Mothering › Forums › Breastfeeding › Lactivism › Regrets?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Regrets?  

post #1 of 17
Thread Starter 
This may be a strange question to ask in a forum full of happily breastfeeding advocates, but have you known anyone who actually regretted breastfeeding?

I ask because my SIL is pregnant with her second baby. Her first was formula fed. She's been open to talking about it, but has said that she will probably not breastfeed this one.

I don't want her to feel pressured in any way, but obviously I do want to encourage her to reconsider. I want to be able to say, "Go for it! You won't regret it!" But I guess I want to say that with a clear conscience, if that makes sense.

She's still newly pregnant, so there is plenty of time for conversation about it - and I'm certain that her birth center will do whatever they can to educate and change her mind. I will urge her to at least start out on the breast, and say that she can always switch to formula later - but that odds are it wouldn't pan out if she starts out on the bottle and then has a change of heart. I want to be gentle in my approach to her...I have a new babe as well, and one thing I definitely don't want is for her to feel as though she is somehow a lesser mother for choosing formula. I'm pretty much over the moon with breastfeeding, and there is no other way in my mind barring some extreme circumstance - but I don't want my passion for it to translate as looking down on her, because I truly don't feel that way. We get along great, but don't really know each other well due to a big age gap and living so far apart. I'd love for this to be an opportunity to develop a deeper relationship with her, so it's important for me to tread lightly.

Any thoughts on the best way to encourage her? What have your experiences been?
post #2 of 17
Nope.

I just wanted to say, though ... be aware that she might have a hang-up about nursing one child when she didn't nurse the other. I've heard that argument many times. "Well it's not fair to my older child since I didn't nurse him!"

Having FF before also plays into the "so-and-so was FF and is fine" argument. Just be ready for those to crop up!
post #3 of 17
If she regrets breastfeeding, she can wean to formula. If she formula feeds and regrets it, it's much more difficult to relactate in order to breastfeed.
post #4 of 17

Not Sure But

The people I know who gave up on breastfeeding are not close friends, so I haven't had heart to hearts with any of them over the issue. Sometimes I do get the feeling though that they regret their attempt at breastfeediing though.

When people say things like, "I was starving my baby while I was trying to breastfeed and she gained four pounds as soon as I started using formula" it sounds to me like they regretted the breastfeeding part. I know that some moms go to formula feeling like horrible failures after their attempt at breastfeeding, reminding themselves that some nursing is better than none, but I get the impression that others figure they should have just done formula right from the start rather than spending those weeks struggling with the stress of poor weight gain or whatever issues they were dealing with.

In the case of your SIL I would take a very relaxed approach. Focus on the positives from her perspective, and suggest that it doesn't hurt to just try. Since she has FF her first you don't want to make her feel like she damaged or shortchanged that baby. Rather than working on her with the long term benefits for baby stuff (higher IQ, lower risk of diabetes, etc) talk to her about breastfeeding being cheaper, easier, less stressful, helping mom with weight loss, etc.
post #5 of 17
I know one woman who regrets not getting more help with her DC1 so that she ended up exclusively pumping, but she's bfing DC2 no problems.
post #6 of 17
Honestly? I'm one of the moms whose babies didn't gain weight. I don't regret nursing - I love nursing, and we're still going at almost 16 months!!! I do regret not supplementing sooner, and since I have/had no access to donated breastmilk, that means/meant formula. I do regret and still have painful feelings over all the struggle to feed her those first few months, and still not being "fully" successful. Feeling like a failure in breastfeeding is extraordinarily painful, IME, so I understand that fear for some women.

What I would tell a mom considering nursing is that most women can do it and love it with the right support, and you'd be happy to be part of her support system. And for those of who try and can't make it happen, or at least not exclusively, the effort is still worth it. Here's what my LC told me:

"You are 100% a breastfeeding mother, no matter how much milk your baby actually gets from you. Nursing is lifestyle, a way of mothering, and you couldn't be more committed."
post #7 of 17
Quote:
Originally Posted by justthinkn View Post
"You are 100% a breastfeeding mother, no matter how much milk your baby actually gets from you. Nursing is lifestyle, a way of mothering, and you couldn't be more committed."
This is lovely - thanks so much for sharing.
post #8 of 17
It is hard to imagine anyone regretting breastfeeding; even when problems occur you have the assurance that you were doing the very best for your baby.

Justthinkin' still going strong at 16 months is awesome and you are absolutely a BFing success!
post #9 of 17
Quote:
Originally Posted by sparklefairy View Post
If she regrets breastfeeding, she can wean to formula. If she formula feeds and regrets it, it's much more difficult to relactate in order to breastfeed.
What she said!!
post #10 of 17
Quote:
Originally Posted by La Rune View Post
Nope.

I just wanted to say, though ... be aware that she might have a hang-up about nursing one child when she didn't nurse the other. I've heard that argument many times. "Well it's not fair to my older child since I didn't nurse him!"

Having FF before also plays into the "so-and-so was FF and is fine" argument. Just be ready for those to crop up!
Yep - I still feel guilty about not bf Brendon for more than 3 months, even though Hypatia is going strong at 11 1/2 months.
But my take is, live and learn. Also, why should I compound my error by not bf my other babies? I screwed up with Brendon - that doesn't mean I should punish the younger babies, too.
You know what I regret? Not having the luxury to nurse Brendon when he's upset/hungry. You don't know HOW many times I've instinctively tried it and wished it would work once I realized what I was doing!
post #11 of 17
I don't think I've ever spoken to a mother who truly regretted breastfeeding, though I have met moms who had enormous difficulties (for a variety of reasons) and some of them did regret the amount of time and effort they put into certain breastfeeding goals (like no formula supplementation meaning that they were away from their babies pumping).

But a mother regretting having breastfed, nope. Plenty that harbour lots of guilt about not having managed it though, unfortunately.
post #12 of 17
This is still kind of hard for me to admit.

I wouldn't say I regret breastfeeding. I did struggle with it a great deal emotionally though. I didn't really have any desire to breastfeed. I felt pushed into it by doctors, and my husband, and I felt guily. I felt like if I didn't breastfeed I was a failure as a mother (not that I think ff moms are bad moms, these were my personal feeling, and I would never think this about anyone else). I felt as though I wasn't bonding with my dd. I resented her. So much of my time spent with her was feeding her, and I hated it for the most part. This lasted about 6 or 7 months. In hindsight, I really think I had PPD, and this may have been more responsible for these feeling than breastfeeding. At the time though, it seemed like breastfeeding was the worst thing ever.

Thankfully, things have changed. :

I'm a much happier person. I now enjoy nursing my 13.5 month old dd, and I don't plan to wean soon. On one hand, I'm so glad I stuck with breastfeeding, because I wonder if I could have formed any kind of relationship with my dd if I was able to have other people feed her all the time and take care of her more often. But sometimes it still hurts knowing how negative I felt about the whole experience those first months. So while I don't regret nursing, I have kind of mixed feeling about my early nursing relationship. HTH.
post #13 of 17
There are times when nursing DD has proven to be a challenge....but I don't regret nursing her or continuing to nurse her.
post #14 of 17
Quote:
Originally Posted by miche28 View Post
I don't think I've ever spoken to a mother who truly regretted breastfeeding, though I have met moms who had enormous difficulties (for a variety of reasons) and some of them did regret the amount of time and effort they put into certain breastfeeding goals (like no formula supplementation meaning that they were away from their babies pumping).

.
I sort of agree with this.
I don't regret BFing, but I do regret not supplementing with dd - my insistence on not giving her a drop of formula turned the first year ofher life into a nightmare of constant, round the clock nursing from a nearly-starving baby. Proper use of truly necesary supplementation (i have true low supply due to PCOS) would have saved my sanity, and made things so much easier. I was on the verge of psychosis at times from complete lack of sleep after nursing all night. (i cant sleep while nursing, i HATE the sensation of nursing..)

I also regret not having weaned sooner...I wanted so much to nurse forever, lol.....but when my cycle returned and my already critically low supply plummetted but I continued nursing despite horrific nursing aversions, and creepy discomfort due to dry nursing, really affected oru relationship. it made me HATE my dd, because i HATED nursing her, and the entire relationship became very warped, because i was trying to do what i thought was best for her, but it was so awful and hard it made me really bitter and in the end, dd KNEW it, she knew i hated nursing her, she knew i didn't like HER because she nursed...very bad, BAD situation.

This time around, i gave myself "permission" to supplement if necesary (happy to report it has NOT been!) and to wean at any point after a year *IF* things become ugly like they were with dd.(not there yet, but not seeming like it will happen soon if at all)

doi reget nursing? No. Do i regret being so focused on certain "goals" i let the relationship take over my life in a negative way? Yes.
post #15 of 17
No regrets here. And I'm glad I let dd have solids a bit early, starting at 5.5 mos. She was ready, eager, and all for it. My current BF baby, almost 7 mos, is still EBF, giant, fat & happy and not that interested in solids so none yet.

I'm also glad I let dd wean at 19 mos. I felt guilty about it at the time because I'd wanted to make it to 2 years, but it was right for her.

I think it really helps to let go of guilt, expectations, and rigid desires and just focus on this baby, this BF relationship, and its needs and benefits.
post #16 of 17
I think it would be nicest for you to share how much you like BF, and tell her that you think it would be great if she feels she wants to try it and you are happy to answer questions or just to be there for her for support if she wants to give it a go. You could offer to share or send books, etc.

But then you need to listen to her and see how she responds and not be pushy. If she doesn't want the books, that's OK, etc. Make a kind offer and see what happens. Good luck!
post #17 of 17
Quote:
Originally Posted by bobandjess99 View Post
do i reget nursing? No. Do i regret being so focused on certain "goals" i let the relationship take over my life in a negative way? Yes.
Thank you! That was beautifully stated and reading it felt positively cathartic for me!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Lactivism
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Breastfeeding › Lactivism › Regrets?