i have no experience with cathy or susan, but Wendy is great! she helped me get started BFing with dd1. and barbara robertson is the BEST LC i've encountered out here. my dd1 went on a nursing strike at 8mos old. after riding it out for about 2-3wks on our own, i started trying to find a LC to help. i called anyone and everyone i could get the name of. no one had much interest in making an appt to try and help us out. Barbara drove to MY HOUSE in hazel park and had a really detailed appt with us. she charged me a greatly reduced rate b/c she felt bad she couldn't figure out what was going on, but she was the biggest help i had!
we never got dd1 back to nursing again (i EPed until she was 17mos), but barbara definitely went above and beyond. if i ever need an LC with dd2, i'll call barabara before trying anyone else. she's well worth the drive!