I've been making yogurt for a while, so I don't have to buy yogurt very often anymore. But, when we're travelling or visiting others, sometimes we buy Brown COw. I don't like Stonyfield for a couple of reasons...the yogurt is gross--I really don't like how they put all the fillers and thickeners in, the consistency makes me gag; also, they are owned by Dannon (but now you tell me Brown Cow was bought by Stonyfield, so I guess that sucks, too!!). The Brown Cow tastes and seems more like real yogurt than Stonyfield. It seems like most places that sell Brown Cow also sell Seven Stars, can you get that kind? It's really tasty and is biodynamic and organic. Also still independently owned, as far as I know.
So, anyway, I would choose Brown Cow b/c it is apparantly from grassfed cows, and they at least ensure that their cows don't get BgH, and they don't add wierd things to their yogurt, like Stonyfield, even though Stonyfield is organic; The Brown Cow just seems and tastes like healthier yogurt.