
Thread Tools 
I don't know yet whether it will be the answer, but I'm still very excited about this new math book. My son's after school mentor found it for us. It's this Prealgebra from The Art of Problem Solving, which I see now has a whole website. Ooh baby.
(Oh, what a weird thing it is to have a kid who likes math. I would never have imagined me saying "ooh baby" about pages and pages of difficult math problems before I had a kid.)
I think there are a few of us who have kids who are really into math. I don't think my kid looks gifted across the boardhe has some problems with writing that seem very sticky. School is going pretty well for him and he's slowly working out his issues with words. The only thing that was a total disappointment was how the school dealt with his math gifts.
This book series seems to teach math in a systematic way for the precise audience my kid fits: the passionate math lover.
Has anyone used these? We aren't going to be homeschooling with them. Probably he'll get to use them during an enrichment period at school. I cannot imagine they'll let him use them instead of the math curriculum.
Divorced mom of one awesome boy born 232003.
Sponsored Links  
Advertisement


We discovered AoPS a few years ago. My then11yearold was quite entranced by it, but she found it got too challenging too quickly. It was tough for her to turn each page and find yet another problem that she could just barely manage to solve. She really missed the feeling of competence and mastery she would have got from being able to solve a few simpler problems easily once in a while. Now, this was Intro to Algebra (PreAlgebra wasn't available at the time), she was working on it completely independently with no adult support as was her preference at the time as a stubborn unschooler, and she had no real frame of reference to make it clear to her that this was not by any stretch what most 11yearolds were doing. She got bogged down and abandoned it about a quarter of the way through. But if she'd had the earlier level and some adult support and some other less challenging math going on at the time, I think it would have made a big difference. Your ds's experience will probably be different.
Miranda
Mountain mama to two great kids and two great grownups
I think the prealgebra book is fantastic. The problems are so thoughtful and rich. Many of the problems look tricky at first glance, but have a trick that makes them actually very simplethat piece is very rewarding for kids, I think. And the organization is so beautiful, the way the ideas build.
Another book that might work well for dabbling is Jacobs: Math, A Human Endeavor. Very different, chattier, lots of fun problems to play with. It is not as thorny mathematically, but more appliedthere will be a lesson or theme for the chapter (number sequences, or probability), and then different reallife examples of how that idea might applythe counting and probability problems might be how to make a pair of fake dice that will win at craps, or how many ways there are that a world series game can come out if the home team has already won two games.
ETA, if you possibly can talk them into letting DS use AoPS instead of the curriculum, you'll have a fantastically mathrich kid. Not having to plow through the regular math might be pretty good incentive for working through AoPS :)
One thing I think would help him stick with this book is if I can scan and print out the pages. I know that sounds like a very silly thing to say. I think being stuck for a long time in the beginning of the book will be disheartening. Each section is the right length, though. You're right about mastery, Miranda. I think he can master every piece of this, but it will be less daunting if he's only working on one thing at a time.
This is the balance between adequate challenge and too much challenge. If I had been any good at this stuff, I would have much more of a reference for what to expect, but since I wasn't, I don't. I just really like the authorial voice in this book. It sounds like a math geek writing for a younger math geekcompanionable. The best thing about this is that the material maps onto the stuff he's learning at schoolit's just more challenging.
Well, I don't want to get so excited that I count my chickens before they've hatched. Anyway I should leave all counting to the kid, since he likes it so much...
Divorced mom of one awesome boy born 232003.
It sounds like a math geek writing for a younger math geekcompanionable.
This is such a good descriptionrings true for the tone of the book, and also for the problems themselves.
My son has done the AoPS prealgebra and algebra online. Even if you don't sign up for the classes, you can do alcumus. Some of the problems are purposely too hard for kids to solve. The point is to teach them persistence.
We loved the prealgebra, but finally gave up on the algebra. However, while my child always did really well in math, it wasn't her "thing". . . she wasn't driven to figure it out. We literally just switched, our new algebra book hasn't even arrived yet.
I do have a question though: did I misunderstand you when you mentioned scanning in a bit at a time? I felt that every part of the book was needed; the way the material was presented was meant for a kid who loved math, but the problems built on each other. I hope you aren't just trying to let him sample the curriculum. If you just think the thickness of the book will be daunting, don't worry about it. Each section has several pages of problems/explanations so it doesn't take long before making it to the middle of the book.
Amy
Mom to three very active girls Anna (15), Kayla (12), Maya (9).
Oh, I was going to scan pages in order, because of the thickness of the book. I'm hoping he can use it in public school for enrichment. It would be nice if he didn't have to carry the huge book back and forth. I could be wrong about this.
I don't have a plan for him to skip around the book. I also had the sense that the authors were building. My sense (since I know nothing about math!) is that they're using arithmetic problems that he can do already to illustrate new concepts. I am assuming at some point the problems are going to get harder for him, though.
Divorced mom of one awesome boy born 232003.
Oh, I was going to scan pages in order, because of the thickness of the book. I'm hoping he can use it in public school for enrichment. It would be nice if he didn't have to carry the huge book back and forth. I could be wrong about this.
I don't have a plan for him to skip around the book. I also had the sense that the authors were building. My sense (since I know nothing about math!) is that they're using arithmetic problems that he can do already to illustrate new concepts. I am assuming at some point the problems are going to get harder for him, though.
That makes sense. It is a heavy book.
And, yes, the problems get very challenging. It can be fun though.
Amy
Mom to three very active girls Anna (15), Kayla (12), Maya (9).
Thread Tools  
Show Printable Version Show Printable Version
Email this Page Email this Page


Posting Rules  
Online Users: 10,249 
16 members and 10,233 guests 
BinCar , cloa513 , Criss Pirlo , daddytap , foreskin_is_normal , katelove , Lutfar Rahman Chisty , MamaByGodsGrace , Moda Ani , omarinbox1888 , PSoulfidis , RosemaryV , rubelin , sciencemum , shantimama 
Most users ever online was 449,755, 06252014 at 12:21 PM. 