rectal temp at the Dr's? - Mothering Forums

rectal temp at the Dr's?

Wittyone's Avatar Wittyone (TS)
10:19 PM Liked: 12
#1 of 12
09-19-2006 | Posts: 738
Joined: May 2005
DH and I took ds to the Dr yesterday for a check up. He had an intermittant rattle in his chest that we thought was probably allergies and he is most obviously NOT sick, but we wanted to get it checked. Our doc is a family doc (not ped), delayed/non-vax friendly, etc, etc...we like the office. Well, the medical assistant took us back, weighed him and then told my husband to turn him over on the exam table b/c she needed to get his temp and "of course it will be rectally." I spoke up and said we would not be doing a rectal temp and she argued that's the way it's done in infants under 1 and yes we would....ummm, no. She finally said well then *you* can explain to the nurse practitioner why he didn't have his temp taken (no offer to do an axillary one).

Naturally the NP never mentioned it b/c he *wasn't sick*...although I'd be *very* reluctant to agree to a rectal temp even if he was sick. I didn't say anything to the NP b/c she's brand new to the practice and we had other things to discuss with her. However, I'm an RN, I work with newborns, I know you can get an accurate enough temp under the arm. A rectal temp is invasive and unecessary IMO. I would expect this argument at the ER, but in the doctor's office?!? I guess this is mostly a rant, but I also want to know:

when you take you dc to the doc for anything other than a WBV, how do they take the temp?

any references on why rectal temps are NOT necessary...I'd like to send some literature to the office

Thanks mamas!
momtoNatalee's Avatar momtoNatalee
10:34 PM Liked: 0
#2 of 12
09-19-2006 | Posts: 1,327
Joined: Nov 2005
Wow, that is crazy. Don't have any literature to send. When I USED to take dd to well baby visits, they always took her temp w/ the ear kind (sick or not).
the_lissa's Avatar the_lissa
10:35 PM Liked: 12
#3 of 12
09-19-2006 | Posts: 11,838
Joined: Oct 2004
Don't have any lit, but ime, temps have always been done orally or in the armpit, and that is with drs, midwives, and nurses.
laralee16's Avatar laralee16
10:35 PM Liked: 730
#4 of 12
09-19-2006 | Posts: 1,499
Joined: Nov 2005
I wont told that recal is the ONLY way to get the temp on a baby under a year old. That anything eles would be wrong. Hmmm, then again, i have only had one doctors office take it that way, and they were kinda...:
annekevdbroek's Avatar annekevdbroek
10:39 PM Liked: 13
#5 of 12
09-19-2006 | Posts: 3,168
Joined: Jun 2005
Our ped clinic uses either the ear thing, or more recently some sort of magic wand that they rub on the forehead. They say it is quite accurate.

The only time I EVER used a rectal temp on my DS was when he had a temp on our ear reader of 105 and I called the nurse line to determine if I needed to take him to the ER at 3am. She suggested a more accurate reading (rectal) and close monitoring.... But for a routine visit in a non-very-ill child I can't imagine why they'd even want to go there, KWIM?
rebeccalizzie's Avatar rebeccalizzie
10:47 PM Liked: 8
#6 of 12
09-19-2006 | Posts: 1,505
Joined: Mar 2005
I've been going to the same pediatric practice since *I* was little, and they have always taken temps axillary, or now they use the forehead wand thing (which is very cool). When I took DS to one of their satellite offices for his first check, the nurse took a rectal temp and I about hit her. She was checking his weight and all that without a dipe, and I didn't realize what she was doing until she had already started. I asked her what the heck, since their main office doesn't do that, and she said "well, it's the best way and *our* office does". I complained to the doctor, and if we end up at that office again there is no way it will happen again...especially not for a well visit! Who the heck cares if his temp is a tenth of a degree different for a well visit!

The only way I will ever consent to a rectal temp is if he is sick enough that they really do need a perfectly accurate temp.
*guest's Avatar *guest
11:07 PM Liked: 0
#7 of 12
09-19-2006 | Posts: 1,396
Joined: Oct 2005
Augh. I had a fight with a nurse at our practice about this. I brought my daughter in to confirm thrush and they wanted to do it. They did it once at a sick visit for something else, and it was so awful I said never again. I was told that rectal was their policy for infants under 3 months. I said "how big can you write REFUSED on her chart?" In the hospital when she was born, they only took it under her arm. When she had surgery at 1 month at Children's Hospital, they checked the ear. So non-rectal is good enough for some of the best hospitals in Massachusetts, yet Nurse Ratched must poke her bum because she thrush?! : The doctor didn't care that we skipped it.
rmzbm's Avatar rmzbm
11:11 PM Liked: 14
#8 of 12
09-19-2006 | Posts: 15,098
Joined: Jul 2005
I take temps. under arm.
I would not allow a rectal temp.
snoopy5386's Avatar snoopy5386
11:56 PM Liked: 13
#9 of 12
09-19-2006 | Posts: 2,575
Joined: May 2005
my doc has never taken DDs temp, but I have a few times at home and honestly I find it much easier to do a rectal temp than under the arm. We have a 5 second rectal thermometer, and DD doesn't even seem to notice when I stick it in, but trying to use the regular digital thermometer under her arm, now that was a nightmare. She was screaming because I was trying to hold her arm down for 60 seconds. So in our house, rectal thermometer equals easier at least for now. Who knew?
huggerwocky's Avatar huggerwocky
12:13 AM Liked: 0
#10 of 12
09-20-2006 | Posts: 5,396
Joined: Jun 2004
It won't be happening, we haven;t been to the peds yet. Good I read this thread, I'll make sure I'll undress her myself for weighing and minimize any handling by others.
wendizbaby's Avatar wendizbaby
01:36 AM Liked: 20
#11 of 12
09-20-2006 | Posts: 891
Joined: Jul 2005
I didn't even know that taking a rectal temp was a problem? I guess it's invasive, but my ds smiles and laughs every time I do it.

paquerette's Avatar paquerette
02:00 AM Liked: 297
#12 of 12
09-20-2006 | Posts: 6,594
Joined: Oct 2004
The first few visits at our ped they did it, but if I'd known then what I know now, I would never have allowed it.
Reply Subscribe Life With a Baby
Powered by vBadvanced CMPS v3.2.3