I didn't have stairs again until #3 was 2, and we never bothered at that point. We finally put some up when #4 was a toddler and we were homeschooling. I could no longer just jump up and follow him. He had mastered the actual stairs, but I couldn't leave him on another level by himself.
Raising a full house- Kings (12, 3, new) over Queens (8, 7)
I can't even imagine living w/o our gates. They make it *SO* much easier to just let the boys play and not be worried about them climbing up and falling down them all the time, yk? I'd just feel like I had to keep both eyes on them 24/7, and I'm not into that. I'd rather be able to sit and relax sometimes, yk? And w/o them... I just couldn't.
I live in a split entry, and have stairs right at the juncture of my kitchen and living room. It is a very high traffic area in my home. There is also a half wall beside them, so if I am sitting on the couch, I can't see the stairs. They are just too close for (my) comfort to not have a gate.
I also have two large dogs (60lbs and 100lbs) and I worry about them bumping into a wobbly toddler and knocking them down the stairs.
So we absolutely have a hard mounted gate. [It is also a requirement for my home daycare, but we had it before anyways.]
Wife to DH (06/10) and Mummy to DD (07/08).
Mama to Elsa Louise: 2/10, 13lbs 8 oz and Oscar Allen: 7/12, 13lbs 8 oz
Anne, Mama to Conner 2/27/04 Gabrielle 2/6/06 W/LMC-TCS, Neurogenic Bladder, AFO & KAFO wearer, Neurogenic Bowel & Delaney 5/12/08 & Beethoven & Gizmo
The way our stairs are it would pretty much be impossible to install a gate as they angle out from the wall and have posts on both sides. What I did for those months where I was most concerned was to put chairs in front of the steps...that at least slowed them down and alerted me to what was going on by the noise of them moving the chairs.
They aren't that cheap but I really feel we'll need a gate. That's the only un-friendly-to-baby thing in the house. Otherwise she can have free range.
We have one gate hard mounted at the top of the stairs, it only gets closed at night when we, me & DH, have gone to bed; or when we might be totally indisposed - bathroom or shower and DD is up stairs with us. The last one up closes it. Now that DD is 3 we mostly use it at night.
Our upstairs is really just a hallway with a bedroom at each end and the bathroom directly across from the stairs, so there isn't a lot of room. We mostly worried about DD walking from her room to our room at night, if she woke up and wanted us.
We kept a watchful eye on DD around the stairs, and allowed her to climb them with supervision and certain rules - No playing on them etc. This helped a lot especially when we went to our families' houses when they didn't have gates either. DD had learned to wait for an adult to say she could go down and to be careful. There was probably a little more anxiety than if we had waited, but at least she was learning how to be safe on the stairs while she was little and moved slower. She started out climbing the first few steps, and down and as she got to be a better crawler/ climber and eventually walker she did more of the stairs. Now she goes up and down freely without us worrying.
So far, so good. The only thing I'm a tad worried about is when we transition her out of out bed and into the room with our other two kids, I worry a bit about her having to walk past the staircase in the middle of the night. We'll cross that bridge when we come to it--not for another 6-12 months, at least).
Of course it is entirely optional but then again.. many kids many times
will grew up withouth using one and yet many will end up with life long disabilities due to not taking advantage of one.
Back on topic.. the gates.. they are slightly inconvenient to the adults but I think this is a little price to pay for the added safety. Especially when a child starts carawling and using all kinds of ride on little contraptions it is super easy to just misscalculate speed, angle and child might simply roll out the stairs into the staircase downstairs.
I think that this is a decission every parent is facing but for us personally it was no-brainer. Just comparing to what "might" "could" happen without a gate made us decide pro gates. It is not that you can keep a child forever from climbing it and all but it is entirely different even if a child is old enough and strong enough to climb it as they are just skillful enough and this is different mind set to climb a gate then have an unprotected ditch that a child might end up in by total accident and misscalculation.
I would like to encourage you to read this article "Kidscan't fly - preventing fall injuries" to gain more perspective on the gate issue..
just take a look at the number of falls from the stairs among children in the
year 2002 - (see the table on the second page) :
250 000 falls..
I think that this number alone gives good idea aobut how dangerous stairs are in case of little children.
Good luck with your choice making process.
I think child proofing is more about the individual child's temperament than anything else.
Doula mama to dd (Oct '11) & ds (Oct '08) and expecting (Apr '17)
My house has a stairwell to the basement in between the kitchen and living room. It is a hard stair with metal strips on the edge of each step for traction. My house is small so we're always near that stairwell. So for my sanity I really prefer a gate on the stairs, though I COULD have just constantly redirected from 10 months to 2 years or so with DD. DD is a cautious personality and was late in getting mobile.
Now we're going to have two more, and I don't think I could do it without a gate there. Especially if the twins are more adventurous or earlier walkers than their sister.
We also have an upstairs, which has basically bedrooms and a bathroom. I could have gotten away without a gate there because DD sleeps with us and is fine on the stairs now at 2yo. But it was nice to be able to, say, let her wander around while I put away clothes without worrying.
Both gates are down for the time being, but I will put them back up when the twins start getting mobile.
Of course it is entirely optional but then again.. many kids many times will grew up without using one and yet many will end up with life long disabilities due to not taking advantage of one.
They are slightly inconvenient to the adults, but I think this is a little price to pay for the added safety.
Baby gates are safe when they are used within the parameters of normal operation as set by the manufacturer. What has become apparent is that a toddler, a preschooler and a six year old are not able to use stair gates according to any sort of usage guidelines. Monitoring the gates for appropriate usage and proper installation is enough of a task with three small kids using them that it seems easier to just monitor the baby and skip the gates.
Especially when a child starts crawling and using all kinds of ride on little contraptions it is super easy to just miscalculate speed, angle and child might simply roll out the stairs into the staircase downstairs.
I think that this is a decission every parent is facing but for us personally it was no-brainer. Just comparing to what "might" "could" happen without a gate made us decide pro gates.
It is not that you can keep a child forever from climbing it and all but it is entirely different even if a child is old enough and strong enough to climb it as they are just skillful enough and this is different mind set to climb a gate then have an unprotected ditch that a child might end up in by total accident and miscalculation.
We have a lot of experience with kids and stairs. We have four kids, and we just moved out of a town house with four levels of living space. Our girls shared the loft as a bedroom which was accessed by set of spiral stairs. We've had all sorts of gates, including custom built gates that were bolted through the wall. I didn't start out wanting to avoid baby gates. I've come to this after seeing kids use and abuse the gates, and seeing babies and toddlers learn to use stairs carefully (and very quickly) when they had the opportunity.
I would like to encourage you to read this article "Kidscan't fly - preventing fall injuries" to gain more perspective on the gate issue.. just take a look at the number of falls from the stairs among children in the year 2002 - (see the table on the second page) : 250 000 falls..
It isn't completely clear, but I believe that those numbers are emergency room visits for all persons under the age of 16.
This is really a whole other topic, but my experience has been that these types of articles, PSAs, etc breed hypersensitivity to certain dangers. My MIL has caused so many near falls by not letting our kids concentrate on stairs while she nagged them about being careful, and jumped around making gasping noises and causing a massive visual distraction.
I won't deny that stairs, playgrounds, and beds are a factor in many falls, but honestly, you take reasonable precautions and accept a certain amount of risk in life. I would suggest that inattention is the biggest risk factor for most falls and other accidents, not lack of safety devices. It is not uncommon for people to rely on safety devices, and take risks they wouldn't normally take because they feel safer with the devices in place.
Like most parents, I started out assuming that babies and toddlers would fling themselves down stairs like lemmings. Of course, I can only speak for our own children, but when given the opportunity I found that they actually approached things like stairs in a very cautious and mindful way. I won't deny that I find the learning period stressful, but once we're through it, I feel safer knowing that our kids know what their bodies can do and know how to handle themselves in more challenging environments.
When it came right down to it, I felt that a 14 month old who knew how to go up and down stairs was safer than baby gates being improperly used and abused by other children. I knew that DS (or anybody else) could fall, but in the grand scheme of things it seemed that developing and using good stair skills offered the greater safety overall. And so, the baby gates came down with our first DS after about eight weeks.
DS #2 is now 11 months, and he knows how to climb down the stairs. He can't do the whole flight yet, but he's making really good progress. For a long time he would just lay on the upstairs landing and look down over the edge of the top step. He started going down on his own about two weeks ago. He figured out to turn around and go feet first on his own. The top and bottom of our stairs wind around a corner, and he knew to cruise along to the fattest part of the winder stair. I know that he could fall, but with the progress he's making he should be able to go up and down completely on his own sometime in the next six to eight weeks.
I want to be clear though that I'm not campaigning against stair gates. I'm just looking to connect with other parents who found themselves in a similar situation to our own.
In our case it was not a dangerous choice at all- the kids were only upstairs as toddlers when they were with us in our bedroom or bathroom. Then we could close doors (and did when they were at stages that it was needed)
Posted via Mobile Device
DS crawled at about 10 months, but didn't seem to even notice the stairs for many months after that. He did figure out how to go up and down, and he goes very slowly and carefully. At this point, it also seems very unfair to DD that she wouldn't be able go up to her room and play with her toys freely if we had a gate.
Hopefully it's a decision I won't regret (not that it was a decision so much as it was us never getting to a point that we thought that our kids are in grave danger and we need to go out and buy a gate). And I'm pregnant now, so it's perfectly possible that #3 will be a little daredevil child and by 6 months I'll be needing a gate before she hurtles herself down the stairs again.
We also have an old house with very wonky stairs. First of all, the ceilings are so low that the staircase isn't terribly tall. It also has steep risers and narrow treads that are a PITA for most adults, but actually seem to be the perfect size for a toddler to be able to creep down very slowly and carefully. You'd think that this setup would make things even more dangerous, but for some reason it works really well. If we had a more conventional staircase, we'd probably be more likely to have a gate.
He is a little scary on them at the moment because he sometimes turns around & stands up on a step & terrifies me, but I'm sure he'll get past that soon.
Oh, we did use a playyard to block the bottom of the stairs for awhile because he'd climb up and disturb the older boys when they were going to sleep, but it wasn't because of the stairs, that was just a convenient way to keep him from waking his brothers.
mom to all boys B: 08/01, C: 07/05 , N: 03/09 , M: 01/12 and far too many lost ones
Once I had DS2 I ended up ditching the gates for much the same reasons the OP stated once he became mobile having a 6 year old and a2 year old messing with the gates made them seem unsafe. I was constantly readjusting them and the kitchen one damaged the plaster becoming impossible to install correctly.
I would say I spent over 200 bucks on gates and that ultimately they were a complete waste of money.
Ima Sophie + D + J =
To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 10 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.
A big factor in our life without gates is that our DS simply was always playing near us.
I wouldn't have, for example, left him alone upstairs at an age young enough where I would need to worry about him falling down the stairs. I guess that is another way of saying he wasn't playing unsupervised, near stairs, until he was old enough to safely handle the stairs. Now, that being said, we live in a large old house.
If I lived in smaller house with a different layout, maybe we would have needed a gate somewhere. I can think of friends houses where the basement stairs are open, right between the kitchen and family room. A little one could easily tumble down those stairs in the blink of an eye.
I do think house layout and a child's personality a big factors.
All of my kids have been interested in climbing stairs and I just help them learn. The worst that would happen is they would fall down 6 stairs onto hardwood floors, and it happened once or twice to each of them.
If I had a house with 20+ stairs that were not carpeted I would think about having gates. Luckily, I don't.
|21 members and 7,993 guests|
|AngelicaParedes45 , Childrenareawesome , danzergurl00 , holistic5 , katelove , Leelee3 , manyhatsmom , mercadolibre519 , quiltermom , redsally , Sara Tobosa , sciencemum , shantimama , SherryGonzales , StarsFall , thefragile7393 , transylvania_mom , Vanessa Garrido|
|Most users ever online was 449,755, 06-25-2014 at 12:21 PM.|