Mothering › Forums › Breastfeeding › Lactivism › I'm so disappointed in Ty Pennington....
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

I'm so disappointed in Ty Pennington....  

post #1 of 12
Thread Starter 
...that I decided to write him a letter. Here it is:

November 7, 2008
Dear Mr. Pennington,

I want to first say that I enjoy your show and I think it’s wonderful to see people do nice things for families who have helped their communities. I think that you do great work, and because of that, people want to listen to what you have to say. They like to think that you are working to do good for them.

That being said, I am extremely disappointed to see you endorsing Similac formula. I have seen the ads in many, many places, and each time I see them, I feel discouraged and disheartened. American culture is already not terribly friendly to breastfeeding; many people shame mothers who nurse in public, and many doctors are woefully uneducated about how to resolve breastfeeding issues and end up urging their patients to just give up and switch to formula. Everywhere we look, we see images of babies being fed not from their mothers’ breasts but from bottles.

Not only is breastfeeding what nature intended, but it has been proven over and over again to be the best, healthiest thing for both mother and baby. Both the World Health Organization and the American Academy of Pediatrics recommend strongly that all babies be breastfed for the first two years of their lives. The benefits of breastfeeding for babies include better immune function, higher IQs later in life, lower obesity rates, better gut health, fewer ear infections, better bonding with their mothers, and better health in general. For mothers, it helps them return to a healthy weight after birth, helps prevent breast cancer, helps to comfort baby, and saves time and money. Every day we discover more benefits that were previously unknown.

Many mothers, especially those with lower socioeconomic status, tend to be uneducated about breastfeeding and are taught that formula is “just as good”, when in fact, it is much less healthy for both babies and mothers. By endorsing a brand of formula, you are sending the message that formula is, in fact, just as good as breastmilk. You have the power to send a message to the public, and I find it disappointing that the message you are sending encourages unhealthy practices to new mothers. I know that there are cases where a mother legitimately cannot nurse her baby for one reason or another, but it is my hope that you will stop endorsing a vastly overused product that damages the health of our youngest and most helpless people.


ETA: I think I have the correct address to reach him. I think we should ALL write letters. FLOOD them with letters! Let me know if you want the address.
post #2 of 12
Good for you for writing a letter! I thought the same thing when I saw the ads. How remarkably inappropriate for him to do a formula ad in the first place and how disappointing that women will go for it because the ad has his face. Similacs got some good marketing staffers I guess :
post #3 of 12
post #4 of 12
Good letter!
post #5 of 12
My only suggestion would be to turn your language around. Instead of pointing out all those good things about breastfeeding, point out what the lack of breastfeeding does: increased risk of cancer for mom, increased risk of diabetes, etc., later in life for babies, lower IQ scores on average, etc. You might also want to point out the many formula recalls in the US and ask if he really wants his stellar reputation being associated with something so potentially damaging. The way it reads now, formula is the norm with lots of "extra goodies" provided by breastfeeding. Am I making sense?
post #6 of 12
Quote:
Originally Posted by Turkish Kate View Post
My only suggestion would be to turn your language around. Instead of pointing out all those good things about breastfeeding, point out what the lack of breastfeeding does: increased risk of cancer for mom, increased risk of diabetes, etc., later in life for babies, lower IQ scores on average, etc. You might also want to point out the many formula recalls in the US and ask if he really wants his stellar reputation being associated with something so potentially damaging. The way it reads now, formula is the norm with lots of "extra goodies" provided by breastfeeding. Am I making sense?
:

I think we really need to work on changing our language on this issue. It's not just that "breast is best," it's that formula causes health problems!

Way to go writing that letter!
post #7 of 12
This is great! I just saw one of the ads in People Magazine and was really sorry to see Ty was doing them. I don't see what he has to do with formula or babies??? Other than maybe moms might find him attractive???

Your letter is great; I agree with talking about the benefits of bf'ing as standard, and the risks of formula.
post #8 of 12
I don't even get why he is promoting it. Does he even have any children? What about all his shows helping families after their home has been destroyed by a natural disaster like hurricanes and tornados? Has it occurred to him that in those circumstances, a mom using formula then has no way of safely feeding her baby at all?
post #9 of 12


Good letter mama!
post #10 of 12
I really am glad you did this. I have seen the ads and thought great another but now male celeb endorcer. I will write one to.
post #11 of 12
Quote:
Originally Posted by LinzluvsGJ View Post
I don't even get why he is promoting it. Does he even have any children?
I wondered what on earth he had to do with formula...and then I got the ad in the mail. It's all about the "newly designed" container the formula comes in. He's a designer or whatever. The ad also had a "lovely" tag line that read "now even closer to breastmilk!". Sure...it might be closer...but it's still about 10 miles off! : I'm sure he doesn't know anything about it...and I'm sure they're paying him a pretty penny.
post #12 of 12
Let's keep this to the Lactivism issue--great letter, by the way! There's a thread in TAO if you want to discuss Ty Pennington.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Lactivism
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Breastfeeding › Lactivism › I'm so disappointed in Ty Pennington....