This is a subject on which I have heard conflicting views, and I have no firsthand knowledge at all. A doctor who practiced in Indiana for more than 40 years said that among th Amish he served that he never delivered a baby whose parents didn't ask for a circumcision and that almost all the adult Amish men in his practice were circumcised before they became his patients. I have heard the same thing about Amish in Northern Ohio, the source being a midwife who practices there. On the other hand, I have also been told that other Amish groups to not cirucmcise at all. COuld it be that it varies according to where the Amish community is? A few months ago I went thorugh everything I could find on the Amish online and could find not a single reference that gave any idnication one way or the other.