Mothering › Forums › Health › The Case Against Circumcision › I Am Ecstatic!!!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

I Am Ecstatic!!!  

post #1 of 6
Thread Starter 
I called my mom this morning to ask her about macaroni and cheese (has anyone else noticed that Kraft changed the recipe?) and she told me that she had a big revelation that she wanted to share with me. I thought she was just being silly.

But then she told me that she realized that I was right about circumcision. :

I know I've talked about this here before, but my mom has always been the most unwavering person when it came to circ. It was always "the thing we didn't discuss," because every time we tried talking about it we would argue for hours. She thought I was ridiculous, that intact penises were disgusting, everything under the sun. We haven't discussed circ in probably a year at least. I had accepted it as something that we would always disagree on, even after I had children.

She just said that she had been thinking about it, and if it "wasn't broke, then why fix it?" She feels very guilty about circ-ing my brother, which makes me sad, but he's happy and says he doesn't know the difference so he's fine with it (but is against infant circ). She added a bunch of disclaimers like "I still see both sides, I still think it's a decision your husband might have to make, etc. etc.," but I ignored them just because I was so happy to see that she had seen the light.

This is proof that you *can* change peoples minds, even a 60-year-old someone who seems to be stuck in their ways. Just my influence and my passion for intactivism has been able to sway her. I am just so happy!
post #2 of 6
Awesome! My mom had my brother circed but is totally supportive of ds2 being whole
post #3 of 6
: This gives me hope for my best friend. She is vehemently pro-circ (even though she doesn't have kids) b/c she works in a nursing home and says that dealing with elderly men who are intact is her main reason for being pro circ (they have more sores, redness, rashes, etc due to there not being enough staff to properly take care of such a sensitive area). What's sad is that in the same conversation she'll talk about elderly women who develop sores underneath their breasts for the same reason and when I pointed out to her that "maybe we should cut off women's breasts too since it is such an inconvenience when they get older" she thought it was nowhere near the same kind of thing. She has a whole list of "reasons" why circing is important so this gives me hope that I can change her mind someday if she decides to have kids...or in general...
post #4 of 6
Quote:
b/c she works in a nursing home and says that dealing with elderly men who are intact is her main reason for being pro circ
EEEE-GADS! That is the same reasoning my RN aunt gives me
So the first 70+ yrs of a man's life he has to be w/o full benifit of being intact just so it's "easier" on his care givers at the end???

Mind you this comes from the very same aunt who defends her grandson's circ with a PASSION even though he has had adhesion issues since birth and to this day (3yrs old) he screams when anyone even attempts to remove his pants:
post #5 of 6
Congrats! It's always nice to be on the same page with your mom. Maybe my mom will come around some day too.
post #6 of 6
That is so wonderful!!!

Thank you for sharing this, it gives me hope that the people in my life will figure it out eventually too
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: The Case Against Circumcision
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Health › The Case Against Circumcision › I Am Ecstatic!!!