Mothering Forums

Mothering Forums (http://www.mothering.com/forum/)
-   Unassisted Childbirth (http://www.mothering.com/forum/306-unassisted-childbirth/)
-   -   fetal doppler (http://www.mothering.com/forum/306-unassisted-childbirth/1245691-fetal-doppler.html)

mamaofthree 07-21-2010 03:25 PM

i want to get a fetal doppler, have any of you gotten them and what do you think of the one you got? i don't have alot to spend, but i don't want to be wasting money either. and renting one seems pretty silly as they can be expensive after 5 months.

thanks

h

tammyswanson 07-21-2010 03:43 PM

Isn't a doppler some sort of ultrasound? I wouldn't do the U/S or doppler again, I read it can cause problems. A stethoscope seems much safer IMO.

HappilyEvrAfter 07-21-2010 04:47 PM

I have one that I used during my first pregnancy. It was about $40 and was nice to have piece of mind....cool to hear the heart beat anytime I wanted and others had fun listening too. It also had a recording feature.

Now I just lend it out as friends find out their pregnant or let my kiddo hear his own heartbeat (which he's been intrigued with lately).

I haven't read anything about the dopplar being harmful, but my son seems to have turned out just fine.

mamaofthree 07-21-2010 06:42 PM

happily: do you recall the brand?

thanks

h

corrio 07-22-2010 03:19 PM

Yes a doppler is a form of ultrasound.. All you need to do is google risks/dangers or ultrasound and there will be more then enough info..

As a person who had a full term loss, having a doppler during my last unassisted birth (who is now 3 weeks old) was very important to me.. I got mine off e-bay for about a 100 dollars.

I used it twice in labor, I had my husband do it once and then he was off taking my older children to school and I checked when I knew I was ready to push..

If the benefits out weigh the risks then get one but if you just want to hear the heart beat i would reccomend a fetoscope..

HappilyEvrAfter 07-22-2010 03:23 PM

Quote:
Originally Posted by mamaofthree View Post
happily: do you recall the brand?

thanks

h
Oh, no, sorry. It's loaned out at the moment or I would look for you!

mamaofthree 07-22-2010 04:05 PM

just to clarify: i have no issue with the occasional use of a doppler. what i would love to know is what brand people have used and if they liked the brand they got, if they felt it was worth the money.
i have 5 healthy children, but i have also had three miscarriages. so yes it do "just want to hear the heart beat", i feel better knowing the baby is alive especially since it is a bit early to feel it.

h

2ID_Wife 07-23-2010 08:56 AM

I got one just just about 100$ I use it just about once a month and for DH since even when I make appts he can never go. I still have no found it from my move so I am not sure what brand it is.

Blue_Spiral 07-27-2010 01:31 AM

Just last week or two my husband and I were finally able to feel our baby move from the outside. At least once a day now we are able to feel him kick our hands.

At my last prenatal check-up she put the doppler to my belly and BAM! he kicked it TWICE. Not just once, but twice, a couple inches apart.

He kicked it harder than he has ever kicked our hands and it was as if he was kicking the doppler itself on purpose.

It may just be in my head, but that was the first time it occurred to me that maybe a doppler's not a great thing for a baby.

I had read stuff about ultrasounds but never heard the mention of an actual doppler as unsafe.

My immediate reaction was, "wow, he doesn't like that doppler." Even if that doesn't make a lot of sense...

I'm interested to see that some think it's harmful.

~Demeter~ 07-27-2010 02:03 PM

I got mine off of ebay.. it was around 80 dollars. It's a sonoline. I had a miscarriage 6 weeks prior to conceiving this baby so I felt I needed it for peace of mind. It helped with the anxiety. I never left it on my belly for very long, just long enough to hear the heartbeat and then I would shut it off. It was especially helpful when I wasn't feeling as icky at the end of the first tri before movement really kicked in.

ETA: I just want to say the doppler is the only intervention I have sought out this pregnancy. It really helped me relax when I felt it was hard to relax. I have not had an u/s or sought out prenatal care even. know it's not totally in line with the UC 'philosophy' but that doesn't necessarily fit for everybody and every situation.

lovestolearn 07-28-2010 01:33 PM

My understanding is that 1 min of doppler use = 30 min of Ultrasound exposure.

Personally, I wouldn't use a doppler. Here's one article that convinced me not to. There are many more out there.

northcountrymamma 07-28-2010 01:45 PM

Quote:
Originally Posted by lovestolearn View Post
My understanding is that 1 min of doppler use = 30 min of Ultrasound exposure.

Personally, I wouldn't use a doppler. Here's one article that convinced me not to. There are many more out there.
Not a UC mamma but found this thread through a search.

This article is fantastic, this was what I showed to DP when he wasn't sure on the whole avoiding us, doppler use.

mamaofthree 07-28-2010 05:59 PM

i appreciate all the concern... but after 3 miscarriages i want to know my baby is alive. so i got one. if you choose not to use on, be my guest. i support all sorts of peoples views and choices. again i did not ask for scary stories i wanted product information.

h

mwherbs 07-28-2010 06:09 PM

so there are some on ebay that are waterproof and sell for fairly cheap- a mw I work with has that one and it works ok the button is a little tricky as it is inset so you push the button down lower than flush but the cost was less than 150$

~Demeter~ 07-28-2010 07:32 PM

Quote:
Originally Posted by lovestolearn View Post
My understanding is that 1 min of doppler use = 30 min of Ultrasound exposure.

Personally, I wouldn't use a doppler. Here's one article that convinced me not to. There are many more out there.

We all have our reasons for making the choices we make. I also don't knock someone for their choices... like I said we are all on different paths in this journey and have had different experiences that cause us to make different choices. I'm quite certain that those of us that have used the doppler that are choosing to have a UC birth know the supposed risks and are comfortable accepting them for peace of mind which is necessary in any pregnancy.

kittywitty 07-28-2010 08:04 PM

Quote:
Originally Posted by ~Demeter~ View Post
We all have our reasons for making the choices we make. I also don't knock someone for their choices... like I said we are all on different paths in this journey and have had different experiences that cause us to make different choices. I'm quite certain that those of us that have used the doppler that are choosing to have a UC birth know the supposed risks and are comfortable accepting them for peace of mind which is necessary in any pregnancy.
I agree. I wish I had one during my last UC. I had a stethoscope (my fetoscope was terrible), but it's hard to check with that when you're laboring IME. I would like one this time, again, but they are so expensive! I wish I could buy one secondhand or rent one for a little while for cheaper. I know all about the safety issues and sure my kids have kicked the doppler. They've also violently kicked and punched me. It just amplifies the noise-and they tend to kick when you push in the belly at all, like while feeling for body parts and position.

OP- Can you update us on which one you get if you do get one?

lovestolearn 07-28-2010 08:36 PM

I'm not knocking anyone for their choices, just sharing my perspective and information. Feel free to ignore my post if you wish!

Quote:
I'm quite certain that those of us that have used the doppler that are choosing to have a UC birth know the supposed risks and are comfortable accepting them for peace of mind which is necessary in any pregnancy.
This actually hasn't been my experience, either here or on the Bornfree forum. Many women have assumed that they are safe because their midwife used one, or that dopplers are less "intrusive" than ultrasounds.

Also, with respect to the OP, lots of other women read these threads and may be interested in this information, even if you already have made up your mind.

DFiona90 03-07-2014 04:00 PM

Considering that the Sonoline B is FDA approved, I also believe the benefits outweigh the risk. Speaking from personal experience, using mine has quelled any worries and kept my stress levels down. I believe that is the best thing I can do for my baby.

 

I did a lot of research and decided to get the Sonoline B since it seems to be the best one out there. I actually got it for $57 which seems cheaper than everyone on this post so far.

 

I got it at fetaldopplerbeats.com. I really can't recommend this product enough :joy 


RorysMum 03-08-2014 06:48 PM

I have ordered the Sonoline also. Should be getting it in a few days. I had a fetoscope and found it so difficult to use. I want peace of mind during the labour...first UC for me :)

 

I got mine for 57 also...plus shipping. 70 total.

 

Good to hear it is highly recommended!


rachie 03-27-2014 05:42 PM

I would rather avoid ultra-sound waves and doppler use (this is my first pregnancy I am not planning to get any sonograms/ultrasounds) BUT I ordered a doppler for about $50 on ebay.  In my case I will likely only use it during labor IN CASE we cannot seem to find it with the fetoscope we have and are concerned at some point about the baby.  I got a Sonoline B.  I hope it works well if we need it.  I will post a review but it won't be for awhile.  

 

Right now it's kind of early to hear the heartbeat clearly with the fetoscope since I'm only 16 weeks along.  We tried but my husband couldn't really tell, even though he's heard our previous baby with the same fetoscope but it was later in pregnancy.  

 

I plan to read the link about doppler use, as I like to be informed about what I'm using so I'm glad someone posted that BUT I totally understand where someone who has been through several losses may really need to feel some peace of mind and being stressed out during pregnancy is not good for mama or baby either.  


rachie 04-01-2014 09:56 AM

Okay - I just wanted to update here.  My Sonoline B came in the mail yesterday and we decided to go ahead and try to find a hb.  I went over my concerns with my husband that I wanted it to be as fast as possible to limit exposure to the ultra-sound waves.  It took him all of 5 seconds to find the hb (I'm 17 weeks) and see the rate on the screen.  It wasn't the best because he wasn't pushing as hard as a mw or ob/gyn does with a doppler (from previous pregnancies) but it was enough that the doppler picked up the heartbeat clearly and it was obviously the baby's heart-rate, which was around 120.  We decided that was plenty for our knowledge and "records" since we are up and uc.  We don't plan to use it again until the birth and only then if we feel something might be wrong *if* we can't pick it up well on the fetascope.  Overall - it was cheap, it worked and it worked well enough and fast enough that we were able to really limit baby's exposure time to a doppler to much shorter than it would be with conventional care.   


bcgartley 04-02-2014 02:07 AM

Quote:
Originally Posted by DFiona90 View Post
 

Considering that the Sonoline B is FDA approved, I also believe the benefits outweigh the risk.

 

I know I am a little late on this thread but this sentence kind of bothered me. The FDA approves all sorts of products that aren't necessarily good for you: amalgam, certain food additives, livestock anti-biotics, etc.. The "FDA Approved" sticker really gives me no peace-of-mind.



All times are GMT -7. The time now is 02:18 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Resources saved on this page: MySQL 7.14%
vBulletin Optimisation provided by vB Optimise (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2014 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
User Alert System provided by Advanced User Tagging (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2014 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.