Mothering › Forums › Breastfeeding › Lactivism › Montana breastfeeding laws and an angry co-worker?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Montana breastfeeding laws and an angry co-worker?  

post #1 of 35
Thread Starter 
We have a good friend visiting us right now. She used to work with dh and now is in another state (Montana), working with a Federal agency. She is single and childless by choice. She doesn't like children particularly, which is, of course, her every right. I don't have any problems with that.

The other night, she was talking about her co-workers. One, a woman, just had a baby a couple of months ago. She is breastfeeding and, sometimes, brings the baby to work (at the discretion of the individual office, they can bring their babies to work for the first 6 months).

Well, our friend was going ballistic about this co-worker's pumping! She said, "Gah! I walk into the bathroom and there she is, her udder hooked up to her pump and it is just gross! Nobody wants to see her boobs in the workplace! It's as bad as when I was here and XXX was doing the same thing in the women's room here. At least her boobs were so small the milking machine covered them. Co-workers is built like a 2000 lb -bad word- dairy cow!"

I, asked, gently (because she is a friend, we were having dinner and I didn't want to turn it into a battle), where should she pump? It wasn't like it was at her desk, it's the women's bathroom. Nobody else is seeing anything, except other women, and it isn't like they've never seen breasts before! (trying to keep the conversation as light as I can).

She said she complained to her supervisor about the bathroom pumping and how offensive it is and the woman was told she couldn't do it in the bathroom anymore, she could do it in another area. Well, our friend goes on to say that the new place is worse, it's public, a storage area where they hang their spraying clothes (there would be noxious weeds chemicals there) and it is where the guys sometimes change out of their clothes, when they come in from the field. So, now it is also an inconvenience, as far as our friend is concerned, 'cause the guys have to change someplace else. The "Milk Cow" is now in their area.

She said she complained, again, to her supervisor on the error of this new location just before her vacation (ongoing now) and said she assumes things will be different when she returns to work, after this present visit to our place.

In other words, she doesn't want this woman to be pumping OR breastfeeding at work. She should stay home with her kid and that is that.

I was angry. But, like I said, I was trying to be polite and keep the peace.

I did mention that the co-worker IS protected, by law, and it is her legal right to breastfeed wherever, whenever she wants, and that I thought it was too bad that she had to pump in the women's room in the first place. Who would want their food prepared in a public restroom??

And, that they had better watch out, because the woman had all the makings of a harrassment claim because of being asked to pump in an area with possibly toxic chemicals. It didn't really matter if it bothered anyone, it is her legal right to do this.

Dh was nodding with what I said. He agrees with me and (said later) he thought I was doing just fine!!

She pretty much simmered down at this point. I don't know if it was the words I said or the cool tone as I said them. She changed the subject and we continued our evening.

But, now I can't stop thinking about this. I was, and am, a sahm. I nursed ds until he was 4 1/2 years old. I had a pump (as a just-in-case thing) and used it, perhaps, half a dozen times. Ds never would take a bottle (though he drank a shot glass with breastmilk at 4 days of age!).

So, I don't have any experience with working + pumping + annoying co-workers. I think it would have reduced me to tears, first, and then to legal action, second!

All of this really surprises me about her. She is a very radical feminist. Very "a woman CAN do anything a man can do, except produce sperm" type of gal. She is a former Marine. She plays hockey. She doesn't need a man to complete her nor to compliment her (her words). But, she does love men, too. I just can't understand her extreme reaction to the breastfeeding thing.

I don't see the subject coming up again while she is visiting (she leaves early Wednesday morning). But, if it does (I don't plan on mentioning it), does anyone have some calm replies to her lame arguments?

Though she works for and at a Federal agency, I would think that state laws would still protect the co-worker. I just wanted some clarification if the subject comes up, again.

Thanks, in advance!

P.S. On the good side of this, ds (age almost-10 years old) was up in the loft, listening to the conversation. He asked us later, "What is "A's" problem with breastfeeding? You'd think a woman would be understanding! I guess she's not as cool and smart as I thought she was."
post #2 of 35
I'd so want to track down that mom and encourage her to file a harrassment claim, that is just sooooo wrong.

and btw women can make sperm now
post #3 of 35
Maybe something like "as a feminist I'm really surprised that you would feel like it's ok to force a woman into toxic rooms to do something that is her legal right to do." Imagine what other women's rights could be rescinded because someone found them "offensive".

Reading this post made my blood boil, and I'm a bit of a hothead so I would have had no problems laying it out for this woman. I'd be so disappointed in her as my friend and I'd let her know that. Hearing it from a friend might put it in perspective. So many of these "childfree by choice" people can be so hateful - calling her a cow...I'm really surprised you were able to remain composed.

I agree with OP in wanting to track down that woman, or writing an anonymous letter to her department in defense of the woman, reminding them of her legal rights. She needs a hero right now.
post #4 of 35
Quote:
Originally Posted by grahamsmom98 View Post
She is a very radical feminist.
I think your best bet is to show her how breastfeeding is a feminist issue. Becuase...you know...it is!
post #5 of 35
Quote:
Originally Posted by kangaroomum25 View Post
I'd so want to track down that mom and encourage her to file a harrassment claim, that is just sooooo wrong.

and btw women can make sperm now
Yes, this.

I wish there was a way you could contact that mama and tell her she doesn't have to pump in the bathroom or the toxic storage closet.

I can't believe you kept your cool so well, that must have been hard.
post #6 of 35
I don't know how you managed to keep from asking her to leave. Above and beyond being insulting to breastfeeding, her comments were just.plain.offensive.period. A 2000 pound effing dairy cow??????? How did you keep from slapping her????
post #7 of 35
Because she is a federal worker, she is protected by the federal breastfeeding laws. "Notwithstanding any other provision of law, a woman may breastfeed her child at any location in a Federal building or on Federal property, if the woman and her child are otherwise authorized to be present at the location."
post #8 of 35
Quote:
Originally Posted by KirstenMary View Post
I don't know how you managed to keep from asking her to leave. Above and beyond being insulting to breastfeeding, her comments were just.plain.offensive.period. A 2000 pound effing dairy cow??????? How did you keep from slapping her????
Yes, that. :

Friend or foe, she would've been picking herself up off of the floor. (Of course I am a working and pumping mom, so she would've been PERSONALLY insulting me.) I am impressed by your cool demeanor! That's the best way to deal with things like this, it lets the air out of people.

Anyway, I would ask how precisely she reconciles being a "feminist" and being anti-breastfeeding. Since breastfeeding is a purely female right, if she is against it, she is against SOME women's rights and therefore not a true feminist. Dig?

Good luck.
post #9 of 35
Some calm replies to her lame arguments? How about:

"I think you should complain to the baby--tell him you're not happy with his meals being prepared in the washroom, and ask him if he could arrange for them to be prepared in the staff cafeteria instead--if that's good enough for everyone else, he should be satisfied with that."

Sometimes being facetious is a good way to make a point.

(My apologies if the baby is a girl--I picked a pronoun for convenience.)
post #10 of 35
Please keep in mind that namecalling, no matter how deserved, is against MDC's User Agreement.
post #11 of 35
Wow, as a mom getting ready to return to work and will be pumping at work this really hit home. What an ignorant human being. I apologize since the woman is your friend, however it's mentalities like that which have required frickin legislation to be able to feed a baby in public in the most pure and natural way. She too has fallen into the programming that breasts are sexual objects. Its always just boggled my mind that we must have laws to protect feeding an infant, but thank goodness we have them. I must agree she would have been picking herself up off the floor, it's one thing if I jokingly refer to myself as the cow, it's completely another to have someone who doesn't know the first thing about motherhood or breastfeeding to rudely and cruelly insult a woman caring for her child. Pumping is WORK!!! (my beautiful dd is nursing as I type this with one hand). I again apologize only one word for that woman and it isn't feminist.
post #12 of 35
Quote:
Originally Posted by lacysmommy View Post
Because she is a federal worker, she is protected by the federal breastfeeding laws. "Notwithstanding any other provision of law, a woman may breastfeed her child at any location in a Federal building or on Federal property, if the woman and her child are otherwise authorized to be present at the location."
This applies to members of the public in federal buildings. It does not protect federal employees on the job since it is in the employer's discretion whether she can bring her child to work. Unfortunately, there is no federal workplace pumping or workplace breastfeeding law. Also, sadly, state law does not protect federal employees. In Montana, state law wouldn't help anyway because the workplace pumping law only applies to a select group of public employees:

39-2-215. Public employer policy on support of women and breastfeeding -- unlawful discrimination. (1) All state and county governments, municipalities, and school districts and the university system must have a written policy supporting women who want to continue breastfeeding after returning from maternity leave. The policy must state that employers shall support and encourage the practice of breastfeeding, accommodate the breastfeeding-related needs of employees, and ensure that employees are provided with adequate facilities for breastfeeding or the expression of milk for their children. At a minimum, the policy must identify the means by which an employer will make available a space suitable for breastfeeding and breast pumping for a lactating employee, including the provision of basic necessities of privacy, lighting, and electricity for the pump apparatus. The space does not need to be fully enclosed or permanent, but must be readily available during the term that the employee needs the space.
(2) It is an unlawful discriminatory practice for any public employer:
(a) to refuse to hire or employ or to bar or to discharge from employment an employee who expresses milk in the workplace; or
(b) to discriminate against an employee who expresses milk in the workplace in compensation or in terms, conditions, or privileges of employment unless based upon a bona fide occupational qualification.
post #13 of 35
Wow, how horrible! I've been back at work for a little over a week and I've had no issues. I'm actually getting ready to pump in the next few minutes. I'm military and one of the first things they told me at the clinic was about BF support for nursing mothers. They have to give me access to an approved room (non bathroom) once every 4 hrs.

They have set aside an office for me to use since I work on a large open floor with no privacy. I've had no issues. I've had one guy ask, "Is that breastmilk?" when I put it in the fridge. I said yes and he just chuckled, most people here are of the BTDT attitude.
post #14 of 35
You are much kinder to her than I would have been.

I would try to track down the woman at her workplace.

And how freakin cute is your son :
post #15 of 35
this is all so horrible. first she's got to pump in a bathroom with people coming in and out. Then there is a complaint against the poor pumping mom. Then she's moved to a toxic chemically closet? How horrible!!

Yeah, OP your friend may think shes a feminist, but she sure sounds like she hates one of the most important parts of being a woman...

I don't think I'd be able to hold my tongue at all. I'd say something to the effect of, "wow, and she kept pumping after everything you've done to humiliate her? That's amazing, what an amazing woman. pumping is already so hard, but to have someone go out of their way to make it harder really sucks. I'm so happy your co-worker has stuck with it to give her baby the best nutrition a woman can give her baby, despite your best efforts to make her stop"
post #16 of 35
Quote:
Originally Posted by MommyJoia View Post
I don't think I'd be able to hold my tongue at all. I'd say something to the effect of, "wow, and she kept pumping after everything you've done to humiliate her? That's amazing, what an amazing woman. pumping is already so hard, but to have someone go out of their way to make it harder really sucks. I'm so happy your co-worker has stuck with it to give her baby the best nutrition a woman can give her baby, despite your best efforts to make her stop"
:

It actually is remarkable that she's keeping it up. Maybe next time you chat you can ask her how this woman is doing...I hope she hasn't had more harassment. North America is such an unfriendly place to families. We're so bent on divorcing ourselves from what we are, mammals.
post #17 of 35
your self control is remarkable i think i would have exploded
post #18 of 35
I've thought more about this and I wonder if asking questions rather than making arguments isn't the way to go. I'd ask "Is your issue with breastfeeding or breastpumping?" If it's the latter, I'd try to find out why. It's just possible she's been for a mammogram, or had someone close to her get sick with breast cancer, and she unconsciously makes the connection "breast + machine = cancer." Well, that's what would happen if she were a character in a play or a novel, anyway! It's probably not the case, but questioning her on her issues might give you the material on which you can build the most effective argument.

Good luck!
post #19 of 35
questioning is also good b/c then people really have to think about why they feel a certain way.
post #20 of 35
Holy freakin' crap..

You know, it's a really rare situation that my inner *B* comes out (which is a very good thing since I tend to run my mouth waaay more than is needed at that moment), but ummmmm.. yeah. Close friend or not.. wow. The things she said were beyond offensive. My blood is boiling just reading what you wrote.
I seriously don't think I would have been able to contain myself. Aaaand I'm going to shut up now before I violate the UA.
Ugh.. how disgusting!!


My heart breaks for that poor woman!!! How dare she be treated like that. I've gotta hand it to her, though - just the fact that she continued to keep it up after being treated so horribly repeatedly.....
GOOD FOR HER!! Now, there's a mama on a mission!

I also have to agree with some of the others.. please do see if you can find out more about her and perhaps let her know that how she was/is treated is in NO WAY acceptable.. and also commend her for what she is doing for her baby. Since she has been faced with so much ignorance and hate, she really needs to hear just the opposite.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Lactivism
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Breastfeeding › Lactivism › Montana breastfeeding laws and an angry co-worker?