Mothering › Forums › Breastfeeding › Lactivism › Annoyed - please let me vent!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Annoyed - please let me vent!  

post #1 of 8
Thread Starter 
Copying a bit from the allergies forum where I posted looking for resources to "fight back"

I had the ped appt from H**L today. Started off great. It was a follow up to a bad EI that my son had. We tried yogurt in his diet (for the probiotics mostly) for 1 week, and that weekend, he had a extremely high fever, and he was cranky and upset. (My diet has been mostly milk free since early on since he was congested as an infant and I found no milk helped considerably). We gave it some time, but eventually after his extreme discomfort continued, we took him in, and we have been going through antibiotics to address it. We finally on the 3rd time, got the right antibiotic and it had cleared - yay!, but now we have a separate issue...

My daycare had informed me that in Nov when he moves up to the toddler room, they according to state regs, they have to offer my son what is on the menu unless they have a doc note. They have milk on the menu and cheese, so I asked this doctor (not our regular doctor, who is a DO) if he could write us a note exempting us since I can still provide pumped milk for him.

He said "no." Not just "no," but - "There is no medical evidence that links cow's milk to ear infections. In fact EI are 100% linked to being in daycare. I will not write you a note to exempt you because withholding milk from your son who is less than 2 is to his detriment. You can do what you want, but I will not write you a note that condones this." I asked him about an allergy test, but he refused. He said to have a follow-up in 6-8 weeks and any EI re-occurrence would have to be referred to the ENT. Well - you would think at least a note to sub my milk for DC milk for at least 6-8 weeks would be in order to not confuse the results, right? I told him I understood that cow milk did not CAUSE the EI, but that the congestion aggravated any kind of low-level infection he would have fought off on his own (and always has), and he refused to talk further about it. He said that "my milk is not as nutritious as what is provided at DC, because it lacks vitamin D." I told him I do not mind giving him vitamin drops in the winter when his outdoor activity becomes limited, but again - he would not hear it.

This is a teaching practice, so he is a 3 year student after med school on rotation, but dude - seriously? I have goo mind to write them a letter and complain, but I feel like I need some refereed journal articles to back me up. I am just so LIVID!

Thanks for letting me vent - I know you girls would understand!!
post #2 of 8
you should write a letter, absolutely!
post #3 of 8
i agree complain....

but my question is, what if you were vegan, or didn't do milk for relgious reasons? would DC still insist on giving your kid dairy products? can you just send a lunch in instead?
post #4 of 8
Thread Starter 
I feel at odds with claiming religious excemption here. But I will do whatever I have to in the end.

I am slowly cooling down - writing it out has been theraputic for me, and getting support and here - so thank you! I am seriously considering writing still though. Just feel like I need some good refereed evidence on my side first, and I am not sure I can provide that... I am doing some searching, but no real luck yet...
post #5 of 8
Definitely write a letter, that dr. was completely disrespectful and just plain idiotic.

But I also wonder why you aren't allowed to choose what your kid gets to eat in school, without a dr.'s note. That's just bizarre. Find a new dr. and a new day care imo.
post #6 of 8
Of course I think it is ridiculous that the doc won't write you a note, but I also find it ridiculous that the daycare won't respect your wishes on this. Since they are citing this as a state regulation, I would call the state child care licensing people and ask them whether it is really a rule. I just seriously doubt that it is. They may state that your child has to be offered milk at lunch, but if you supply your own milk, whether it be pumped milk, soy milk, goat's milk, etc, I bet that is acceptable to the state.

My old daycare used to make things up all the time and tell me their hands were tied and it was a state rule, when in fact it was NOT. For example, they told me that my daughter could not sleep swaddled because it was a state regulation that no blankets be in the cribs. This was not true - the state told me that the daycare just needs to have a policy on what is and what isn't allowed in the cribs and follow it, but that if their policy allowed it, blankets and swaddling would be allowed. The daycare just wanted a scapegoat. Same thing happened when they told me the state would not allow them to apply sunscreen to my daughter.
post #7 of 8
That's ridiculous! About the daycare and the doctor! Please write a letter.
I'm vegan so my son will not be getting cow's milk. I wonder what the daycare would say about that.
post #8 of 8
Thread Starter 
I posted this in the allergies forum as well - I hope some of you can find this information useful as well!
I will be working on either writing a letter or compiling a folder of resources to talk to my DO & the other doctor's superior about it at our next appt.

Yes - a study of 20 people showed no significant effect of milk on mucous production.
http://www.jacn.org/cgi/content/abst...4/suppl_6/547S

However, the rate of milk allergy is estimated at 2% - a study of 20 randomly selected people has a 67% chance of selecting a pool of people none of which have a milk allergy. And a 94% chance of selecting a pool with 1 or less person having a milk allergy. And 1 case of increased congestion would not have been significant in their study.

Milk allergy CAN be a cause of congestion and sinisitis and EI.
http://www.askdrsears.com/html/3/t032100.asp#T032102

In fact a study in 2008 showed that seasonal allergies can cause ear infections and sinusitis and then extended this to food allergies, particularly milk.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/1...ubmed_RVDocSum

The AAP did recommend against eliminating milk as a treatment for lactose intolerance (NOT milk allergy - in fact there is a special disclaimer in the AAP policy release saying this does NOT apply to milk allergy), because it can cause low calcium levels. Instead they suggest lactose free milk and low lactose dairy products like yogurt and aged cheeses.
http://aappolicy.aappublications.org...ics;118/3/1279

I honestly feel I don't even have to reply to the comment about my milk being less nutritional than vitamin D - that is just plain stupid.

Thank you so much for your support - I feel armed now to take this on!!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Lactivism
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Breastfeeding › Lactivism › Annoyed - please let me vent!