I'd much rather see her speak than some of the others out there. Would really like seeing her as a headliner at conferences.
DS1: 2/02 DD: 9/04 DS2: 9/07 and EDD: 11/13
Dp and I just watched this last night. It was awesome. I searched for a reference to it because if there wasn't one, I was going to post one. :) Now I can just bump.
I also thought I wouldn't watch the whole thing, but like others, I wanted more when it was over. I also really loved that she stuck to her convictions when she was implicitly implored to set aside her well-reasoned, well-expressed judgments. I enjoy rationally principled people, whether or not I agree with them; I am inspired by people whose personal integrity is made manifest. :)
Well, I've been absent for 8 months, and during that time, it turns out that I have completely transformed. You are all precious. Thank you for being here and sharing your lives. You are truly a gift. Jan. 23, 2012
I enjoyed her talk, but I thought she did a poor job of answering questions. The usual issues were raised regarding socialization, education level of the parents, supporting adult children who were presumably unprepared to support themselves, etc. I thought her answers were vague and not very encouraging for unschooling. For example, someone asked about whether "blue collar" parents could unschool. She didn't really point out the assumption here that the parents are going to be teachers, she didn't address that well, and sort of hummed and hawed about it. Someone mentioned how her home must have had lots of books and musical instruments and what if another family couldn't afford that or didn't have those things. Um, libraries? Music lessons? Again she was vague. So while I thought she'd be a good example of an unschooled life, I don't think she'd make for a good speaker at places other than where people already understand and embrace unschooling and are simply perhaps looking for examples of unschooled grownups who are capable, intelligent, and well-spoken.
Homeschooling, Homesteading Mama to DD ('02) and DS ('04)
I don't think she ordinarily speaks about unschooling. I think she brought up issues with equitable access to information and opportunity that unschoolers typically ignore. That's what struck me. I haven't watched in awhile.
I do recall liking that she just said what she thought as though it were perfectly normal and acceptable. She spoke as though what she presented was the obvious truth. It made me not question what she was saying. Of course, I agree with her, so that probably doesn't help that as an argument!
Thanks for posting this video.
Well-spoken - yes she is! It was a pleasure to listen to her and I would have enjoyed another hour as well.
I don't think she aimed to convince anyone to unschool. She clearly stated that it worked for her family and that she enjoyed it, was grateful for the experience. But she also raised critical questions, and I appreciated her honesty on that front.
Libraries are wonderful and most hs / us families couldn't manage with out them. But they don't necessarily play all the roles that an educated parent would be able to, even if (or esp if) that educated parent was largely hands-off and zen. I think that uneducated parents, esp if they have self-taught themselves something that they enjoy doing can facilitate as well or better than an educated one. But there are also a lot of parents, whether educated or not, who are compelled to work long hours in dreary jobs and they may face certain disadvantages when it comes to the kind of trusting facilitation that helps unschooling to thrive. I am really just thinking aloud here.
I disagree. I found her talk quite inspiring and kind of want to protect her from the Unschooling Establishment. While unschooling conferences are great fun, one also encounters sometimes the evangelical drive and the pep-rally atmosphere. I think it may actually be better to have talks like this in the general audience rather than among very much like-minded crowds.