I'm not in Jasper now, but I had to respond because my husband and I are originally from Jasper (he was born there, I was an early transplant). We moved to Bloomington after we married. 90% of our family and friends are still in Jasper or B-town. :-)
Anyway, surprisingly for such a small town (albeit one that has experienced growth over the years), there is a small but strong AP community. The non AP community will accept you if you don't back down and don't argue with them. (Even with the influx of "outsiders", there is still a strong German American contingent, and they are notoriously stubborn).
GL with your move, wherever it takes you!
Amanda and Dh, ds 09/00, ds 08/03, ds 10/05, and ds 05/08, and 3 :