

My MIL was fed evaporated milk and corn syrup too... I wonder though if the evaporated milk was different then?
Why did evaporated milk become popular, especcially over just using regular milk?
post #6 of 25
:

This kind of thing really really *%&$'s me off.
There is absolutely NO reason for this woman to be so ignorant/uninterested in this day and age with all the free information and government assistance available in the USA.

Isn't it just COMMON SENSE that feeding a small infant evaporated milk might not be a good idea????

I too, feel very sad for the babe.
I want to cry when I hear things like this.
post #7 of 25
Oh this is so sad I am just so thankful that there are caring people out there like yourself who stepped up and did something.
post #8 of 25
I recently found out that I was fed milk and rice cereal as a babe (I had previous thought I was formula fed). I seemed to have turned out okay In my mother's defense, it was 1970 and she was 18 years old.

Yeah, it's not the best, but some mom's don't "know" any better (even when someone is telling them to their face).
post #9 of 25
Evaporated milk based "formula" was very common back in the day. It used to be what hospitals recommended, before abm was plentiful, cheap, and reliable. Only sick babies got formula for a long time.

It's gross, but it's one of those cases of people doing better when they know better. It's kind of disturbing to me that there are people who think it's best today, but I can't say I'm surprised.
post #10 of 25
Quote:
Originally Posted by trancechylde View Post
:This kind of thing really really *%&$'s me off.
There is absolutely NO reason for this woman to be so ignorant/uninterested in this day and age with all the free information and government assistance available in the USA.

Isn't it just COMMON SENSE that feeding a small infant evaporated milk might not be a good idea????

I too, feel very sad for the babe.
I want to cry when I hear things like this.
Maybe the reason is that this mom is mentally ill or is mentally limited in some way. I really don't see any other reason for a mom to make such a poor decision. I don't get a thread like this. Obviously she is wrong and everyone here will agree. But I am sad for the baby and sad for the mom. She isn't making a selfish decision, but a really bad one for unexplained reasons.
post #11 of 25
Quote:
Originally Posted by pumpkingirl71 View Post
Maybe the reason is that this mom is mentally ill or is mentally limited in some way. I really don't see any other reason for a mom to make such a poor decision. I don't get a thread like this. Obviously she is wrong and everyone here will agree. But I am sad for the baby and sad for the mom. She isn't making a selfish decision, but a really bad one for unexplained reasons.
You know, after I posted my first response, I actually considered deleting it, because I agree with you wholeheartedly that these types of threads aren't helpful to the situation or even productive in any way.
It was a knee-jerk response I suppose, but I stand by what I said.

Quote:
I told her about 'babies only' formula, she said she doesn't care and said again. 'I got it I'm fine'

Quote:
I said well you could always try a homemade formula, I know some good recipes[Weston Price] and she said 'no, I dont have time for cooking'
I personally don't think that this Mama sounds like she's mentally ill...perhaps ill-informed, but also not particularly interested in suggestions and helpful tips/alternative solutions.
With the multi-million dollar advertising campaigns of formula companies nowadays, and the willingness of GP's and hospitals to give it out for free, I see no reason why any Mother would still think that feeding a baby evaporated milk is okay

Quote:
She isn't making a selfish decision, but a really bad one for unexplained reasons.
IMHO, from what the OP has told of her responses, she IS making a selfish decision, and she DID explain them (no time for cooking).

Judgment on our part is not going to remedy the situation, I know. But I think it's okay to express opinions about it, especially since that's what the OP was looking for
post #12 of 25
Dp got evap milk and corn syrup formula from birth. He has a lot of allergies and sinus issues.

I have a copy of The Canadian Mother and Child from 1967 (MIL gave it to me) and there is a section that actually explained how to make "formula" in this way.

Maybe her mother or MIL is giving her this advice? I know I have gotten a lot of advice with "It never killed you" after it. :
post #13 of 25
Quote:
Originally Posted by MadameXCupcake View Post
Why did evaporated milk become popular, especcially over just using regular milk?
I think because often people didn't have fridges back then and evap. milk came in cans.
post #14 of 25
Oh, that's terrible. You said you called CPS? Hopefully they can get her on WIC. She sounds really ill informed.
post #15 of 25
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Justthatgirl View Post
Oh, that's terrible. You said you called CPS? Hopefully they can get her on WIC. She sounds really ill informed.
Well thats why I posted and guess I should have emphasized more that yes I called but I feel bad now that I did.

And I wanted opinions, I guess I wasn't very clear but I was hoping some would say they would have done the same thing.
post #16 of 25

My Understanding As Well

Quote:
Originally Posted by eilonwy View Post
Evaporated milk based "formula" was very common back in the day. It used to be what hospitals recommended, before abm was plentiful, cheap, and reliable. Only sick babies got formula for a long time.
This is what I know of evaporated milk being fed to babies as well. If was something that was done a couple generations ago. I'm pretty sure I have a breastfeeding resource guide from the hospital that addresses the issue in a "do NOT do it, even though your grandma might recommend it" kind of way.
post #17 of 25
Well. Brain and body both can grow ok on it. BUT that doesn't make it a good or healthful choice ... I mean, I *could* survive just fine on nachos and twinkies, but it wouldn't be wise.

My mom says the same thing about having done just fine on a banana flake concoction as an infant, but at least she knows better than to advocate it.
post #18 of 25
I'm going to move this to Nutrition, since it seems like the crux of it is the nutritional content of evaporated milk for an infant.
post #19 of 25
My own mother was raised on formula made from evaporated milk and corn syrup- evaporated milk preferred over fresh milk due to lack of refrigeration- canned milk stayed fresh on the shelf (both in the store and in the house) while fresh milk went bad quickly and was much more expensive.

Who knows if my mom would have diabetes or asthma today if she'd been BF or given proper formula? The point is that, while evaporated mlk will keep the baby alive, it won't promote ideal growth and development. We know better now, and ther'es really no reason for a baby to subsist on a substandard formula when better formulas are readily available (I'm assuming that this particular mother has no interest in relactation.)

I would probably call CPS on that family myself, if I was unable to convince them to use real formula or relactate. That baby is in danger and the mother seems unwilling to make changes.
post #20 of 25
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ruthla View Post
I would probably call CPS on that family myself, if I was unable to convince them to use real formula or relactate. That baby is in danger and the mother seems unwilling to make changes.

I absolutely concur.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Nutrition and Good Eating
Mothering › Mothering Forums › Natural Living › Nutrition and Good Eating › Evaporated Milk as formula?