It's the egg that gives the pumpkin pie it's texture, so I don't know that the "cream" will make a difference if you can't do eggs. We can't do soy (vegans use tofu in their pumpkin pie usually), and I tried the flax eggs, and it didn't work. We can't use egg replacer (potato starch) or any of the gums, so I think I've given up on pumpkin pie. I did make a pumpkin pie flavored ice cream the other day though, that tasted just like pumpkin pie. And I may try pumpkin cookies one of these days because it's that time of year.